-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Amazon Yakuza/Like a Dragon - First trailer
- Thread starter Gp1
- Start date
ForAcademicPurposes
Member
Didn't Miike Takashi make a movie like this in the 90s?
Hrk69
Member
i hope they dun have turn based battle
HAYA8U5A
Member
If you are talking specifically based on the video game series it was 2007.
If you are talking Yakuza in general then yeah he had some in the 90's and I would guess you are thinking something like Dead or Alive but he has made a lot of Yakuza movies. Yakuza movies are very common in general. Especially in the 60's and 70's when they were pumping out a ton of them which is why I am surprised the video game series never had a spin-off in that time frame as a homage to those films.
‐-------------
This teaser didn't show much so impossible to get a feel for it until a full trailer. Not overly optimistic but that could just be the usual expecting the worst from a video game adaptation even if Amazon are coming off one of the few good ones.
FunkMiller
Member
Gritty is precisely the wrong tone to be using for a Yakuza adaptation. Let's hope it's a lot more playful and weird than this trailer seems to indicate. Suck all of the fun stuff out of the games and they wouldn't be half as good as they are.
deriks
4-Time GIF/Meme God
Let's see your review of the show in comparison with someone who plays since ever, like myself
I hope all the episodes get released in the same day
rubik's dude
Member
Awful trailer, the show looks ugly and cheap, and Kiryu was a complete miscast. Made by a bunch of people that never played the games for an audience that never asked for this.
The games are already episodic like a TV series, and the character models are some of the most detailed in gaming. You can see their fucking pores most of the time. This is the last series that needed a live action adaptation.
The games are already episodic like a TV series, and the character models are some of the most detailed in gaming. You can see their fucking pores most of the time. This is the last series that needed a live action adaptation.
NecrosaroIII
Ultimate DQ Fan
I wonder what a gritty take on Ichiban would look like
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Yikes
Hrk69
Member
Yikes
The Cockatrice
I'm retarded?
Yikes
I dont think western journalistic farts are the target audience for such a show.
March Climber
Member
This could be another Cowboy Bebop situation instead.
I thought the live action CB was a fun show with style that, if it were named literally anything else, could have had better reviews and impressions than what it ended up with. That's how I'm going to treat this Yakuza show when I watch it.
These studios just play with fire every time they decide to name these projects after cult classics.
a multicultural team of v
Member
The Yakuza movie that came out a while ago is actually kind of stupidly fun if you just consider it some weird spinoff in a vacuum.
This however I have very little hope for, unfortunately... I'll give a watch this weekend though and see how bad it gets.
This however I have very little hope for, unfortunately... I'll give a watch this weekend though and see how bad it gets.
xrnzaaas
Member
I don't think fans of the video game series are either.
rubik's dude
Member
Is one of those changes Majima using more masculine honorifics for Kiryu? With the pasty twigboy they got, Majima calling him Kiryu-chan doesn't really work as a joke anymore.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Jack Videogames
Member
Watched the first episode today
Is it bad? No. But is it Yakuza? Also no. The show is like somebody was given a rough outline of the plot of the first game and some incomplete character profiles and was told to fill the gaps as they liked. Sometimes it felt more like Kurohyou than Yakuza.
Luckily thanks to this disconnect I was able to turn off the part of my brain that was telling me that something I cherished was being desecrated before my eyes and I was able to watch most of the episode for what it was: a watchable crime drama that would probably have scored like 10 or 15 points more if it wasn't associated with LaD
Is it bad? No. But is it Yakuza? Also no. The show is like somebody was given a rough outline of the plot of the first game and some incomplete character profiles and was told to fill the gaps as they liked. Sometimes it felt more like Kurohyou than Yakuza.
Luckily thanks to this disconnect I was able to turn off the part of my brain that was telling me that something I cherished was being desecrated before my eyes and I was able to watch most of the episode for what it was: a watchable crime drama that would probably have scored like 10 or 15 points more if it wasn't associated with LaD
March Climber
Member
I just watched the first 2 episodes. My advice is to take
Jack Videogames
advice and turn off that part of your brain that heavily associates this with Yakuza/LAD.It's not too late to do so since you're only on episode 1, and you'll have a much better time with it because it won't upset you with all of the changes.
Dazraell
Member
I haven't seen Majima yet, he wasn't in the episode 1 and beginning of episode 2. And I'm not sure if I even want to watch remaining two episodes lol But yeah, that looked so weird on a trailer
Yeah, I'm not in a camp that says adaptations always should be direct 1:1 to source material, but I feel they should at least try to keep the spirit of it. Every change I saw so far feels significantly worse than how it was handled in the game. Kiryu's actor unfortunately also doesn't have the same presence and charisma like his character has in games. Shows version is very forgettable so far. Nishiki's change is also portrayed really funny, the 2005 version looks like just the same kid but in a suit lol
It's kinda like with Netflix's Witcher TV series. You recognize characters, places and some story beats, but story is so warped and changed that it kinda loses the meaning of the original. I agree, it's best to not approach it as an adaptation. But problem is that I don't think this stands on its own even with detaching from the IP as a lot of story beats so far were between meh to midI just watched the first 2 episodes. My advice is to take
It's not too late to do so since you're only on episode 1, and you'll have a much better time with it because it won't upset you with all of the changes.
Jack Videogames
Member
Ellie, we truly are the last of us
Soltype
Member
"He really is like a dragon"
BaneIsPain
Member
a bit disappointed. could’ve been its own story without using yakuza name. oh, well.
I am watching this right now (second episode) and I have played most of the games. So far I think the show is taking itself too seriously. Taking the Yakuza name to make a live action sets expectations. Why not call it it's own thing and change the names? From what I remember, this is pretty loosely based on the games, like the characters were there, it takes place in Japan, and the Tower storyline was in the game.
I would have taken the chance and called it something different. Take the money it cost them in licensing to do better advertising and more story line investment.
It also has also been quite some time since I played the games...
I would have taken the chance and called it something different. Take the money it cost them in licensing to do better advertising and more story line investment.
It also has also been quite some time since I played the games...
March Climber
Member
I guess for me the difference between this and Witcher is that this show is still in a 'real world' setting enough for me to consider it yet another gang/crime show.
It is very hard for someone to look at Witcher like it's something else because the setting is fantasy and it heavily depended on concepts from that fantasy series.