• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Edge December 2024 - Scores

tommib

Gold Member
80_articlefull.jpg


Metaphor: ReFantazio
Metaphor is a game that isn't quite like anything else, even Persona
9

Silent Hill 2
It's a state of mind, and it waits for us to return
8

Life Is Strange: Double Exposure
Clever character writing spreads throughout
8

Unknown 9: Awakening
derivative and crudely executed
4

Neva
Neva is never as effective as we might have feared
7

Redacted
Redacted makes no apology
8

Ara: History Untold
ultimately falling short of glory
6

Europa
you're stuck in the mud
5

Vendetta Forever
a quickfire format, squeezing in so many little ideas that you'll lose track of where each has been borrowed from
8

Phoenix Springs
a frustrating match for what is nominally a detective story
5

Wilmot Works It Out
the drive to complete a picture remains strong
7
 
Last edited:

cormack12

Gold Member
Clever character writing spreads throughout

Uh Oh Wow GIF by Bounce


Errrrr, no. So far I'd say the storyline/plot is the much bigger strength with a lot of nostalgia too.

Can't argue with the score though, I'm only halfway through and it's prob a 7.5 atm so might elevate.

Some of the character writing especially in messages, journal and crosstalk is poor to average imo. Let alone some weird turns in the actual characters themselves.
 
Top Bottom