Support NeoGAF

[DenchDeckard]

I just wrapped up my playthrough on Jedi Survivor and I gotta say it was a really great enjoyable Star Wars game.

I played through on Series X and waited until the majority of patches were out to ensure I could get a more or less solid 60FPS. Gameplay was absolutely brilliant. Thoroughly enjoyable. The lightsaber fighting was a little mashy at times but still more than serviceable.

Where this game really shined was the traversal! I absolutely loved it! awesome metroid style and once I had all the powers I felt like an absolute bad ass! - I more or less 100 percented it but game up on all the chests as it was a bit cack trhat these were just cosmetics, which gets onto the negatives.

Negatives, are some hokey writing and a less than great skill tree plus the abundance of cosmetics hidden away.

So, overall. Brilliant. I'll give it a solid 8.5 pushing to a 9 if you are a big Star Wars fan, like myself!

Well worth a playthrough in my opinion!

 

[Portugeezer]

Did you play the first game? Is this one as difficult? (I played the first one on easy because I just wanted a dumb scifi world to explore)

 

[pxlwrld]

Great time all around. Played on PC myself and with a couple of mods its performance woes are more ore less tolerable. Agree with everything you said, my only gripe with it was the hit-or-miss hitboxes. Some hard hitting enemies really should have been staggered sometimes by my strikes, especially in cross guard stance. It became frustrating sometimes.

 

[violence]

I know I’m not buying this on PC. It’s currently $35 on PSN. I was debating whether to get now or wait. Looks like I’ll get it now.

 

[Nankatsu]

Yeah, game is really good.
Even though I played at launch I had a blast with it.

Plot twist is really well executed in my opinion. To me Cal Kestis and this narrative currently carry the Star Wars franchise in terms of big medium.

 

[Big Baller]

One of the best SW games out there. Put in 60 hours.

 

[cormack12]

This is number 3 in my list after Alan wake 2 then mirage. I enjoyed the first game aside from some bullshit. Hoping they fixed it in the new game.

Did they improve that map? And the fast travel points for the end of the level?

 

[The Shepard]

Did you play the first game? Is this one as difficult? (I played the first one on easy because I just wanted a dumb scifi world to explore)

I'd say it's easier, completed myself just before Xmas and is the better game imo.

 

[King Dazzar]

I just wrapped up my playthrough on Jedi Survivor and I gotta say it was a really great enjoyable Star Wars game.

I played through on Series X and waited until the majority of patches were out to ensure I could get a more or less solid 60FPS. Gameplay was absolutely brilliant. Thoroughly enjoyable. The lightsaber fighting was a little mashy at times but still more than serviceable.

Where this game really shined was the traversal! I absolutely loved it! awesome metroid style and once I had all the powers I felt like an absolute bad ass! - I more or less 100 percented it but game up on all the chests as it was a bit cack trhat these were just cosmetics, which gets onto the negatives.

Negatives, are some hokey writing and a less than great skill tree plus the abundance of cosmetics hidden away.

So, overall. Brilliant. I'll give it a solid 8.5 pushing to a 9 if you are a big Star Wars fan, like myself!

Well worth a playthrough in my opinion!

Its on my to do list. Good to hear that you didnt encounter anything major technically. I only played the first 5 mins on PS5 but my initial impressions were very good.

 

[CartesianMan]

7/10 - it's an OK game nothing special. The main character remains bland and highly punchable.

 

[StereoVsn]

Is it still shit on PC? I actually have the EA store copy from AMD promo but was waiting for it to get patched up.

Otherwise will buy a used copy for PS or Xbox at some point.

 

[Big Baller]

Ill never get the hate for Cal. He even has a romance with Merrin, have you seen her ass?

 

[Topher]

This is number 3 in my list after Alan wake 2 then mirage. I enjoyed the first game aside from some bullshit. Hoping they fixed it in the new game.

Did they improve that map? And the fast travel points for the end of the level?

The map is still a confused mess. Worst part of the game, imo, especially for those like me trying to track down collectibles for trophies.

 

[Topher]

7/10 - it's an OK game nothing special. The main character remains bland and highly punchable.

But now you can give him a mullet so….

 

[Punished Miku]

I'm looking forward to it on GP. I thought the 1st game was really good.

 

[Majormaxxx]

I just wrapped up my playthrough on Jedi Survivor and I gotta say it was a really great enjoyable Star Wars game.

I played through on Series X and waited until the majority of patches were out to ensure I could get a more or less solid 60FPS. Gameplay was absolutely brilliant. Thoroughly enjoyable. The lightsaber fighting was a little mashy at times but still more than serviceable.

Where this game really shined was the traversal! I absolutely loved it! awesome metroid style and once I had all the powers I felt like an absolute bad ass! - I more or less 100 percented it but game up on all the chests as it was a bit cack trhat these were just cosmetics, which gets onto the negatives.

Negatives, are some hokey writing and a less than great skill tree plus the abundance of cosmetics hidden away.

So, overall. Brilliant. I'll give it a solid 8.5 pushing to a 9 if you are a big Star Wars fan, like myself!

Well worth a playthrough in my opinion!

I finished fallen order recently. Lookin forward to it. Did you play fallen order?

 

[Luipadre]

Finished it a few weeks ago. Game is still felt like it held together with ducktapes on PS5, cant imagine the launch version. Story was bad, villains were boring. Level design was great and the platforming, altho it was too much sometimes. Combat was still as jank as ever. Overall it was decent

 

[tommib]

Ill never get the hate for Cal. He even has a romance with Merrin, have you seen her ass?

And have you seen Cal’s ass…

 

[Chuck Berry]

The map is still a confused mess. Worst part of the game, imo, especially for those like me trying to track down collectibles for trophies.

The fast travel sorta makes it better

....But not really

 

[DenchDeckard]

Did you play the first game? Is this one as difficult? (I played the first one on easy because I just wanted a dumb scifi world to explore)

I finished fallen order recently. Lookin forward to it. Did you play fallen order?

Yup, completed fallen order and this is better in every way imo.

Big scale, awesome use of environments and some great extra challenges to dig into.

Oh, as someone else said. Let me add my annoyances of hit boxes and deffo pressing up to heal, the game triggering the voice queue of " bd I need a stim" even doing the animation sometimes but it not triggering the heal!

Very annoying in difficult side content boss fights.

Apart from that, awesome game!

I really like what they did with Cal I'm this one and can't wait to see what happens in the third installment!

 

[analog_future]

It's a phenomenal game and if it weren't for the performance/bugs issues, it would've been right in the middle of the GOTY conversation IMO,.

 

[Švejk]

Just picked this up yesterday myself. Really enjoyed the first one, so I can't wait to dive into this one.

 

[yamaci17]

It's a phenomenal game and if it weren't for the performance/bugs issues, it would've been right in the middle of the GOTY conversation IMO,.

it really wouldn't though. super forgettable cliché story
there's some character build up yeah but again, it literally is a placeholder story

it is like rogue one but without any satisfying end

overall game is good , very fun gameplay (this part can be in the goty conversation), creative map design, and some sequences are legit goty tier. but then again, all of it breaks apart due to non existent story. I already forgot about it. there were some good moments I remember about but overall the whole tanalorr storyline and leading up to it and the eventual result... it just so much feels like a placeholder story

which it is. but could've been much more.

 

[Chuck Berry]

How and why in the FUCK is this game 150 gigs to download? It’s bigger than Red Dead, bigger than Witcher 3, GTAV etc. I just don’t get it.

 

[diffusionx]

Just finished this on PS5. I thought it was overall good, but the combat and exploration are not quite as good as they should have been. The combat feels really messy later in the game when they are throwing melee and ranged enemies at you, pressing up to heal doesn't always trigger a stim, sometimes the environment is too cluttered and it's not at all clear what the next step is, map is a travesty, all this stuff. It also still has technical problems. I played it on PS5 and had my fair share of crashes, texture loading issues, frame rate problems, etc. Really needed another 3-6 months of development and could have been a classic. It seems like EA doesn't care anymore. I did like the story though.

 

[Kindela]

Chiming in since I'm some 30 hours in. It's as good as the first one I'd say, slightly better due to more movement and combat options.

Really like the traversal and my only complaint about it is that it's not a bit more challenging, akin to the Prince of Persia games.

The combat, on the other hand, can be a hit or miss. It's excellent when it's one on one, but only if the enemy is not a red attack spammer. In group fights, it's almost always messy. It just doesn't seem designed for such encounters. I think that no animation cancelling kills it the most.
There's a fight in an area called Imperial post, where you have to fight like 3-4 waves of enemies. You're spammed by rocketeers, basic imps, tanky droids and you constantly have a feeling you're barely surviving, not playing methodically.

 

[Trilobit]

Playing it right now and loving it. It improves on everything from Fallen Order, maybe except for the villains. But the gameplay is much more polished and I love the saloon.

I have one thing that bothers me every time though. A character referred to their pet bird as "them". Why not call it "it"? Has Star Wars erased genders now? I also hear stormtroopers saying that "they are around" when speaking about me. Do they mean me and my droid or am I genderless too? Each time I'm pulled out from the game and I feel like I'm traversing a California university instead.

 

[Nankatsu]

Playing it right now and loving it. It improves on everything from Fallen Order, maybe except for the villains. But the gameplay is much more polished and I love the saloon.

 

[The Cockatrice]

 

[Trilobit]

Ssssh! Don't spoil me, I've just beaten the Thanos wannabe so I'm not done with the game yet!

 

[SyberWolf]

the game overall was ok. but the performance and bugs was terrible at launch. i didnt beat the game until a few patches later that improved the performance a bit on PC.

 

[Trilobit]

I just finished it and it's now one of my favourite Star Wars media under the Disney era. Very good story and I was completely immersed to the end. The part with Merrin where you fight with her on Jedha had my heart pumping furiously. I highly recommend it to anyone who enjoyed the first game.

I also read that there's a third game in development which makes me very pumped!

This is the canon Cal Kestis hair and facial hair style and no one's gonna convince me otherwise, it fit his character perfectly.

 

[Big Baller]

 

[yamaci17]

I just finished it and it's now one of my favourite Star Wars media under the Disney era. Very good story and I was completely immersed to the end. The part with Merrin where you fight with her on Jedha had my heart pumping furiously. I highly recommend it to anyone who enjoyed the first game.

I also read that there's a third game in development which makes me very pumped!

This is the canon Cal Kestis hair and facial hair style and no one's gonna convince me otherwise, it fit his character perfectly.

jedha chase was peak gaming! memorable unforgettable sequence for sure

 

[Trilobit]

jedha chase was peak gaming! memorable unforgettable sequence for sure

It was so insanely good that I would have been completely satisfied with the game had it ended there. The build up to it and then when the madness was unleashed oh boy! I was immersed 300% and thought to myself "This is why I play games!!" I also had the jedi clothes during that time so it made it even better.

I hope they knock the sequel out of the ballpark, but I'll be there day one no matter what.

 

[jonnyp]

Completely mediocre experience.