• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

what happened to mk1 female fighters design

PlayofSparta

PlayofSparta

Gold Member
Mileena

manuel-robles-b4.jpg

ahhCblr.jpg


Sindel

9txgb40x7wkb1.jpg

Trailer-emocionante-de-Mortal-Kombat-1-com-Sindel-e-General-Shao.jpg.webp


Kitana

Kitana-MK11-Unmasked-the-ladies-of-mortal-kombat-43077060-1324-1152.jpg

fa6qlzd58xdb1.jpg


Tanya
legiao_fgXlvAjnqwTkyiP27K5E4huN3aeUQpJOx1HzYLbcB0.png.webp

sXm2E40T_400x400.jpg


Li Mei and Ashrah look great at least. But is strange such designs, when the men from the roster are way more good looking.
 
RagnarokIV

RagnarokIV

Battlebus imprisoning me \m/ >.< \m/
M

Montauk

Member
RagnarokIV said:
www.eurogamer.net

Balancing Mortal Kombat 1's violence and enabling monetised streaming is a "dilemma", creator says

Mortal Kombat creator Ed Boon has called the balance between delivering the violence fans want and the need to sanitise…
www.eurogamer.net www.eurogamer.net



MK is long dead, mate.
Click to expand...

Because of the possibility of an optional gore switch, in order to get around how that limits the games spread in certain arenas?

What a ridiculous comment.

The appeal and benefit of that is obvious and it would in no way impact your desire to see all the gore and violence.
 
Last edited:
Alexios

Alexios

Cores, shaders and BIOS oh my!
Would all of them except maybe Tanya (in your "before" version too). Clothes design isn't great but that's never been a MK strong point save for a couple iconic looks like the classic ninjas or Raiden.
PlayofSparta said:
the men from the roster are way more good looking.
Click to expand...
kunonabi said:
if the men weren't all super attractive
Click to expand...
I mean, that's a personal preference, not much game devs can do about that, you like what you like.
 
Last edited:
kunonabi

kunonabi

Member
Eh, Ashrah is a huge downgrade too and Li Mei has the same generic Asian face that Sindel and Kitana have. Tanya is still the worst of the bunch but Tanya sucks regardless so I find it hard to really care one way or the other. I don't mind them going for more natural looks after how excessive MK9 was but they're definitely aiming to downplay the women as much as possible. It wouldnt stand out as much if the men weren't all super attractive and as super jacked as can be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Isa
M

Montauk

Member
STARSBarry said:
They changed Sonya a bit too...
L1cucQ5.jpg


9VnZGP9.png
Click to expand...

So she’s been turned from a cartoon into a still slim and fit still very conventionally attractive much more realistic looking woman that is dressed like the original design?

Wow. What a truly devastating blow.

What, you’re acting like she’s hideous now because she doesn’t have equally massive tits?

Would you reject this athlete-level blonde woman in real life?
 
Last edited:
STARSBarry

STARSBarry

Gold Member
Rudius said:
Massive downgrade in mammary potential.
Click to expand...

DemonGamerTTT said:
This change is fine the character looks a lot like the original... The old lady from MK11 was the problem.
Click to expand...

Montauk said:
So she’s been turned from a cartoon into a still slim and fit still very conventionally attractive much more realistic looking woman that is dressed like the original design?

Wow. What a truly devastating blow.

What, you’re acting like she’s hideous now because she doesn’t have equally massive tits?

Would you reject this athlete-level blonde woman in real life?
Click to expand...

We go from someone having a laugh at how awful the early Sonia models where.

Someone telling us quite rightly that Sonia is MK11 is terrible (but at least it matches the terrible voice actor)

To finally being told what my tastes in women should be and asserting that only the current Sonia can be seen as attractive as a universal truth that all men must align to.

I love this place.
 
M

Montauk

Member
STARSBarry said:
We go from someone having a laugh at how awful the early Sonia models where.

Someone telling us quite rightly that Sonia is MK11 is terrible (but at least it matches the terrible voice actor)

To finally being told what my tastes in women should be and asserting that only the current Sonia can be seen as attractive as a universal truth that all men must align to.

I love this place.
Click to expand...

It’s the opposite problem. I haven’t said you have to find her attractive. But I am challenging to explain the insinuation that she’s ugly.

I mean we’re gonna get loads of guys coming in here to state as if it were indisputable fact that these women are hideous (Jesus Christ all of them are way dramatically slimmer than most Americans), aren’t we?
 
M

Montauk

Member
STARSBarry said:
We go from someone having a laugh at how awful the early Sonia models where.

Someone telling us quite rightly that Sonia is MK11 is terrible (but at least it matches the terrible voice actor)

To finally being told what my tastes in women should be and asserting that only the current Sonia can be seen as attractive as a universal truth that all men must align to.

I love this place.
Click to expand...

Did you love the comments bluntly declaring all these women uggos? Does that make you love this place, because that’s what I’m talking about?

Funny you didn’t quote those ones, isn’t it?
 
Last edited:
Luigi Mario

Luigi Mario

Member
While I think most of the female characters already had questionable designs in MK11, especially Frost and Skarlet, every MK1 design in your comparison is a downgrade.
 
March Climber

March Climber

Member
It would help if these screenshots weren’t YouTube compressed blurry messes.

Regardless, I’ll review this fairly.

Mileena = better
Sindel = same
Kitana = worse
Tanya = better

Idk what happened with Kitana but she gives me the ‘modern mom’ image, especially with those high waisted leggings and that top. It’s weird and a gigantic downgrade. The designs for the rest are better and Sindel keeps being treated with the best care in both beauty and style. I don’t know why that’s a thing either.

The ones who are currently whining about the lack of cleavage will stop caring once they show the alternate outfits. The same thing happened with Street Fighter 6. As for the ones who are complaining about the faces, I only agree that Kitana looks worse. I don’t see any agendas, especially since they’ve greatly improved Mileena and Tanya.
 
ssringo

ssringo

Member
Mileena: decently attractive face, neck looks super long and an ugly outfit. Prefer the short hair on her. Guess she's hiding her real mouth somehow? Or is that shit retconned away? Other than the normal mouth she's fine.

Sindel: looks like an older woman? One with an adult daughter? I dunno. Both versions look fine.

Kitana: decently attractive face that I like more than her MK11 version, ugly outfit and inferior to her MK11 version. It's a wash.

Tanya: is that even the same character? And why such a shitty picture of her? Whatever.

Sonya: Looks good to me. Doesn't need gigantic tits.

I don't really care though. I'll pick up the all-in-one edition in a few years on fanatical for $5 and see what's what for a few hours.
 
kunonabi

kunonabi

Member
March Climber said:
It would help if these screenshots weren’t YouTube compressed blurry messes.

Regardless, I’ll review this fairly.

Mileena = better
Sindel = same
Kitana = worse
Tanya = better

Idk what happened with Kitana but she gives me the ‘modern mom’ image, especially with those high waisted leggings and that top. It’s weird and a gigantic downgrade. The designs for the rest are better and Sindel keeps being treated with the best care in both beauty and style. I don’t know why that’s a thing either.

The ones who are currently whining about the lack of cleavage will stop caring once they show the alternate outfits. The same thing happened with Street Fighter 6. As for the ones who are complaining about the faces, I only agree that Kitana looks worse. I don’t see any agendas, especially since they’ve greatly improved Mileena and Tanya.
Click to expand...

Tanya's new design is all about agenda. Or at the very least appeasing Ed Boon's girlfriend since Jackie is most likely gone.
 
M

Montauk

Member
kunonabi said:
Tanya's new design is all about agenda. Or at the very least appeasing Ed Boon's girlfriend since Jackie is most likely gone.
Click to expand...

Ah damn, he’s got a girlfriend and she’s fucking it all up?

If only he was volcel, like you. Girlfriends just ruin everything. You and the others like you in this thread have got to stay strong and continue resisting the siren call of females.
 
Last edited:
March Climber

March Climber

Member
kunonabi said:
Tanya's new design is all about agenda. Or at the very least appeasing Ed Boon's girlfriend since Jackie is most likely gone.
Click to expand...
I don’t see how giving Tanya a better face and a better outfit is an agenda. That OP image is highly cherry picked to try and even make her look bad, but it barely even works there and it especially doesn’t work the minute you view the trailer.
 
Crayon

Crayon

Member
They intentionally made them look more like er... not all models. I will tell you, plenty of people who are not woke psychos find it refreshing.

It's okay to want sexier characters. If it's enough to weigh on your purchasing descision then consider trying some good fg's instead of mk.
 
ReBurn

ReBurn

Gold Member
Crayon said:
They intentionally made them look more like er... not all models. I will tell you, plenty of people who are not woke psychos find it refreshing.

It's okay to want sexier characters. If it's enough to weigh on your purchasing descision then consider trying some good fg's instead of mk.
Click to expand...
Seriously. Mai is still bouncy in KOF XV. Folks can turn on training mode and watch her sway in standing position to an infinite timer until they finish whatever it was they turned the game on for.
 
Crayon

Crayon

Member
ReBurn said:
Seriously. Mai is still bouncy in KOF XV. Folks can turn on training mode and watch her sway in standing position to an infinite timer until they finish whatever it was they turned the game on for.
Click to expand...

I just did last weekend. She was wobbling this way and that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

The Mortal Kombat 1 Full Roster Has Been Leaked
Rumor
19
2K
BennyBlanco replied
The Electric Underground | Street Fighter III: 3rd Strike is Peak Arcade Design | Why It Endures
Opinion Retro Trailer
8
1K
NeverYouMind replied
  • Poll
SF6 vs Moron Kombat 1 vs Tekken 8
2
77
7K
Area61 replied
Shift Up CEO says his Stellar Blade and NIKKE character designs come from “following his instincts”
Game Dev 2
88
6K
Synastry replied
First time you realized Japanese devs were GOAT?
Drama Retro Game Dev 2 3
118
3K
Spukc replied
Top Bottom