UK Supreme Court rules legal definition of a woman is based on biological sex

Status
Not open for further replies.
RetroGamingUK

RetroGamingUK

Member
www.bbc.co.uk

UK Supreme Court rules legal definition of a woman is based on biological sex - live updates

Judges say the "concept of sex is binary" while cautioning that the landmark ruling should not be seen as victory of one side over another.
www.bbc.co.uk www.bbc.co.uk

Purple forum advocating violence over this already.

I respect and sympathise with people suffering from gender dysphoria, but the whole "trans women are women" and legal confusion we had going on in this country needed to stop.

Common sense has prevailed.
 
Last edited:
Good, finally rationality on this issue has been prescribed at the highest legal level. And the purple forum seems full of trans terrorist at this point. Someone in the UK should report the site to officials (seriously).
 
Reading the Purple Forum thread. Peak comedy, these people do not engage with the real world.

Normies outnumber terminally online like 10:1. Keep crying. Trans people deserve to be respected but the push for it all to be merged together is insanity. Know your place.
 
TBH this is a tricky part. The key is the "legal" part, I would think with legal text and classification you want to avoid ambiguity and subjectivity as much as possible. Doing it differently opens a whole can of worms e.g. someone will say they are a woman one day, a man a week later in order to exploit the legal system.
 
Also, I think people as always are not reading the details. This was what triggered the whole process:
This case first arose when the Scottish government included transgender women in quotas to ensure gender balance on public sector boards.
Click to expand...
You can make a case that someone who was born male and did not face the difficulties of what being a woman is for probably at least 15-20 years of their lives should not be then benefitting from a process that is designed to improve the situations of AFAB. This was btw a very similar position that got JKR in trouble - the idea that fighting for trans women rights risked to marginalise the efforts and actions of biological women.
 
Last edited:
This topic has alienated so many people from the left and ultimately empowered dipshits like Trump. It's a tragic case of a political ideology getting hijacked by uneducated whack jobs with borderline schizophrenia. I hope now we're entering an era of not letting these whiny, unhinged minority of people rule such massive political factions.
 
The Purple Forum seems to think that because of this trans people are now free reign to be annihilated. lmao. If you harshly discriminate against anyone like that in a work place you're gone. Don't get it twisted. Maybe out on the street OUTSIDE of major cities people will give you funny looks, you've gotta be wanting a death wish if you commit to it on a council estate. But that is always gonna happen.
 
Werewolf Jones said:
The Purple Forum seems to think that because of this trans people are now free reign to be annihilated. lmao. If you harshly discriminate against anyone like that in a work place you're gone. Don't get it twisted. Maybe out on the street OUTSIDE of major cities people will give you funny looks, you've gotta be wanting a death wish if you commit to it on a council estate. But that is always gonna happen.
Click to expand...

Saw the news headline and I just had to check on them 😂 absolute hilarious takes over there.
 
Werewolf Jones said:
The Purple Forum seems to think that because of this trans people are now free reign to be annihilated. lmao. If you harshly discriminate against anyone like that in a work place you're gone. Don't get it twisted. Maybe out on the street OUTSIDE of major cities people will give you funny looks, you've gotta be wanting a death wish if you commit to it on a council estate. But that is always gonna happen.
Click to expand...
They're idiots.
 
Werewolf Jones said:
The Purple Forum seems to think that because of this trans people are now free reign to be annihilated. lmao. If you harshly discriminate against anyone like that in a work place you're gone. Don't get it twisted. Maybe out on the street OUTSIDE of major cities people will give you funny looks, you've gotta be wanting a death wish if you commit to it on a council estate. But that is always gonna happen.
Click to expand...

Conversely now that it's been settled it'll become less of a contentious issue, this could result in less discrimination in some cases.
 
Crazy that such a thing is even necessary to be solved by a fucking court, lmao. But whatever, at least the outcome is positive.
 
Last edited:
My question is: is the Gender Recognition Certificate awarded based on you "identifying" as a given gender, or does it require e.g. gender re-assignment surgery? Because if the first one I can easily see the problem.
 
Werewolf Jones said:
The Purple Forum seems to think that because of this trans people are now free reign to be annihilated. lmao. If you harshly discriminate against anyone like that in a work place you're gone. Don't get it twisted. Maybe out on the street OUTSIDE of major cities people will give you funny looks, you've gotta be wanting a death wish if you commit to it on a council estate. But that is always gonna happen.
Click to expand...
The purple forum is fucking retarded.

No one is saying trans people should be harmed or attacked. No one deserves to be abused based on their beliefs however irrational they are, as long as they aren't harming others.

They simply aren't women.

Don't like it? Cry moar.
 
CompleteGlobalSaturation said:
The purple forum is fucking retarded.

No one is saying trans people should be harmed or attacked. No one deserves to be abused based on their beliefs however irrational they are, as long as they aren't harming others.

They simply aren't women.

Don't like it? Cry moar.
Click to expand...

The thread on "trans genocide" is hilarious.

There's a section on the term "genocide" that's completely clueless about the term "existence".
 
RetroGamingUK said:
The thread on "trans genocide" is hilarious.

There's a section on the term "genocide" that's completely clueless about the term "existence".
Click to expand...

Choice quote I found on the thread: "honestly, if we end up living in a world like that... I'd rather burn it to the ground."

Oh look, they're advocating violence/terrorism.

Make-Up Meme GIF by Justin
 
Last edited:
Klosshufvud said:
This topic has alienated so many people from the left and ultimately empowered dipshits like Trump. It's a tragic case of a political ideology getting hijacked by uneducated whack jobs with borderline schizophrenia. I hope now we're entering an era of not letting these whiny, unhinged minority of people rule such massive political factions.
Click to expand...

Purple forum types despise cunt Trump with every fibre of their being, and yet they continually fail to realise it is they who literally got him elected. Absolute dickheads.
 
The fact things have gone this far on such idiocy genuinely makes me sick. I know the US did some executive orders, but things still need to be more defined with our courts. Not sure what is in the works.

In any case, there's one chapter in one land closed at least
 
Werewolf Jones said:
The Purple Forum seems to think that because of this trans people are now free reign to be annihilated. lmao. If you harshly discriminate against anyone like that in a work place you're gone. Don't get it twisted. Maybe out on the street OUTSIDE of major cities people will give you funny looks, you've gotta be wanting a death wish if you commit to it on a council estate. But that is always gonna happen.
Click to expand...
I have never seen a single person call for "trans people to be annihilated." Even people against this gender ideology want them to get the help they need, which they have not been getting for 10 years.
 
diffusionx said:
I have never seen a single person call for "trans people to be annihilated." Even people against this gender ideology want them to get the help they need, which they have not been getting for 10 years.
Click to expand...

The help is the difficult part

The brain area size issue relies on MRI scans and is inconclusive. And then the purple forum crazies whine that the MRI scans would be descriminative.

When the cause or mental health many GPs these days are reluctant to go down that route.

Then there's the solutions, many are sold the idea (through social media) that "transitioning" will solve all their problems, when in many cases it just makes things worse (most of society just won't accept them as women regardless of legal status).

At least the court ruling brings clarity in order to better inform future decisions.
 
Klosshufvud said:
This topic has alienated so many people from the left and ultimately empowered dipshits like Trump. It's a tragic case of a political ideology getting hijacked by uneducated whack jobs with borderline schizophrenia. I hope now we're entering an era of not letting these whiny, unhinged minority of people rule such massive political factions.
Click to expand...
DirtInUrEye said:
Purple forum types despise cunt Trump with every fibre of their being, and yet they continually fail to realise it is they who literally got him elected. Absolute dickheads.
Click to expand...

Yes, it is even more obvious that these people are crazy than it is obvious that Trump isn't your friend, which is impressive.

CompleteGlobalSaturation said:
No one deserves to be abused based on their beliefs however irrational they are, as long as they aren't harming others.
Click to expand...

I hope MAGA got this memo.
 
Great Auk said:
What is the Purple Forum? I never heard of it.
Click to expand...
Not sure if you're being serious or sarcastic. Oh well if serious they're talking about Resetera. Its a video game forum that split off from this one. They have a politics forum that is so left wing you'll wonder if it's parody. Of course the part that sticks out to me is how many people on that forum claim to be experts and leaders in their field yet don't know basic stuff. (You know, like having people claiming to be lawyers and prosecutor in the US but not know what the 10th amendment is.) So many there claim to be superlative. (Such as their "what's your height thread" where pretty much a huge portion were over 6' 2")
 
dave_d said:
Not sure if you're being serious or sarcastic. Oh well if serious they're talking about Resetera. Its a video game forum that split off from this one. They have a politics forum that is so left wing you'll wonder if it's parody. Of course the part that sticks out to me is how many people on that forum claim to be experts and leaders in their field yet don't know basic stuff. (You know, like having people claiming to be lawyers and prosecutor in the US but not know what the 10th amendment is.) So many there claim to be superlative. (Such as their "what's your height thread" where pretty much a huge portion were over 6' 2")
Click to expand...

Thanks for the info. I legit did not know what Purple Forum was lol. You did not waste your time so I thank you!

Sounds like a place I would hate haha
 
Werewolf Jones said:
Reading the Purple Forum thread. Peak comedy, these people do not engage with the real world.
Click to expand...

Imagine if these people were just chill and cool people with differences, accepting their differences. Everyone would have a much easier time to like them. I like all chill and cool trans people.
But instead of being chill and cool, most of them have chosen to be fanatic, close-minded, obnoxious assholes. This is not the right strategy for any minority - or basically any human being - to be liked by others.
 
If you want to pretend to be something you are not that is fine, and probably a little weird to me, but don't make me enter into your pretending with you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Jussie Smollet’s conviction overturned by Illinois supreme court
38
2K
Drake replied
UK Woman convicted in first known case of cyber farting
47
3K
MayauMiao replied
Maya Hawke: Hollywood is casting movies based on Instagram followers
2
51
3K
Toons replied
Cream - Outside Woman Blues
1
417
HRK69 replied
an Illegal immigrant just set a sleeping woman on fire on a New York subway
2
64
5K
thefool replied
Top Bottom