Ended up buying it last night. That's $24.99 I wish I had back.
Far be it from me to insult darling Eggers, but the movie is kind of an interesting mess--but mostly a mess. At times there's incredible imagery and savagery, and then there are times when the whole thing just rubs me as needlessly self-indulgent and hammy. I did get a huge laugh out of the final sword fight, especially when both men are yelling at each other for what feels like 5 minutes. I don't know why either the director or editor thought that needed to be included to the extent it was, but it did give me some much needed laughter after an emotionally-draining week at work.
With its stunning box office underperformance, I don't see how anyone gives Eggers anything close to 100 million ever again--not without an extremely short leash attached. To be fair, he didn't have the final cut on this one, so was this true to his vision? I kind of think it was, but who knows....
Eggers is going to need a sure-fire hit on his next modestly-priced outing, or his career will experience a stark "re-imagining."
5/10 is my score.