Support NeoGAF

[YesNOnoNOYes]

DAY 7 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Flame_AC (2)
Ourobolus 1796
Spoiled Milk 1862

Ourobolus (0): Spoiled Milk 1769 1862

No active vote for Day 7: *Splinter, Fireblend, Flame_AC, Kawl_USC, zeemumu

Day 7 Postcount: *Splinter 7, Fireblend 20, Flame_AC 26, Kawl_USC 1, Ourobolus 41, Spoiled Milk 11, zeemumu 13


Day 7 ends:

Automated vote tally here

4 votes for majority

 

[Flame_AC]

(Flame_AC) ...
doesn't even care to contribute in the slightest? Every post today was self-defence today, yesterday he did nothing at all and tied the vote in a deceitful way.

Neither of these lynches are scum but I can't see someone else getting pushed into the lead at this point.

Vote: Flame_AC

I'll go with Flame as he has a better chance of being lynched than Crab at this point. Knowing his alignment could help clear up that day 1 vote.

Maybe it's scum hitting scum, but the most consistent people against me in this game (besides you Ouro) have been scum. The posts above are from near the end of Day 2. Personally, I feel like they were somehow frustrated my lynch wasn't gaining steam and for whatever reason wanted me dead, not like I had done all that much at that point in the game. So in hindsight, it does seem pretty clear that the thunderdomer had to have been one of them. Looking at that read list you seem to like:

Town:
2. [m] *Splinter

between:
6. [m] Ouro

Null:
12. [m] zeemumu

Uneasy:
7. [m] Kawl_USC
17. [m] Spoiled Milk
11. [m] Fireblend

Scum:
14. [m] Flame_AC - The end of the day is a very damning fact. No matter how much he highlights not having seen bats vote, that doesn't even matter. He knowingly went into the last minutes that this could happen. That self-awareness post is another aspect. And today there is only self-defending (yeah yeah, one very brief interjection about nin), but in general he didn't contribute anything today or yesterday.

Everyone else's little comments were removed for space, but I feel like Gorlak, as scum wouldn't be bussing me (or any other player) this hard given the thunderdoming ability. What good purpose does it serve?

My lynch has been on the table almost every day this game. Give me one good reason that, after all this push from both Kalor and Gorlak, they decide to throw me in the thunderdome? If they wanted to bus me, they could have put someone else (Spoiled Milk) in the dome, had them lynched, then gone for me again. Then once I flipped, as scum in this magical fantasy world, Gorlak and Kalor come off looking amazing. If I am scum, the play throughout the game makes no sense, not once the thunderdome was on the table.

 

[Spoiled Milk]

I clicked through that first quote because it's a really good point and i want to highlight this exchange.

Neither of these lynches are scum but I can't see someone else getting pushed into the lead at this point.

Vote: Flame_AC

I'll go with Flame as he has a better chance of being lynched than Crab at this point. Knowing his alignment could help clear up that day 1 vote.

Top scum for me are Kalor and CCS.

Reasons? What's with your opinion on Ourobolus? And any chance you'll answer my previous questions?

Gorlak was really quick to jump to Kalor's defense but they were both willing to vote Flame. I just don't think sacrificial lambs were part of their game plan.

And then there's this great gem I'll never forget.

What previous questions? I checked out of this thread yesterday and have been watching The Office.

Classic Milk!
Unvote

 

[Ourobolus]

I'll be honest. I don't have a great read on anyone here.

Vote: Kawl_USC

 

[Spoiled Milk]

Vote: Kawl_USC

 

[*Splinter]

You know who I mostly pushed for on day 1?

CCS

That's neutral teammate CCS.

Gorlak was the first vote on flame, right? i.e. he voted for him when it looked like he wouldn't be lynched? So yeah I don't think the bussing theory is so outlandish. Obviously the flame vote picked up more steam than Gorlak wanted, but the same thing happened with my vote for CCS! (Just for fun, have a look at me begging CCS to give me an excuse to move my vote on day one)

 

[cabot]

DAY 7 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

ourobolus (0)
spoiled milk 1769 (1862)

flame_ac (0)
ourobolus 1796 (1873)
spoiled milk 1862 (1872)

kawl_usc (2)
ourobolus 1873
spoiled milk 1874


Day 7 ends:

Automated vote tally here

4 votes for majority

 

[Fireblend]

Vote: Spoiled Milk

I'm gonna stick to past Fireblend's gut read for now. I'm still reading and not leaving soon, but I think it's good to have my vote reflecting where I'm at right now.

I'm also pretty unsure about everyone right now, specially Kawl and Flame. I think both might be deserving of the win if they're scum. Flame maybe a little more so.

 

[Fireblend]

You know who I mostly pushed for on day 1?

CCS

That's neutral teammate CCS.

Gorlak was the first vote on flame, right? i.e. he voted for him when it looked like he wouldn't be lynched? So yeah I don't think the bussing theory is so outlandish. Obviously the flame vote picked up more steam than Gorlak wanted, but the same thing happened with my vote for CCS! (Just for fun, have a look at me begging CCS to give me an excuse to move my vote on day one)

Doesn't this also fit as an argument for voting for Kawl because of that thunderdome day post where he votes for Gorlak and calls out Kalor?

Ouro, can you walk me through your suspicions of Kawl?

 

[*Splinter]

Doesn't this also fit as an argument for voting for Kawl because of that thunderdome day post where he votes for Gorlak and calls out Kalor?

Ouro, can you walk me through your suspicions of Kawl?

I think the Gorlak lynch completely ruined scum this game. I don't remember how early/late Kawl was but if he made his argument when there were still undecideds I doubt it was a bus.

 

[Fireblend]

I think the Gorlak lynch completely ruined scum this game. I don't remember how early/late Kawl was but if he made his argument when there were still undecideds I doubt it was a bus.

He voted when the vote could go either way. I agree, that was my logic for townreading him most of the game. Good to know I'm not insane. Even if the validation is coming from a neutral

I'd rather vote Flame than Kawl.

 

[Fireblend]

Kawl, your thoughts on Milk vs Flame vs Me?

 

[Flame_AC]

Hey Fireblend. What if we voted for the miller? Just to be completely sure, that and give it another night of kills to narrow down the pool a little bit.

 

[Ourobolus]

Doesn't this also fit as an argument for voting for Kawl because of that thunderdome day post where he votes for Gorlak and calls out Kalor?

Ouro, can you walk me through your suspicions of Kawl?

I am kinda lost when it comes to Milk and Kawl. Neither have really stood out to me either way, though I have a slight Town read on Milk.

Still debating voting for Flame instead

 

[Fireblend]

Hey Fireblend. What if we voted for the miller? Just to be completely sure, that and give it another night of kills to narrow down the pool a little bit.

What. No. If Ouro is scum I'm taking and framing and staring every night longingly at that L.

 

[Spoiled Milk]

I think we should just vote for Kawl. Quiet players make more sense as mafia and his voting pattern doesn't rule him out. There's a higher probability Kawl is scum than there is that Flame was going to be thrown under the bus.

 

[Flame_AC]

The only thing I really want out of the rest of the day is Kawl to come in with a defense of some type.

 

[Ourobolus]

I'm gonna be at a Pride parade soon and likely will have shitty service. Gonna drop my vote here for now, I'll check in if I can to see what's going on and maybe change if I need to.

Vote: Flame_AC

 

[Spoiled Milk]

The only thing I really want out of the rest of the day is Kawl to come in with a defense of some type.

Lynchable offense right there!

 

[Flame_AC]

Lynchable offense right there!

I dunno. I feel like I've tried so hard to survive and have brought up so many interesting points, I can't see how Ouro thinks I am the best choice today.

 

[Ourobolus]

I dunno. I feel like I've tried so hard to survive and have brought up so many interesting points, I can't see how Ouro thinks I am the best choice today.

I am flying by the seat of my pants and this point. Each of the three I think could be scum have done things here and there I find scummy, it's just a matter of hoping I hit scum in that three in two chances

 

[Flame_AC]

D7:
T-N-S
5-1-1 -> No lynch

N7:
4-1-1 -> After night kill

D8:
4-1-1 -> No lynch

N8:
3-1-1 -> After night kill

D9:
3-1-1: Decision day. We could do this, let scum kill two more times and just see what happens, see who drops and let that narrow our decision down for us?

Thoughts, even for just one day?

 

[Fireblend]

My read list is the same right now but I want to see Kawl come in here and say something of value before I switch to Flame (since my Milk vote is going nowhere because I don't know why?).

I'll also be at pride soon but I'm hoping I'll be able to keep up and be here anyway.

 

[Spoiled Milk]

Why wait two days? Just lynch someone today and we'll get to your two days later scenario in half the time.

Your posts are looking really desperate, you know.

 

[Flame_AC]

Why wait two days? Just lynch someone today and we'll get to your two days later scenario in half the time.

Your posts are looking really desperate, you know.

Make scum narrow down the list by two people. Pretty straight forward right?

We can let scum bring it down to the final 5 people and hopefully by then someone else around here will actually have a read.

 

[Fireblend]

D7:
T-N-S
5-1-1 -> No lynch

N7:
4-1-1 -> After night kill

D8:
4-1-1 -> No lynch

N8:
3-1-1 -> After night kill

D9:
3-1-1: Decision day. We could do this, let scum kill two more times and just see what happens, see who drops and let that narrow our decision down for us?

Thoughts, even for just one day?

Hmm, worth considering? I think we'd need 2 days to get anywhere though, I'd expect Ouro to be nkd tonight which tells me nothing. We would be replaying today's phase except without Ouro's input.

Also this is a good townie suggestion. Why are we not voting Milk again.

 

[Spoiled Milk]

Let's
Just
Skip
Straight
To
LyLo!

What would Jesus do?

 

[Flame_AC]

Hmm, worth considering? I think we'd need 2 days to get anywhere though, I'd expect Ouro to be nkd tonight which tells me nothing. We would be replaying today's phase except without Ouro's input.

Also this is a good townie suggestion. Why are we not voting Milk again.

You think Ouro would be the one to die? That makes me want to do a no lynch more just to see scum make that choice.

You already know why I'm not really voting Milk. Go in with me on this no lynch idea, for at least a day and lets see where it gets us? It literally does us no harm, other than dragging the game out a little bit.

 

[*Splinter]

Spoiler alert: Zeemumu dies tonight, tomorrow is a repeat of today with one less townie.

That's a truly awful suggestion.

 

[Spoiled Milk]

It literally does us no harm, other than dragging the game out a little bit.

 

[Fireblend]

Fuck, Zeemumu is alive.

My bad, this is a bad plan.

 

[Flame_AC]

Spoiler alert: Zeemumu dies tonight, tomorrow is a repeat of today with one less townie.

That's a truly awful suggestion.

Then we'll see what happens on the second night.

It's only an awful suggestion for our dear neutral.

 

[*Splinter]

Right now you have time to lynch 2 or 3 people, with Flame's suggestion you can only lynch one.

Fireblend said this was a good idea what am I reading.

Wait, nevermind, I'm not town, y'all go nuts!

 

[Ourobolus]

No lynch doesn't change anything. We have two days either way

 

[Fireblend]

I forgot zeemumu was in this. Why is he not here talking with us?!

 

[*Splinter]

Then we'll see what happens on the second night.

It's only an awful suggestion for our dear neutral.

Makes no difference to me.

 

[Fireblend]

Splinter, if you know something that may help, please help :<

I'll owe you one?

 

[Flame_AC]

Look. I don't see y'all coming up with some ideas. I'm trying to find something, anything that can help us out.

Zeemumu isn't here cause he got that 'super' clear from our 'friend' the 'neutral'. Kawl hasn't really been here either.

 

[*Splinter]

Splinter, if you know something that may help, please help :<

I'll owe you one?

Already done all I can. Flame still looks most likely to be scum from where I'm sitting.

Look. I don't see y'all coming up with some ideas. I'm trying to find something, anything that can help us out.

Zeemumu isn't here cause he got that 'super' clear from our 'friend' the 'neutral'. Kawl hasn't really been here either.

How does your plan help though? Right now there's not much to go on between Kawl/Flame/Fire/Milk. If you no lynch for 2 days in a row you'll still be in that same situation except now you have to get it right first time. It's madness.

 

[Flame_AC]

Already done all I can. Flame still looks most likely to be scum from where I'm sitting.


How does your plan help though? Right now there's not much to go on between Kawl/Flame/Fire/Milk. If you no lynch for 2 days in a row you'll still be in that same situation except now you have to get it right first time. It's madness.

If I'm scum, my play doesn't really make any sense. Why would I have spent a bunch of time trying to clear Spoiled Milk and restrict the choices even further, making my lynch more likely?

It was an idea that I presented to all of y'all, as is evident now, it has its flaws.

 

[*Splinter]

If I'm scum, my play doesn't really make any sense. Why would I have spent a bunch of time trying to clear Spoiled Milk and restrict the choices even further, making my lynch more likely?

It was an idea that I presented to all of y'all, as is evident now, it has its flaws.

Clear Milk to make yourself look town, increase likelihood of Kawl lynch. Not a bad or even unusual play for scum to make at this point.

 

[Flame_AC]

Clear Milk to make yourself look town, increase likelihood of Kawl lynch. Not a bad or even unusual play for scum to make at this point.

And then tomorrow I'm completely doomed? I'd be better off just defending myself and hopping on the Milk train with Fireblend. Ouro has Fireblend's back, so that's already two votes on me. That's why I'd be shocked if Ouro/Fireblend die during the night, cause they're gonna choose me to die D8 (if I get there) and then scum will win the game.

 

[Spoiled Milk]

No lynch doesn't change anything. We have two days either way

Are you sure you'd rather leave your vote on flame than Kawl? Don't you think you might be biased toward flame because he engaged and Kawl doesn't?

 

[Flame_AC]

Are you sure you'd rather leave your vote on flame than Kawl? Don't you think you might be biased toward flame because he engaged and Kawl doesn't?

He's been after me since like D2. I can't defend against an entire game's worth of built up scum-feeling.

I guess a question you could ask is, who does everyone want around on Day 8? I'll bring my hardest defense and scum reads to D8 if I make it there.

 

[Ourobolus]

Are you sure you'd rather leave your vote on flame than Kawl? Don't you think you might be biased toward flame because he engaged and Kawl doesn't?

It's possible. I can always get Kawl tomorrow

 

[Flame_AC]

It's possible. I can always get Kawl tomorrow

You'd really rather have Kawl's whole 1 post for the day then me? You wanted me to go back and see what I could find, I found pretty great evidence of Spoiled Milk being town. I found a consistent pattern of Gorlak/Kalor attacking me, what more do you want me to find?

 

[Fireblend]

If I'm scum, my play doesn't really make any sense. Why would I have spent a bunch of time trying to clear Spoiled Milk and restrict the choices even further, making my lynch more likely?

It was an idea that I presented to all of y'all, as is evident now, it has its flaws.

I'd like to think you're town. You've been active and provided decent thoughts today. Could've gone after Milk but you're his biggest defender. Your concern sounds genuine. I liked the no lynch idea until I realized zeemumu was alive. It seems to me like you've stopped antagonizing me for similar reasons. But I can't be sure.

Is there anything that would make you reconsider Milk? I'm willing to reconsider Kawl, his silence isn't doing him any favors but I don't want inactivity to be the entire justification for my vote today.

 

[Ourobolus]

Tbf Kawl said he would be out for most/all of this phase

 

[Flame_AC]

I'd like to think you're town. You've been active and provided decent thoughts today. Could've gone after Milk but you're his biggest defender. Your concern sounds genuine. I liked the no lynch idea until I realized zeemumu was alive. It seems to me like you've stopped antagonizing me for similar reasons. But I can't be sure.

Is there anything that would make you reconsider Milk? I'm willing to reconsider Kawl, his silence isn't doing him any favors but I don't want inactivity to be the entire justification for my vote today.

I would consider a Milk lynch, maybe. The posts they've done today have been completely reactionary. Just look at their voting pattern and how much it follows Ouro's (maybe that's why Ouro doesn't want to lynch them). So I mean, from a purely actions point of view, I'd have no problems lynching Milk. But there's that pesky choice of Kalor's to lynch Spoiled Milk on day 1, that was missed by like 10 seconds, that I can't just throw to the side. Why would scum Kalor have chosen Spoiled Milk to die (besides me being scum), unless Kalor didn't care who died cause both of us were town.

 

[zeemumu]

Look. I don't see y'all coming up with some ideas. I'm trying to find something, anything that can help us out.

Zeemumu isn't here cause he got that 'super' clear from our 'friend' the 'neutral'. Kawl hasn't really been here either.

I was at a party yesterday and I didn't get home until almost 3AM.