CrimsonFist
Member
Day 5 has ended
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Danganronpa 3 Mafia |OT| Side: Scum
- Thread starter CrimsonFist
- Start date
CrimsonFist
Member
Sorian is no more! He has ceased to be! 'E's expired and gone to meet 'is maker! 'E's a stiff! Bereft of life, 'e rests in peace! If you hadn't nailed 'im to the perch 'e'd be pushing up the daisies! 'Is metabolic processes are now 'istory! 'E's off the twig! 'E's kicked the bucket, 'e's shuffled off 'is mortal coil, run down the curtain and joined the bleedin' choir invisible!! THIS IS AN EX-Sorian!!
Sorian has died
Sorian has died
CrimsonFist
Member
And with that, despair need no longer fear the future foundation, they were in control now, and were free to spread despair across the world, or at least they would once they got off this island.
StarSketch and Ty4on have died
Bronx-Man, AbsolutBro, FluxWaveZ and Natiko have won
StarSketch:
Ty4on:
FluxWaveZ:
Natiko:
And so the killings came to an end. Nothing was really resolved, and by point, I doubt anyone really cares. As rescue ships finally appeared on the horizon however, movement was seen from beneath the rubble.
upupupupu, I hope youre not forgetting about someone. Did you think this was over without the unmasking of the true mastermind.
And on saying that, the head of the bear fell to the floor, revealing none other than an ordinary snail.
Now Im sure youre all just waiting for me to explain the complexities of my machinations, and the grand future I have instore for all of
The survivors left the snail to its ramblings, and departed from the island without looking back.
The End.
StarSketch and Ty4on have died
Bronx-Man, AbsolutBro, FluxWaveZ and Natiko have won
StarSketch:
Ty4on:
FluxWaveZ:
Natiko:
And so the killings came to an end. Nothing was really resolved, and by point, I doubt anyone really cares. As rescue ships finally appeared on the horizon however, movement was seen from beneath the rubble.
upupupupu, I hope youre not forgetting about someone. Did you think this was over without the unmasking of the true mastermind.
And on saying that, the head of the bear fell to the floor, revealing none other than an ordinary snail.
Now Im sure youre all just waiting for me to explain the complexities of my machinations, and the grand future I have instore for all of
The survivors left the snail to its ramblings, and departed from the island without looking back.
The End.
StarSketch
Banned
:\
StarSketch
Banned
Man I was onto something but it didn't seem concrete
CrimsonFist
Member
Scumputer MVP
Scumputer was terrifying accurate. Looking back I noticed Sorian and Natiko were on many of the same wagons as well.
I got to lynch you I guess
;_;
I got to lynch you I guess
CrimsonFist
Member
Well played to everyone, scum in particular, who going into the game I thought would have quite an uphill battle, especially with their forbidden actions, but they had a lot of luck in that regard day/night 1.
I feel like the game worked out surprisingly well. There was potential for a much worse night 1, but that was just about avoided, and we had a surprisingly balanced endgame. Full night actions are here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...NRfJiY6cVXUK6r3cgwCBJJ86Y/edit#gid=2058602319.
Any feedback is welcome.
I feel like the game worked out surprisingly well. There was potential for a much worse night 1, but that was just about avoided, and we had a surprisingly balanced endgame. Full night actions are here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...NRfJiY6cVXUK6r3cgwCBJJ86Y/edit#gid=2058602319.
Any feedback is welcome.
StarSketch
Banned
I have no excuses for what happened on day 3. None at all.
Also thanks you guys for turboing Bronx while I was actually AFK for once :|
Meh, went into the last day with the game solved and put scum into an awkward spot even if someone couldn't realize that. Where did the claim that you missed me N1 come from? Obviously the only thing that threw a wrench in because I would have voted Natiko instead of Flux (which probably would have changed all of nothing).
But it's oh so rewarding, baby
You've won your first games as neutral and scum. Jeez. >_>;
EDIT: AND you won your first game as town I think too (Quarantine Mafia) although you weren't alive at the end.
Bronx is that guy that does none of the heavy lifting but shows up at the after party and mooches alcohol from everyone.
It's certainly different. My first time as scum from the outset, though I had been scum before. It's fun, though.
I guess I did a decent job to be active enough while also not raising too many alarms, which made people null read me or slightly lean scum for the most part. Sorian targeting me there took me off-guard.
The worst thing is Sorian was right
Feedback:
I liked the idea of FAs, and liked how they counteract the roles. I didn't like how much they dominated discussion, but that was mostly town's fault - one improvement you mentioned in spec thread was to tell everyone at the start that FAs are like PRs, would have cut down on that speculative chatter.
I like the idea of a cop that can't claim, BUT claiming is also a big part of Mafia and I feel it was a bit intrusive to the base experience to not let Terra say anything. I would have solved this by giving him a day command to confirm his alignment (but not role). This might sound op BUT it's kind of what any cop can do by claiming, and he still has to work around giving his results without explicitly claiming them, which was the interesting part of the role.
Apart from that this was a reasonably entertaining game, gg all, gg scum.
I liked the idea of FAs, and liked how they counteract the roles. I didn't like how much they dominated discussion, but that was mostly town's fault - one improvement you mentioned in spec thread was to tell everyone at the start that FAs are like PRs, would have cut down on that speculative chatter.
I like the idea of a cop that can't claim, BUT claiming is also a big part of Mafia and I feel it was a bit intrusive to the base experience to not let Terra say anything. I would have solved this by giving him a day command to confirm his alignment (but not role). This might sound op BUT it's kind of what any cop can do by claiming, and he still has to work around giving his results without explicitly claiming them, which was the interesting part of the role.
Apart from that this was a reasonably entertaining game, gg all, gg scum.
I think you might have got another day with a Natiko lynch since it seemed like Ty was tunnelling you two pretty hard.
But then StarSketch gets killed and Ty4on kills you on the last day.
Well we had a few ideas for my claim, but I went with that one because it seemed the most believable. I couldn't say I waited until N2 to check you if I activated D1 because it didn't line up as well with my reads and would seem odd. Instead I stuck with N1 with the idea that even though my claim contradicted your even night one that I could always argue I was roleblocked (not knowing then how being roleblocked would have actually worked). Basically I got lucky on a 50/50 gamble.
My first game as town was actually Zelda...RIP. But hey, I'll take the neutral and scum wins
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
well that was fun.
good jobs scums.
hey remember when i wasn't terrible at mafia?
good jobs scums.
hey remember when i wasn't terrible at mafia?
me neither.
My first game as town was actually Zelda...RIP. But hey, I'll take the neutral and scum wins
Still, having a win as every faction is very impressive.
I remember when you won us the game in GAFia 2.5 after Kawl screwed up.
Well we had a few ideas for my claim, but I went with that one because it seemed the most believable. I couldn't say I waited until N2 to check you if I activated D1 because it didn't line up as well with my reads and would seem odd. Instead I stuck with N1 with the idea that even though my claim contradicted your even night one that I could always argue I was roleblocked (not knowing then how being roleblocked would have actually worked). Basically I got lucky on a 50/50 gamble.
My first game as town was actually Zelda...RIP. But hey, I'll take the neutral and scum wins
RIP, I would have slashed you out so fast if you had said you lost your shot investigating me N2. Damn.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
Still, having a win as every faction is very impressive.
I remember when you won us the game in GAFia 2.5 after Kawl screwed up.
that was when i shot royal right? only i didnt actually shoot him, as i was only holding a banana, but the shock of thinking he got shot gave him a heart attack, and everyone threw a parade in honor of the banana.
prtty sure thats exactly how it went down
something something fruit vedor
Royal_Flush
Member
I believed in you, Ty
Short Feedback: I really like the FA, both idea and implementation. I might steal a variation of it at some point, maybe I'd be curious about rejected ideas.
I probably also would have voted Sorian
Short Feedback: I really like the FA, both idea and implementation. I might steal a variation of it at some point, maybe
I'd be curious about rejected ideas.*sigh*I remember when you won us the game in GAFia 2.5 after Kawl screwed up.
Yeah, I made the claim expecting I may still die. We agreed to have Flux bus me instantly and hope he could convince Ty to kill you the following day if it came to that.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
I believed in you, TyI probably also would have voted Sorian
Short Feedback: I really like the FA, both idea and implementation. I might steal a variation of it at some point, maybe
*sigh*
totally agree with this, the FA's were an awesome addition to the game, unlike many similar mechanics they struck a great balance of altering how we had to think about players actions and claims, but without ever becoming too great a focus, (we only lost a like a single day meaningless mechanic disccusion! not half the game like would usually be the norm)
Bronx is that guy that does none of the heavy lifting but shows up at the after party and mooches alcohol from everyone.
AbsolutBro
Member
3-0 as scum baby!
Huge thanks to my scum team, sorry I died so early and couldn't help.
Huge thanks to my scum team, sorry I died so early and couldn't help.
CrimsonFist
Member
Yeah, I kind of realised that earlier on, someone in scum chat came up with a much better one, but I didn't want to confirm or deny what was actually in the game.
I don't think they were all too unbelievable though, at least when compared to a few of the other vanilla town ones. Stanley's in particular was super easy to get around, since there was no limitation on not being honest about it.
It looked better in context!
As *Splinter said too, I should have given town a bit more information on how FA's worked and lined up to PR's, PR ones being obvious along with the possibility of someone being unable to claim (although nobody considered that possibility in the end) were supposed to be disincentives against a mass claim.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
wait what?
"Not fake claiming a role by day x"
but is that what my FA was?
edit:
nope, no it wasnt, mine was not fake claiming an FA,
excuse me while i got get new glasses.
CrimsonFist
Member
Yours was not fake claiming a forbidden action.
Ultimate Movie Critic
Ultimate Athlete
Ultimate Caretaker
Ultimate Politician
Ultimate Driver
Additionally, here are some Forbidden Actions which are not in the game, should you need to claim one other than your own:
Name Claiming
Quoting [Player]
Not adding banana to the start of every post
Not witnessing pigs fly by the end of day 2
Turboing a player
Having a vote on someone other than the vote leader at EOD
Name claiming was the only viable one to use really. The turbo one was really similar to nin's. The rest are just bait for getting yourself lynched lol
Nah, you're not alone on that. This is the only game I've been in that outright pissed me off while I was playing. Compared to Pokemon where I was pissed because I wasn't playing.