If it was a foul he would have pointed his flag to the left. He held it up straight iirc.
edit: Plus the lino said to Suarez "offside" in the post match handshakes.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Football Thread 2012/13 |OT6| Mumei almost banned EVERYBODY (but just Wilbury)
- Thread starter Awesome Animals
- Start date
If it was a foul he would have pointed his flag to the left. He held it up straight iirc.
edit: Plus the lino said to Suarez "offside" in the post match handshakes.
You know that's exactly what they'll say in retrospect.
terrible offside call jesus
liverpool should have won that despite being rubbish which is interesting - i wasn't expecting liverpool's good midfield and possession approach to look so poor on the ball and get dominated by neville and co, nor for them to have the character to nab three goals against the run of play given how they normally are.
liverpool should have won that despite being rubbish which is interesting - i wasn't expecting liverpool's good midfield and possession approach to look so poor on the ball and get dominated by neville and co, nor for them to have the character to nab three goals against the run of play given how they normally are.
The_Hitcher89
Member
Nobody can apologise for that decision. Dumbfounding. Disraceful. Dismal. Dreadful.
I'd have taken a point at the start, but that is sickening
I'd have taken a point at the start, but that is sickening
Vivalaraza
Member
Hahahahahahahahaha.
Amazing.
Tbh I thought Coates fouled Jagielka anyway.
Amazing.
Tbh I thought Coates fouled Jagielka anyway.
Joel Was Right
Member
It amazes me that all this talk of goal-line technology ignores the fact that more goals are denied/allowed due to the offside rule, so we will still have controversy we shouldn't have. So how long before linesman are replaced by cameras
everthustodeadbeats
Member
There were players on the pitch that noticed it was a shit call, so the FA can do nothing about it.
Seriously I'm watching the disallowed goal, it's a blatant goal.
There was no foul anyway.
Jeff Albertson
Member
Lol this is kind of hilarious
Bad offside call but clearly a foul so yes it's terrible officiating but the outcome is correct nobody has been robbed
Bad offside call but clearly a foul so yes it's terrible officiating but the outcome is correct nobody has been robbed
Yup.. It's all Fergie's fault.
Not when it's handed to you in a fucking plate.
SunhiLegend
Member
Not offside, probably a foul but the goal was disallowed for being offside which he clearly wasn't.
Vivalaraza
Member
Coates has his hands all over Jagielka.
The official got it wrong.
But it should have been ruled a foul.
The official got it wrong.
But it should have been ruled a foul.
You better be thanking your lucky fucking stars for that point.
The second Everton goal came after a throw-in was wrongfully given to you, and Liverpool were robbed for the last goal.
Not to mention Fellaini kicked a player ON THE GROUND and so no recourse.
My thoughts on it too.
Yeah, I didn't see what the linesman called but I assumed it was a foul
Coates doing his best Crouch.
Not offside, probably a foul but the goal was disallowed for being offside which he clearly wasn't.
Well piss off. there were other decision that went against us this game and you don't see me whining. So please do one with your bloody biased view.
The_Hitcher89
Member
Can't tell from either of the times they showed it whether Coates had his hands on Jagielka as a part of his jumping motion when he meets the ball, or whether he propelled himself up/Jagielka down by pushing down on his shoulders.
MarshMellow96
Member
Jags shouldn't have been fouled because he should've taken an early bath. Go figure!
Jeff Albertson
Member
Linesman fucked up but by fucking up the correct outcome was achieved
Both teams could have had men sent off probably and I thought the ref did well letting it flow as much as possible
And everyone know you. So I am not even going to reply with erbuff to your view.
Baconsaurus Rex
Member
Joel Was Right
Member
The_Hitcher89
Member
What a shite question to Naismith. 'Do you want to piss off the Ramgers fans, or the Everton fans?'
KidA Seven
Member
Wasn't he played out of position?
Thought Joe Allen was immense in that second half. Never gave that shit house thug Fellaini a sniff.
Hard to take that result after the way the game played out and the shit decision at the end but I think the majority of Liverpool fans would of taken a draw before the match.
Edit- oh god watching that end decision in slow motion makes me feel fucking ill. We did indeed get fucking robbed.
Hard to take that result after the way the game played out and the shit decision at the end but I think the majority of Liverpool fans would of taken a draw before the match.
Edit- oh god watching that end decision in slow motion makes me feel fucking ill. We did indeed get fucking robbed.
The_Hitcher89
Member
MarshMellow96
Member
Nah, not a foul either.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked