-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Oscar nominations 2025
- Thread starter Jaybe
- Start date
Trogdor1123
Member
I never saw it but apparently it’s good
As for the rest, I saw exactly one movie there, dune 2
ChuckeRearmed
Member
It is in general. I think their viewership is going down. Plus how many can you name at this point that are going to win? We don't have many great actors these days either.
od-chan
Member
Depends on how you look at it I guess.
Were they ever more relevant? If yes, how so? I'd argue with the rise of social media, entertainment is now much deeper entrenched in our daily lives than it has ever been. Look how much Letterboxd grew in a couple of years. Every film major is starting his own movie podcast or trying to get on your #MovieTok #FYP.
And the oscars are still, by large, the most high profile event of that industry.
That for example is, I think, a too reductive way of looking at it.
Fbh
Member
The only one I've seen from the best pictures list is Dune and I thought it was just OK (it should win best cinematography though, IMO).
I'm not really into modern movies, there's a couple of decent stuff every year but nothing has wowed me in a long time
LoL this is great.
If the entire movie is like that I might watch it. Seems like that rare The Room style movie that's unintentionally so bad it's good.
I'm not really into modern movies, there's a couple of decent stuff every year but nothing has wowed me in a long time
LoL this is great.
If the entire movie is like that I might watch it. Seems like that rare The Room style movie that's unintentionally so bad it's good.
Last edited:
reezoo
Member
One more thing is it’s easier now to discover what you like then relying on someone else.
ChuckeRearmed
Member
Plus you have movies and TV series that are popular but never nominated so people who watch those series don't care about awards and so on.
Jinzo Prime
Member
I hope this wins Best Picture; let everyone really see the irrelevance of these awards.
Ribi
Member
You know I usually am a snob for movies and tend to wait for the Oscars to narrow down the movies I should watch but what the fuck is this year? Wicked too?
I collect VHS tapes
Member
I live in Los Angeles near the fires. For what it’s worth I think it would be great and people generally would like having something like the Oscars going on right now. Look up the history of movies in the USA, they basically came out as a wartime cope. LA had a history of it in particular. Much of those silent films came out of silver lake and echo park, areas near the California fires.
The problem is that the Oscars in actuality are fucking awful. So I really don’t give a fuck if they happen or not. But if we had some sort of decent award show, I think it would be nice even if the world is burning down.
Last edited:
Radical Dreamer
Member
Rooting for Substance and Nosferatu
Biff
Member
I watched Emilia Perez last night. It was "fine" but in no way close to Best Picture-worthy, even in a relatively weak year like 2024.
Overall I'd give it a 6/10. Without Zoe Saldana it would be a 3 or 4.
- The actual plot is a disaster and completely unwatchable from that perspective. For me, I tend to weigh plot just as much as acting, directing, cinematography, etc. so I could still make it through the movie.
- I thought Zoe Saldana was incredible in it and I do think she deserved her nomination.
- The direction was excellent with some really unique camera movements, especially during the songs (yes it's a musical - don't ask lol)
- The songs themselves were completely forgettable bordering on "bad". I thought Selena Gomez's main song was great but otherwise they are best described as sing-talking which is pointless for a musical.
- I will give major props on the choreography though. Top tier excellent, and Zoe Saldana is actually an incredible dancer. She really carries this film.
- 2h20m is unnecessary. Should have been 1h40m tops.
Overall I'd give it a 6/10. Without Zoe Saldana it would be a 3 or 4.
Thaimasker
Member
It's not a general audience popularity contest. Similar with games, madden doesn't get nominated for GOTY at the TGA.Looking at this list you’d think it was a bad year for movies.
The box office list for last year paints a very different picture when it comes to what was popular.
2024 Worldwide Box Office
www.boxofficemojo.com
Sad that the highest movie on that list that isn't an established IP is #16.. A movie about tornados lol
marquimvfs
Member
Some folks here in Brazil are rooting Fernanda Torres, no matter how bland the movie was. It's sort of reparation for the Oscar that fucking Gwyneth Paltrow stole from her mother (Fernanda Montenegro, who's also in the movie) back in 99.
Last edited:
bitbydeath
Member
Oscar’s are mainly just rubbish movies that are paid to be there. I’d rather see Twisters get awards than most of the movies on this list.
Thaimasker
Member
A lot of them are indie movies. Studios like Disney actually have the money and can't get even get them nominated despite pushing for them. So that logic doesn't add up.
Most people would rather see... Venom get awards than parasite. That's why there are MTV movie awards.. Where the same franchise movies made by the same 3 mega corporations like twilight, scream 5, marvel movies can win. It's based more on marketing $ than artistic merit.
Edit: also, I was wrong. Twisters in itself is a sequel. You have to go so far down the list to find something that is original.
Last edited:
bitbydeath
Member
Whatever the reason, having this even nominated for best visual effects
when there are far better candidates EG. Twisters
Just makes it difficult to take seriously.
Last edited:
RCX
Member
Please god let this sweep the whole thing. It's exactly what's needed to finally rid the Oscars of its last pretence of credibility and for Hollywood to totally unmoore itself from the rest of the world.
Looks absolutely lunatic-level DEI trash.
Thaimasker
Member
It's not perfect and I certainly don't agree with everything, but I and pretty much everyone making the art can take it more serious than something like the MTV movie awards.Whatever the reason, having this even nominated for best visual effects
when there are far better candidates EG. Twisters
Just makes it difficult to take seriously.
bitbydeath
Member
I don’t know what they do different, not sure how much worse it can get.
Thaimasker
Member
Well. In 2023 Mario movie could have won best picture as it was the highest grossing instead of everything everywhere all at once lol.
This really just was a weaker year for movies in terms of quality. Dune 2 made it and it's #5, that's well deserved. Wicked deserved it I guess. The other top grossing? Nah.
The only movie that got nominated for best picture that shouldn't be there is Emilia Pérez. There were Def better movies than that lol.
Last edited:
ChuckeRearmed
Member
To have more hate you need to actually watch the movie.
DKehoe
Member
Which of the ones listed did you like? How many of the best picture nominees have you seen?
I collect VHS tapes
Member
Literally didn’t even realize it was a movie until I saw this thread
bitbydeath
Member
I saw Dune part 2, it was alright, bit too Marvel where they want to be adult but can’t do anything too adult. It was better than the first one though.
I haven’t seen Substance but have heard good things. If any deserve a place on the best of list I would go with that.
Redneckerz
Those long posts don't cover that red neck boy
I saw most movies last year and i can't even remember half of the nominees.
I will say this. The Wild Robot deserves to win something. Amazing artstyle, great story, felt really refreshing.
However i figure Emilia Perez will win, which just merely judging by its plot seems all set for winning because that's the in-thing now.
FYI just reading the plot already sounds ridiculous. A cartel leader doing a sex change. What kind of shit are you on to think of stuff like that?
I will say this. The Wild Robot deserves to win something. Amazing artstyle, great story, felt really refreshing.
However i figure Emilia Perez will win, which just merely judging by its plot seems all set for winning because that's the in-thing now.
FYI just reading the plot already sounds ridiculous. A cartel leader doing a sex change. What kind of shit are you on to think of stuff like that?
Tams
Member
Eh, Dune Part II was great, but also a. It of let down compared to Part I.
Jaybe
Member
Ended up watching both The brutalist (theatre) and Conclave (home rental) yesterday. The brutalist is definitely the better movie, somewhere between good to great, hard to recommend though. The conclave was rather disappointing unfortunately. Fine but I expected more. I think Anora takes best picture.
DKehoe
Member
I saw The Brutalist last night too. I really enjoyed it. It's one I think I'll be turning over in my head for a while. I can see it doing great, in with a really good chance for Best Picture and Best Actor. Some incredible visuals too, particularly in a certain location in the second half.
No BBC=Anger
Member
Script idea for a Hollywood movie. An Oscars like award ceremony descends into a Die Hard type of scenario.
Last edited:
Alx
Member
I mean, it’s not exactly a new or provocative idea… look at Marie-Antoinette, many Three Musketeers adaptations, les Misérables, Pépé le Moko/Casbah,…
Last edited:
Heimdall_Xtreme
Hermen Hulst Fanclub's #1 Member
Emilia Pérez???
Yes, it has fallen under Hollywood
Yes, it has fallen under Hollywood
Heimdall_Xtreme
Hermen Hulst Fanclub's #1 Member
Here in Mexico, that shit movie is very repudiated... Even the theaters are empty.
DKehoe
Member
Conan O’Brien is hosting this year, which should be good.
12Goblins
Lil’ Gobbie
Dang, that is a good catch by the academy :3
marquimvfs
Member
Claro! It's as absurd as if Bin Laden decides to become transex, creates an organization dedicated to eradicate terrorism, dies an stupid death and Americans decide to beatificate him, doing parades for him in the center of Manhattan. Sure thing, it's a great
SF Kosmo
Banned
Anora was my favorite film of the year and I especially think Mike Madison gave such an incredibly charismatic and moving performance. Masterpiece.
But if I was putting money down I would say they give it to Demi Moore just because the Oscars love a comeback and she never got one back in the day. Substance was also. Great film but I liked Anora more.
Haven't seen Brutalist yet.
This movie is absolutely terrible and I have no idea how it is nominated other than trans=important or something. I can't even call it woke because I think trans people would probably find it pretty offensive.
But if I was putting money down I would say they give it to Demi Moore just because the Oscars love a comeback and she never got one back in the day. Substance was also. Great film but I liked Anora more.
Haven't seen Brutalist yet.
This movie is absolutely terrible and I have no idea how it is nominated other than trans=important or something. I can't even call it woke because I think trans people would probably find it pretty offensive.
DKehoe
Member
Let me know what you think of The Brutalist if you do watch it. I really liked it. Maybe it's just that GAF’s movie discussion isn't what it used to be but it’s been disappointing that there’s not really been any talk about it on here.
Edit: just saw you’ve been perma banned. I guess never mind that then!
Last edited:
RJMacready73
Simps for Amouranth
Do yourselves a favour and check out Kneecap, our wee northern Irish oscar contender that's an absolute gem
www.rottentomatoes.com
One of the funniest films I've seen in years
Kneecap | Rotten Tomatoes
When fate brings Belfast schoolteacher JJ into the orbit of self-confessed 'low life scum' Naoise and Liam Og, the needle drops on a hip hop act like no other. Rapping in their native Irish language, KNEECAP fast become the unlikely figureheads of a Civil Rights movement to save their mother...
www.rottentomatoes.com
One of the funniest films I've seen in years
DKehoe
Member
I watched this a couple of days ago and loved it. It's a shame it didn't get a nomination in the Best International Feature category.Do yourselves a favour and check out Kneecap, our wee northern Irish oscar contender that's an absolute gem
Kneecap | Rotten Tomatoes
When fate brings Belfast schoolteacher JJ into the orbit of self-confessed 'low life scum' Naoise and Liam Og, the needle drops on a hip hop act like no other. Rapping in their native Irish language, KNEECAP fast become the unlikely figureheads of a Civil Rights movement to save their mother...
One of the funniest films I've seen in years
Last edited:
Mr Reasonable
Completely Unreasonable
I think that the rules for that category are more about language than nationality.
DKehoe
Member
A lot of Kneecap is in the Irish language so it was eligible. It got shortlisted but not nominated.
Mr Reasonable
Completely Unreasonable
Ah, my mistake, apologies. Thanks for letting me know!