• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Phil Spencer. Post if you're okay.

Skifi28

Member
looking ruff

-1x-1.webp
*This image was AI upscaled using PSSR*
 

Kacho

Gold Member
You don't hear anything from him because Sarah Bond is the new Phil Spencer. She's quiet like Nintendo's Doug Bowser because she ain't got no gamer cred. Doesn't matter how many controllers she places on her dresser. She's the the unseasoned chicken version of a video game executive. She's got no pizzazz, no flair. Current day executives pale in comparison to GOATs like Reggie and Peter Moore.

Besides, it's not like Xbox has anything to boast about. Like, wow... Cooking Mama is coming to Game Pass!
Angry Harrison Ford GIF
 

gow3isben

Member
I have mentioned this several times here before but Xbox has a scoring system they used to use (seems they still do) to decide who to hire and/or promote

People like this are given extra points before ever walking into the interview that immediately gives them an advantage and the only demographic that did not get any starter points are straight white men

90% sure East Asians and South Asians get negative points
 

SJRB

Gold Member
What stress? He could get fired today and retire a multi millionaire. The stressful part of his career is over now that Satya has waved the white flag.

He ran a billion dollar conglomerate into the ground, I'm sure the pressure weighs on him.

Not that every single failure that happened in the Xbox ecosystem is his personal fault by any means, but as CEO he is ultimately responsible for what happened.
 

Det

Member
He ran a billion dollar conglomerate into the ground, I'm sure the pressure weighs on him.

Not that every single failure that happened in the Xbox ecosystem is his personal fault by any means, but as CEO he is ultimately responsible for what happened.
If he had made the best decisions for Microsoft, Phill would have told Nadella to shut down Xbox in 2016 and not sell the idea of "Netflix of games" "100 million GP subscribers" and "3 billion consumer market on cell phones with xcloud" that kept the xbox running until 2024

Looking at the alternative, Phil doing this load of shit was less worse if he had made the best decisions and closed the Xbox in 2016
 

Humdinger

Gold Member
I noticed the silence shortly after the transition to third-party started. He stepped back out of the spotlight and wasn't heard from for months.

I think he stepped back for three main reasons:

1. He doesn't want to answer hard questions that might put him in a bad light (e.g., complaints from the Xbox fans, dwindling console sales, sending more games to Playstation than he indicated, stagnation of GP, etc.).

2. The purpose of his PR junkets was to promote GP and the console. MS is floundering on both of those fronts. If Phil does more cheerleading on that, it won't help.

3. His enthusiasm is down. Phil's vision was that GP was going to be a big success, and so was Xbox (the console). That hasn't come to pass. Although Xbox gamers have saved a lot of money, Phil's vision has largely been a flop and has contributed to the downfall of the console. Phil is an optimist, but even he must realize that things didn't work out as he hoped. And he is not happy about it. He is not that excited about the direction of the company now. He doesn't feel motivated to go out there and promote it.
 
Last edited:

RoboFu

One of the green rats
He makes millions a year. He has worked long enough to where he doesn't need to push himself anymore. He is probably on the way out retiring anyway.
 

Arsic

Loves his juicy stink trail scent
He doesn’t have fans or trust anymore.

In the end his leadership killed Xbox, or any reason to own one.

When the mask is pulled back and investors/higher ups realize engagement doesn’t pay bills or grow market share, he will be kicked out.

He’s the greatest con man ever. I love gamepass but he convinced dozens of people this would make more money and instead flushed sales down a toilet lol.
 

Parazels

Member
Haven't seen a Phil Spencer interview in over three weeks; is he okay?
Do you miss another portion of "immersive gaming experience on Game pass"?

This is exactly what he is repeating in every single interview.
 
Last edited:

Brigandier

Member
I have mentioned this several times here before but Xbox has a scoring system they used to use (seems they still do) to decide who to hire and/or promote

People like this are given extra points before ever walking into the interview that immediately gives them an advantage and the only demographic that did not get any starter points are straight white men

I would genuinely hate to work there.... it sounds incredibly discriminate against white heterosexual men.
 

Sorcerer

Member
I think his PR work mas mostly limited to convincing people that Xbox is where it's at back when MS still thought they stood a chance in terms of hardware market share. Now that Xbox apparently includes Playstation there's no really no more need to convince people to pick sides.
True. Spencer would become the diplomat of consoles (the good guy Dave Grohl of videogames) but he disappeared and Bond is not very public facing either. Nadella seems to have taken over PR.
 
Last edited:
The King who achieved nothing, won no wars, and only was remembered because he expelled his salt of the earth farmers, carpenters, blacksmiths, and bakers to curry favor with a handful of traveling spice, perfume, and gold peddlers.
 

Jaybe

Member
They are preparing to retire him. I don't think he has much time left at MS

Same. I think Matt Booty will get the role since he’s leading the first-party studios, and they seem to be finally running as intended with a content pipeline at a good cadence. Sarah Bond has been dismal leading hardware and game pass, and it wouldn’t surprise me if she’s being encouraged to find a new position elsewhere.
 

JohnnyFootball

GerAlt-Right. Ciriously.
Honestly I'm worried about his health. Imagine the psychological strain when everything you worked for, everything you said, every promise you made, gets upended by those higher than you. The generational road map with X/S and Game Pass didn't pan out. The supposed blockbuster games you've promoted and put your hopes on were financial or critical duds. Closed studios. Cratering console sales. Games ported to competitions platforms. Fan base turning against you. Even if Phil is payed a high salary to endure this kinda heat it can be easy dealing with stuff like this. Some day you're bound to get broken.
Thats Microsoft for you. Microsoft's entire business model has been about being in the right place at the right time. Windows and DOS happened because IBM execs wanted to go golfing.

Phil is and was a always a Microsoft guy. He was good enough at it to snake his way into convincing people he was a gamer, but he and the people around him know absolutely nothing about studio management. he consistently kept sinking billions and billions into many projects that (likely) never received a return on investment (Gamepass being the worst). That is what cost him and Xbox as a whole. Worst of all, they like to make FUD their business model, and whores like ColtEastwood, Old TimDawg, Parris, Destin, Arthur Gies, and Ryan McCaffrey went along with it cuz it made them feel important. Xbox still has an impressive Twitter army.

Is it a shame? Yes, Xbox can no longer stroke the competitive ego of Sony.
 

JohnnyFootball

GerAlt-Right. Ciriously.
Same. I think Matt Booty will get the role since he’s leading the first-party studios, and they seem to be finally running as intended with a content pipeline at a good cadence. Sarah Bond has been dismal leading hardware and game pass, and it wouldn’t surprise me if she’s being encouraged to find a new position elsewhere.
Matt Booty has been with MS since 2010 and they are just NOW finally running as intended with a pipeline of mediocre underachieving games under his belt? Please! He deserves to go down in flames. He also ran Midway into the ground.

But he had the brilliant strategy of spending Sony out of business and that clearly worked out well didn't it?
 

Det

Member
I noticed the silence shortly after the transition to third-party started. He stepped back out of the spotlight and wasn't heard from for months.

I think he stepped back for three main reasons:

1. He doesn't want to answer hard questions that might put him in a bad light (e.g., complaints from the Xbox fans, dwindling console sales, sending more games to Playstation than he indicated, stagnation of GP, etc.).

2. The purpose of his PR junkets was to promote GP and the console. MS is floundering on both of those fronts. If Phil does more cheerleading on that, it won't help.

3. His enthusiasm is down. Phil's vision was that GP was going to be a big success, and so was Xbox (the console). That hasn't come to pass. Although Xbox gamers have saved a lot of money, Phil vision has largely been a flop and has contributed to the downfall of the console. Phil is an optimist, but even he must realize that things didn't work out as he hoped. And he is not happy about it. He's not that excited about the direction of the company now. He doesn't feel motivated to go out there and promote it.


I think they cut his "personal" marketing budget, the marketing he did as a cult of his own personality.

In addition to the end of the "xbox ambassadors" program, the repercussion of the interviews, of what he talks about, is much smaller because there aren't a bunch of "BOTs" paid to keep echoing what Phill says.

This interview with IGN is an example, there were people in the audience being paid to applaud everything Phill said, this costs money. They even applauded when he spoke about the closing of Tango 🤡🤡🤡🤡


On top of that, this interview wasn't talked about for a week, a month... No one said "but what about Sony?" The "impact" that Phill had when he spoke was never organic, it was always manufactured.
If he gives an interview now, he doesn't have the budget to pay for fake applause, much less his Twitter bots to give relevance to what he says.

The impression I have is that Phill wanted to continue appearing, speaking, and getting attention and he even tried to continue doing so, but without money to inflate the relevance of what he said, no one cared. Between talking and everyone realizing he's irrelevant and staying quiet living from the "past where he had attention", it's better to stay silent pretending that his relevance was organic.

 
Last edited:

Crayon

Member
I think they cut his "personal" marketing budget, the marketing he did as a cult of his own personality.

In addition to the end of the "xbox ambassadors" program, the repercussion of the interviews, of what he talks about, is much smaller because there aren't a bunch of "BOTs" paid to keep echoing what Phill says.

This interview with IGN is an example, there were people in the audience being paid to applaud everything Phill said, this costs money. They even applauded when he spoke about the closing of Tango 🤡🤡🤡🤡


On top of that, this interview wasn't talked about for a week, a month... No one said "but what about Sony?" The "impact" that Phill had when he spoke was never organic, it was always manufactured.
If he gives an interview now, he doesn't have the budget to pay for fake applause, much less his Twitter bots to give relevance to what he says.

The impression I have is that Phill wanted to continue appearing, speaking, and getting attention and he even tried to continue doing so, but without money to inflate the relevance of what he said, no one cared. Between talking and everyone realizing he's irrelevant and staying quiet living from the "past where he had attention", it's better to stay silent pretending that his relevance was organic.


candace-cameron-bure-im-afraid-that-its-true-upyps47zfqelppu3.gif



On my list of reasons I hate ms, which I curate daily in a type of meditation, this online presence in console wars is always near the top. It started right from the beginning thanks to Halloween-paper tactics being in the DNA over there. 20 years starting with straight up paid fakes eventually evolving into a borderline cult.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Det
Top Bottom