• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

*** The GAF Precognitive Review Score Project ***

1. Final Fantasy 12. 92%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 91%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 86%
4. Geist. 82%
5. Rumble Roses. 74%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 64%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 91%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 89%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 88%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 99%
 

soul.less

Banned
1. Final Fantasy 12. 96%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 97%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 88%
4. Geist. 81%
5. Rumble Roses. 79%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 75%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 96%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 93%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 94%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 100%
 
1. Final Fantasy 12. 91%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 83%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 79%
4. Geist. 84%
5. Rumble Roses. 79%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 70%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 90%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 88%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 92%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 97%
 

mrklaw

MrArseFace
1. Final Fantasy 12 65%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 65%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 75%
4. Geist. 75%
5. Rumble Roses. 55%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 60%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 80%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 90%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 65%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube 90%
 

john tv

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12 - 100
2. Dragon Quest 8 - 100
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat - 100
4. Geist - 0
5. Rumble Roses - 0
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations - 0
7. Super Mario 64x4 - 100
8. Ridge Racers (PSP) - 100
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2 - 0
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube - 100

My scale ranges from "Going to Play" (100) to "Not Going to Play" (0)

Very simple and effective!
 
1. Final Fantasy 12. 90%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 85%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 74%
4. Geist. 75%
5. Rumble Roses. 62%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 70%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 93%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 78%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 91%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 95%
 

Amir0x

Banned
1. Final Fantasy 12: While the storyline still leaves something to be desired, the new action type almost MMORPG-like battle system and brilliant score catapult it to a special place in my heart. 88%

2. Dragon Quest 8: I finish the 8th game in the Dragon Quest series still wondering why this is so big in Japan. 75%

3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat: Interesting concept, decent execution, but ultimately repetitive and lacking depth. 68%

4. Geist: Everything about this game manages to disappoint, yet not at the magnitude people are expecting. 64%

5. Rumble Roses: 74%

6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations: 79%

7. Super Mario 64x4: While not quite managing to recreate the initial magic felt by the Nintendo 64's flagship release, it still holds up well by todays standards and with the 36 new mini-games has fresh, new life on the Nintendo DS. 90%

8. Ridge Racers (PSP): The visuals manage to blow my mind, especially in handheld format, and the gameplay manages to maintain all the best features of the series over the years. The addition of nitro is welcome, yet unoriginal. In fact, not much of this game feels new or special, disappointing me somewhat. 83%

9. Knights of the Old Republic 2: Another great RPG, but not much new here. 89%

10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube: Defying everyone who thought it'd be "yet another Zelda game", the developing geniuses at Nintendo manage to innovate both artistically and through the games gameplay. Horse battling ends up more fun than we all expect. This time Link plays a Ocalute, some odd combination of Lute and Ocarina. This infuses the game with yet another interesting yet quirky feature that allows it to feel fresh. 96%
 
1. Final Fantasy 12. B+
2. Dragon Quest 8. B-
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. B
4. Geist. F-
5. Rumble Roses. F+
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. F--
7. Super Mario 64x4. C+
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). C
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. D
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. A+
 

AniHawk

Member
john tv said:
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2 - 0
My scale ranges from "Going to Play" (100) to "Not Going to Play" (0)

Very simple and effective!

I no longer consider you my son.
 

mumu

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12. 88%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 82%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 80%
4. Geist. 70%
5. Rumble Roses. 55%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 65%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 86%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 71%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 90%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 99%
 

ninge

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12 - 90% (new combat system is teh suck but it looks pretty)
2. Dragon Quest 8 - 96% (superlatives a-go-go, japan goes nuts)
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. - 90 % (great but gimicky and short lived)
4. Geist. - 88 % (not a bad game, few problems tho that drag it down)
5. Rumble Roses. - 85 % (dont really know much about this one but i expect wrestling fans will love it)
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. - 76 % (not what we want hence shite, too simple etc "teh kiddy")
7. Super Mario 64x4. - 90 % (a great game, nice additions but old and seen before)
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). - 86 % (rushed to market, battery killer, nitro sucks, seen it all before)
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. - 91 % (a solid sequal but must try harder next time)
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. - 99 % (best game ever! nintendo are back etc followed by two years of more average games)
 

Fifty

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12 - Two Apples
2. Dragon Quest 8 - An Orange
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. - Christopher Meloni
4. Geist. - 4
5. Rumble Roses. - No
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. - 68 Diet Sprites
7. Super Mario 64x4. - Man in the yellow hat
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). - n/a
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. - Sir Sean Connery
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. - Two cups of Tingle's semen
 
1. Final Fantasy 12-85%
2. Dragon Quest 8-80%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat-95%
4. Geist-75%
5. Rumble Roses-65%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations-65%
7. Super Mario 64x4-90%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP)-80%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2-85%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube-100%
 
1. Final Fantasy 12.
93%
2. Dragon Quest 8.
91%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat.
84%
4. Geist.
76%
5. Rumble Roses.
72%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations.
79%
7. Super Mario 64x4.
85%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP).
83%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2.
92%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube.
93%
 

u_neek

Junior Member
1. Final Fantasy 12. 97%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 92%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 80%
4. Geist. 70%
5. Rumble Roses. 82%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 56%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 87%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 90%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 82%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 95%
 

shibbs

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12. - 94
2. Dragon Quest 8. - 92
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. - 88
4. Geist. - 80
5. Rumble Roses. - 83
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. - 88
7. Super Mario 64x4. - 93
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). - 90
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. - 91
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. - 98
 

FnordChan

Member
book125-1.gif


Gaze with me into the future! I see...I see numbers rising up from the mists of time!

1. Final Fantasy 12 - 92%
2. Dragon Quest 8 - 85%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat - 80%
4. Geist - 75%
5. Rumble Roses - 75%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations - 80%
7. Super Mario 64x4 - 85%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP) - 95%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2 - 90%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube - 90%

FnordChan, the Wizard of Speed and Time

Edit: Alright, alright, I'll play fair. Scores edited to represent my own, barely educated opinion. Woo!
 
1. Final Fantasy 12. 93%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 86
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 84%
4. Geist. 82%
5. Rumble Roses. 78%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 70%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 87
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 85%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 92%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 96%
 

SantaC

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12. 95%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 90%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 90%
4. Geist. 72%
5. Rumble Roses. 69%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 82%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 87%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 79%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 91%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 97.5%
 
1. Final Fantasy 12. 90%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 94%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 90%
4. Geist. 75%
5. Rumble Roses. 45%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 60%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 95%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 80%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 95%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 100%
 

User 406

Banned
1. Final Fantasy 12. 0%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 0%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 0%
4. Geist. 0%
5. Rumble Roses. 0%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 0%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 0%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 0%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 0%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 0%
11. DYNASTY WARRIORS FOR PLAYSTATION 3 100% (AVERAGE SCORE: 100%/1 = 100% OFFICIAL GAF BEST GAME EVER)

Drinky Crow said:
I will give a copy of Outrun 2

Don't you threaten ME, you son of a bitch. >:|
 

Overseer

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12. 95%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 88%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 61%
4. Geist. 42%
5. Rumble Roses. 77%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 2%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 94%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 88%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 86%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 100%
 

Belfast

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12. 94%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 87%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 78%
4. Geist. 73%
5. Rumble Roses. 75%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 65%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 91%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 84%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 95%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 97%
 

Sullichin

Member
This would be cooler if these games were released, like we rate the big November games etc.

1. Final Fantasy 12 85%
2. Dragon Quest 8 85%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat 94%
4. Geist 80%
5. Rumble Roses 50%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations 75%
7. Super Mario 64x4 95%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP) 81%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2 80%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube 99%
 
1. Final Fantasy 12. - 89%
2. Dragon Quest 8. - 81%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 75%
4. Geist. 77%
5. Rumble Roses. 75%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 62%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 85%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 88%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 91%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 94%

I REALLY hope that i'm wrong on Geist
 

Acrylamid

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12. - 79%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 89%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 81%
4. Geist. 71%
5. Rumble Roses. 69%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 69%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 91%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 89%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 89%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 100%
11. DYNASTY WARRIORS FOR PLAYSTATION 3 49%

If I had an Xbox and/or were interested in Outrun 2, I would have waited as long as possible to calculate the average scores and use these scores...
 

Xizk

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12. 94%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 92%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 84%
4. Geist. 74%
5. Rumble Roses. 72%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 59%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 96%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 85%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 89%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 97%
 
1. Final Fantasy 12. 92
2. Dragon Quest 8. 94
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 70
4. Geist. 60
5. Rumble Roses. 70
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 65
7. Super Mario 64x4. 85
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 90
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 75
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 95
 
1. Final Fantasy 12. 50%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 50%
3. Donkey Kong Jungle Beat. 0%
4. Geist. 0%
5. Rumble Roses. 100%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 0%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 0%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 100%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 0%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 0%
11. Metal Gear Acid. 1000%

Games rated on the likelyhood of SSX running annoying damage control for them.
 

Dave Long

Banned
These are the GAF's only true scores.

1. Final Fantasy 12. 92% (FF fans enjoy it. The Matsuno fans go apeshit and everyone else hates the main character with a passion)
2. Dragon Quest 8. 94% (Finally a breakthrough for this series in the US. GAF is pleased.)
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 92% (if an extra peripheral were not required, it would score higher. GAF screams GIMMICK!)
4. Geist. 83% (It can't overcome the hate.)
5. Rumble Roses. 80% (boobies giveth but also taketh away from the final score. It's prudes vs. porn fans!)
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 56% (OMG WTF?!)
7. Super Mario 64x4. 87% (Nfans back it. Haters claim it's nothing new. This works for any Nintendo release BTW)
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 85% (Namco fucks it up again. 85 tantamount to a 0 at GAF)
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 97% (Xbots and PC gamers drive it to heights of complete and probably unwarranted stardom)
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 98% (The one game that everyone will agree rules the world)

I'd really like to win that Outrun 2. :)
 
1. Final Fantasy 12 20%
2. Dragon Quest 8 30%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 70%
4. Geist. 70%
5. Rumble Roses 10%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations 15%
7. Super Mario 64x4 100%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP) 50%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2 70%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube 100%
 

Rei_Toei

Fclvat sbe Pnanqn, ru?
1. Final Fantasy 12 - 96%
2. Dragon Quest 8 - 92%
3. Donkey King's Jungle Beat - 70%
4. Geist - 61%
5. Rumble Roses - 53%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations - 82%
7. Super Mario 64x4 - 68% :D
8. Ridge Racers (PSP) - 89%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2 - 93%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube - 90%
 

Gek54

Junior Member
1. Final Fantasy 12 - 96%
2. Dragon Quest 8 - 92%
3. Donkey King's Jungle Beat - 70%
4. Geist - 61%
5. Rumble Roses - 53%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations - 82%
7. Super Mario 64x4 - 68% :D
8. Ridge Racers (PSP) - 89%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2 - 93%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube - 90%
 

shpankey

not an idiot
1. Final Fantasy 12 - 91
2. Dragon Quest 8 - 89
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat - 79
4. Geist - 77
5. Rumble Roses - 76
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations - 78
7. Super Mario 64x4 - 93
8. Ridge Racers (PSP) - 88
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2 - 94
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube - 98
 

6.8

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12 - 6/7 = 85,714285714285714285714285714286 %
2. Dragon Quest 8 - 6/7 = 85,714285714285714285714285714286 %
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat - 4/7 = 57,142857142857142857142857142857 %
4. Geist - 3/7 = 42,857142857142857142857142857143 %
5. Rumble Roses - 3/7 = 42,857142857142857142857142857143 %
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations - 2/7 = 0,28571428571428571428571428571429 %
7. Super Mario 64x4 - 5/7 = 71,428571428571428571428571428571 %
8. Ridge Racers (PSP) - 5/7 = 71,428571428571428571428571428571 %
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2 - 5/7 = 71,428571428571428571428571428571 %
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube - 6.5/7 = 92,857142857142857142857142857143 %
 

ElyrionX

Member
1. Final Fantasy 12. 92%
2. Dragon Quest 8. 87%
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat. 78%
4. Geist. 82%
5. Rumble Roses. 76%
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations. 88%
7. Super Mario 64x4. 93%
8. Ridge Racers (PSP). 86%
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2. 90%
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube. 96%
 
carson.jpg


Final Fantasy XII -- 94%
Dragon Quest VIII -- 79%
Donkey Kong Jungle Beat -- 82%
Geist -- 74%
Rumble Roses -- 76%
Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations -- 68%
Super Mario 64x4 -- 94%
Ridge Racer (PSP) -- 77%
Knights of the Old Republic 2 88%
The Legend of Zelda 2005 97%
 

Razoric

Banned
1. Final Fantasy 12.(100%)
2. Dragon Quest 8.(85%)
3. Donkey Kong's Jungle Beat.(60%)
4. Geist.(60%)
5. Rumble Roses.(60%)
6. Virtua Fighter: Cyber Generations.(20%)
7. Super Mario 64x4.(10%)
8. Ridge Racers (PSP).(60%)
9. Knights of the Old Republic 2.(100%)
10. The Legend of Zelda Gamecube.(90%)
 
Top Bottom