-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Arkham Asylum Mafia |OT| It's time to kill the Bat
- Thread starter franconp
- Start date
Look I already explained why you are scum. If we believe you it means Time's power essentially granted Scum 2 free kills with the cage match and their night kill. I see no way Time is scum if all 4 cage match participants are town.
What does this even mean. You like to win, that's it.
And I know what red checks I got. Again, if I was scum trying to get someone else lynched there were plenty of better targets out there for that.
I have an established pattern of going out of my way to delay my win to help a neutral win. You are also well aware that is aided with town much more than I should have in NX.
Also plural checks?
Typo, sorry
Posts like these lead me to believe you either aren't paying attention or you have been coasting scum the entire game.
Faddy has pointed this out like twenty times. Lynching Fireblend and then having Sorian shoot me works best. If you lynch me today and Fireblend turns out to be lying (he is), Sorian now can't shoot him because it means Fireblend is indeed batman. So Sorian shoots someone else, who may or may not be scum, Sorian wins, scum kills another town, and now we're at 2v2 and we lose. So you are either willing to risk the whole game on me being scum, you just aren't paying attention, or your scum yourself trying desperately to save Fire.
Hey Fire, who are you green checks again? Faddy, Bronx, Fat and Penguin, right?
For the record, now that I know Fireblend is scum, I think it's Fire and Bronx scumteam. After Sorian shoots me tonight, keep that in mind.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Yeah, it makes sense to lynch Fire today. Even if we're wrong it gives us a lot of info.
Vote: Fireblend
Vote: Fireblend
No it doesn't make sense and it doesn't give you more info than what I've already given you. Please, at least someone refute my suggestion, not just agree with Sorian because of some presumed neutral goodwill.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
I'm probably the last neutral fan out there, but if we can end the game tonight, then it's​ worth a shot.
And even without the red check there's evidence against Fire. The weird check on weemad, for one. His continued survival, for another. It does seem odd to have a scum cop and neutral cop in this game, but it happens.
Besides, the number of remaining players is small enough that barely anyone else needs to be checked. So from a utility perspective, we don't really need a cop anymore.
And even without the red check there's evidence against Fire. The weird check on weemad, for one. His continued survival, for another. It does seem odd to have a scum cop and neutral cop in this game, but it happens.
Besides, the number of remaining players is small enough that barely anyone else needs to be checked. So from a utility perspective, we don't really need a cop anymore.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Unvote
This makes so little sense now that I re-read it. "If Sorian is lying about you being scum then you should totally trust him to be on town's side and shoot Time tonight!".
How about refuting the arguments that you are scum.
Why do you think Fireblend is Town?
I believe in his checks.
The possibility is there and everyone is aware of it but most are also just wanting Fire to actually defend himself instead of trying to pass the buck to me (like you are lol). Fire has no reason to be trying to get me lynched, he has a straight confirmation at scum which is better than even I can claim because while it's extremely unlikely that my kill was stopped in another way, we are still in role madness. He's all about self preservation at this point.
Also, again, why do I care about swerving tonight. The majority wants Time dead, even Time is fine dying. I don't give a fuck, as long as two people die tonight, I'm out.
While you are here Bronx, why didn't you vote on Day 6? You were in the thread with just over half an hour to go, the vote was tied. Please explain.
I had to run errands at the last second and missed out on the vote.
Now let's count up.
There's 8 of us left. We've already killed 3 scum and one neutral was killed. There is another neutral among us. I doubt that in a 24 player game there's 5 scum and 2 neutrals, so that would mean there's 1 scum left. If we lynch the right scum today, the game ends immediately with 7 players left and town wins.
Game ends today with 7 players and town wins.
You know who doesn't win? Sorian. Who needs 5 players left to win.
So I ask, what possible reason would Sorian have to help us lynch correctly today?
My greater point is this: Sorian and Fireblend both know who the last scum is - Timeaisis. Fire knows that if we lynch him, we win and go home. Sorian knows that if Time is lynched, he automatically loses. That's why he doesn't want Time lynched today. He needs one more night to buy him and scum some time so they can pull off their kills, Sorian wins, and Town is basically shot in the foot.
We can't let that happen. We have to hit Time NOW, not "let Sorian take care of him tonight".
Newsflash! Sorian can't be trusted! No matter what he tells you, he literally does not have town's best interests at heart. Fire, put your vote back on Timeaisis now, PLEASE.
We can't let that happen. We have to hit Time NOW, not "let Sorian take care of him tonight".
Newsflash! Sorian can't be trusted! No matter what he tells you, he literally does not have town's best interests at heart. Fire, put your vote back on Timeaisis now, PLEASE.
There is definitely 2 scum left. I'm not buying 3 scum and a secret partner. Not enough imo.
Could there be another neutral? Maybe. Perhaps Penguin is neutral, win a certain number of bets to win. But then it is currently 4-2-2. If we go with lynching Fire and Time, one is definitely scum, Sorian leaves and scum kill leaves us 2-1-1. Maybe Penguin wins, leaving us 2 v 1.
Still think we are proceeding in the best way.
Not answering the questions.
You realise if you are town you are doing scum's job for them while Lone_Prodigy is just sitting tight.
Why are you sure there is only 1 scum left?
4 scum, 1 hidden partner, and 2 neutrals is almost 30% of the game roster. Town would basically be screwed from the start.
The Neutral team scum hunts up to a certain point, though.
Not to mention the plethora of protective roles we have. Verelios reviver, Nudull/weemad doctor, Flush bodyguard, Penguin gamble Bulletproof, Bronx natural BP, Batsnacks item giver (BP vest).
This is a dumb point and we both know it. Ignoring the very specific task the neutral team had, trying to pretend that it's scum+neutral vs. town always is being purposely dense.
I'm not lying. There is a minute chance you are town and that's fine but the doctor is dead, two roleblockers are dead, the person handing out BPs is dead, and half of those don't even matter because I got refunded a shot which means I either didn't act (roleblocked) or I targeted Batman. I'm not siding with anyone, I gave my info for a price and have accepted the rest of the terms with it. Sides don't matter to me at this point. I was here to equalize the teams and that's what I did.
Why unvote? Firebland has called you out as scum. He has green checks on me, penguin and Bronx. Fat is town confirmed, Sorian is neutral.
Ergo you and Time are scum unless you believe Bronx's assertion that there is one scum left.
Bronx's assertion is funny now that I'm sitting thinking on it. Why does it matter if Time is the only scum even if I do decide to be a dick for no reason? You'd still just be 3v1 tomorrow in that case and Fire would be dead with a red check on Time. Town wins automatically anyway. At least Fire is fear mongering from a position that actually makes slight sense.
You know what Sorian, I will let you live the dream. I think you should shoot Bronx. He is far too compromised now with these dumb arguments. He will almost 100% be lynched tomorrow. At least Time vs L_P will have a real argument.
If it's all the same, I'm happier with the Time shot. Time is a good enough compromise where he might be scum but probably isn't and I don't really want to be the one to end the game because I get screwed here at the end if scum misses their shot for whatever reason and I'm left with the last scum member's head on my plate.
Bronx is who I shoot if I do actually want to kill probably scum and end the game.
Bronx is who I shoot if I do actually want to kill probably scum and end the game.
Oh dear lord Bronx. You just said you believed Fireblend's checks. I got a GREEN check. I'm town.
Then you know I did as well. So why even sugggest lynching me?
Because I believe Fireblend is a liar.
So you ARE scum.
Well then I would need to be scum with Fireblend. So why don't you vote to hammer a scum and we can debate my bussing on the next day.