Is the game actually good now or is it good as in "it's not a tragedy like it released. they turned it into a playable thing but the real problems still persist"?
As someone with 250h in i can tell you that there are still a lot, really a lot, of issues.
Still lot of stability issues on my end (7950X3D/4090). Sometimes i can play 5h straight without any issue, another time game crash every 30 minutes
Awful (really awful) AI. All ennemies are stupid AF, the police appears out of nowhere when hitting someone who happened to jump in front of your car. NPCs are generic idiots.
Gigs & secondary quests all share the same design : Go into building with the same props, cameras, do the same stuff, go out. It's far from the beautiful side content from The Witcher serie.
Lots of minor bugs that adds up to sometimes a very frustrating experience : Flying NPCs, traffic cars going on mayhem for no reason.
As a former high level chivalry player, melee counter/parry is a clusterfuck and completely broken. Edit : I mean timing is shit.
... And yet i'm 250h in because it has an incredible genuine dystopian Blade Runner feel, with lots of good moments, lots of story moments even made me shed tears because they are genuinely describing the future of mankind and the void our entire generation experience.
Some characters are very attaching and well developed.
The city itself and it's outskirts are amazing to play with. Jumping everywhere quickly becomes an addiction
Multiple way to play, slicing ennemies with the katana at end level is fun AF, some firing weapons are great. Stealth is also a thing but ends up being extremely time consuming though.
4 endings to discover.
It's a complete love-hate relationship, like the girlfriend you argue with everyday but still end up loving.