Catching up on this thread...
I try not to complain too much about content or lack thereof because 1) the duders keep a close eye on this thread and I don't want to hurt their feelings and 2) $35/yr (I only buy Premium on sale) is stupid cheap on a $/hour basis. Like, I enjoy UPF, so that's 2 hours of entertainment a week at minimum, plus whatever other content I end up enjoying.
That being said, this whole KH business is quite disappointing. I've wanted the site to do a playthrough for so long because the batshit insanity makes for great LPs, and their caginess on what the feature actually is quite frustrates me. A bit of clarification would go a long way right now- if it does end up being a joke, it's really not worth it.
The first game isn't also terribly long. They could easily finish it in ~20 hours, especially since they're playing on Normal. While I'd love a look at the entire series (not necessarily play all of it, just do an overview), I would be perfectly fine with just completion of KH1.
I'm not some nutter KH fan. But, this has been my dream feature since I ever started following the site. The way it's being handled kinda hurts.