• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Indiana Jones and The Great Circle | Review Thread

What scores do you think Indiana Jones and The Great Circle will get?

  • 61-64%

    Votes: 11 2.3%
  • 65-69%

    Votes: 9 1.9%
  • 70-74%

    Votes: 30 6.2%
  • 75-79%

    Votes: 79 16.3%
  • 80-84%

    Votes: 209 43.0%
  • 85-89%

    Votes: 116 23.9%
  • 90-94%

    Votes: 24 4.9%
  • 95-100%

    Votes: 8 1.6%

  • Total voters
    486
  • Poll closed .

ArtHands

Thinks buying more servers can fix a bad patch
Why can’t Indiana Jones be a GotY contender? It has got the review scores for it, as well as good users scores. It might not be a massive critical success, or you might personally not enjoy it, but it absolutely meets the needed criteria for a GotY pick.

I don’t personally think it would (or should) win, but I don’t see why a nomination would be off the cards.

Me I am just happy that Microsoft delivered such a gem and make up for Sony’s empty year
 

DenchDeckard

Moderated wildly
You think it’s turd now DenchDeckard DenchDeckard ?

Dude, just a def old priest and a lesbian?

Like these haven't existed for century's?

How much are you willing to scrape the barrel to try and turn this into a sweet baby DEI complaint.

I've played for 25 hours now and there is nothing to the level of spider man 2 in this.

Just stop now.
 
Last edited:

Zathalus

Member
Dude, just a def old priest and a lesbian?

Like these haven't existed for century's?

How much are you willing to scrape the barrel to try and turn this into a sweet baby DEI complaint.

I've played for 25 hours now and there is nothing to the level of spider man 2 in this.

Just stop now.
The haircut statement is particularly funny. Just look up 1930s Italian woman haircuts, tousled short hair was all the rage.
 

DenchDeckard

Moderated wildly
The haircut statement is particularly funny. Just look up 1930s Italian woman haircuts, tousled short hair was all the rage.
jHf933P.jpeg


FUCKING WOKIES RUINING MY GAAAAMEZZZ!
 
Last edited:
Dude, just a def old priest and a lesbian?

Like these haven't existed for century's?

How much are you willing to scrape the barrel to try and turn this into a sweet baby DEI complaint.

I've played for 25 hours now and there is nothing to the level of spider man 2 in this.

Just stop now.

Deaf person AND a lesbian?

John Goodman Reaction GIF


80s for Xbox.
90s if PS exclusive.

the force awakens GIF by Star Wars
 

Rambotito

Member
Thanks for saving me money.
It's not Veilguard bad, though. 90% of it is pure Indiana Jones punching and whipping dudes in the face. I hate DEI, but I don't see an overdose of it in this game. I like how you arrive at Italy in some castle and just start ripping people apart like it's something everyone else does while visiting there.
 

SF Kosmo

Al Jazeera Special Reporter
The PC options
Y'all clearly can’t read. I said kudos to the team for making a good game and that I’d likely buy it

You guys are so desperate that you have to take it to hyperbolic levels claiming it’s GOTY or more ambitious than an ND title.

Just stop. That’s all I’m not crediting it for
So my level headed, console agnostic take, I don't think it's GOTY, but it's pretty reasonably in the top 5, especially as far as AAA goes in a year that didn't have a lot of AAA hits.

But as far as ambition? Yeah I think it's clearly more ambitious than Uncharted, in the sense that it tries a lot of new things and doesn't really fit neatly into an existing genre or formula, which is frankly really rare in the AAA space, and doubly so during a time when the industry is at its most risk averse.
 

PSYGN

Member
I was watching penguinz0 playing it and it looked so bad. The AI was dumb as rocks and they didn't even look at him as he was grappling the chandelier with his whip. The whole idea seemed hilarious, in fact the entirety of what I saw seemed pretty silly and unpolished . This looked like a 6/10 game by the 30 min. slice I looked at so I'm actually surprised it is doing so well.
 
Last edited:

Billbofet

Member
2 hours in and loving this. What a wonderful and refreshing experience. Hope it continues to be this awesome throughout. Very impressed and I am a total heathen playing this on a Series S.
 

Topher

Identifies as young
The PC options

So my level headed, console agnostic take, I don't think it's GOTY, but it's pretty reasonably in the top 5, especially as far as AAA goes in a year that didn't have a lot of AAA hits.

But as far as ambition? Yeah I think it's clearly more ambitious than Uncharted, in the sense that it tries a lot of new things and doesn't really fit neatly into an existing genre or formula, which is frankly really rare in the AAA space, and doubly so during a time when the industry is at its most risk averse.

Good summary. Machine Games definitely did more things with Indy than ND did with Uncharted. Each area is a bit of an open world with its own side quests and such. Naughty Dog did some of that with TLOU 2 in that one larger open area. I'd imagine ND would expand on that in their next game much like what MG has done here. That is probably the aspect of Indy I enjoy the most. Combat, not as much, but that isn't to say it is bad either. Just not my personal favorite

I said in the OT that I think it is in my top three behind Metaphor and Astro Bot and I'm sticking with that so far. I think it certainly will win some GOTY from some outlets, especially Xbox aligned ones. At the same time, I'm wondering what the hell happened with Pure Xbox. 6/10? That's crazy.
 

FunkMiller

Member
I remain impressed by the PC optimisation here. With everything maxxed out I get a comfortable 60fps on quiet mode on my laptop (Legion Pro w/ 7945hx and 4090) This is in contrast to most new games that struggle with this when maxxed out. Bump up to auto or performance mode and I'm over 90 all the time.
 

DenchDeckard

Moderated wildly
Like a deaf girl in SM2? Just stop

You mean Black deaf girl with half a shaved head that speaks in sign language and paints murals of black lives matter and other political DEI stuff all over the game.

I actually don't think you guys have the ability to see the difference of Sony games that are swamped with pride flags, black lives matter and LGBTQ+ forced messaging vs this.

You are genuinely embarassing yourself dude.

Plus, none of the above actually bothered me in spider man 2. I have said this. I found the Peter parker and Mary Jane power struggle much worse.
 
You mean Black deaf girl with half a shaved head that speaks in sign language and paints murals of black lives matter and other political DEI stuff all over the game.

I actually don't think you guys have the ability to see the difference of Sony games that are swamped with pride flags, black lives matter and LGBTQ+ forced messaging vs this.

You are genuinely embarassing yourself dude.

Plus, none of the above actually bothered me in spider man 2. I have said this. I found the Peter parker and Mary Jane power struggle much worse.

Jimmy Fallon No GIF by The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon
 
Top Bottom