"Hold up well?" Halo 2 got good ratings, but its image in the community wasn't exactly pristine in 2004. Not with all the weird expectations, and the still-massive shadow of Halo 1. My core opinion of Halo 2 hasn't changed much at all over the years, but it's a lot easier to be nice to its campaign today than it was in 2004.
Im aware, but it was even more inconsistent then I remembered (I played through it at the beginning of the year.)
For every this:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/333c4/333c434288a88ad4e80cb8e5a8a347308132572e" alt="snap002.jpg"
Or:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5854d/5854dfa3815eec1c6122fd79cbd064fbfef9b101" alt="snap053.jpg"
You had some ugly, non-fun areas. Damn me for only uploading mostly nice shots hah.