• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Outer Range Trailer - Josh Brolin, Imogen Poots

DragoonKain

Neighbours from Hell
Wow. Haven’t seen Imogen Poots in anything in a while, I like her. My backlog is too long right now for this show though. Will watch it 28 weeks later.
 

AJUMP23

Parody of actual AJUMP23
I'm no poker stud but
didn't his 2 pair beat her hand regardless? Not sure why he had the cheat card. May e she came out with a straight ir something?
HE had a full house which beat her straight flush. but the 2 pair would not have beat the straight. He needed the full house.
 

daveonezero

Banned
I like the show and love Brolin, but I hate the trope that someone discovers something amazing and keeps it for themselves / tries to hide it for whatever bullshit reason.
Yep. Menetioned this earlier. Hate that. The show is only going because he doesn’t tell anyone.

It would be better if he told his family and they were all sort of dealing with it.
 
Last edited:

jason10mm

Gold Member
Yep. Menetioned this earlier. Hate that. The show is only going because he doesn’t tell anyone.

It would be better if he told his family and they were all sort of dealing with it.
Agreed. But then the show would require a science oriented writer instead of the interpersonal conflict interested one we have. Somehow I'm beginning to doubt that a quantum physics PhD was consulted on this project.
 
All 8 episodes episodes of S1 are available now for those interested. I enjoyed it. Had a Western Twin Peaks feel.

While there are parts that are extremely slow and not worthwhile, I think the main drama is great, edge of your seat stuff. Basically, whenever Brolin is on screen, it's a great fucking show. Every two episodes gets a new director, which explains the inconsistency. Imo, episodes 5 and 6 are garbage compared to the rest (especially 5). Season finale has one hell of a cliff hanger and a lot of No Country For Old Men vibes.
 

AJUMP23

Parody of actual AJUMP23
There is a great reveal about a Rollins character. But I found the show pretty interesting 75% of the time.

The one guy singing all the time was weird.

he was born in 1886


When Poots and her man are making out. That was a choice. Looks like 2 people that have never kissed.
 
Last edited:

Mossybrew

Gold Member
While there are parts that are extremely slow and not worthwhile, I think the main drama is great, edge of your seat stuff. Basically, whenever Brolin is on screen, it's a great fucking show. Every two episodes gets a new director, which explains the inconsistency. Imo, episodes 5 and 6 are garbage compared to the rest (especially 5). Season finale has one hell of a cliff hanger and a lot of No Country For Old Men vibes.

Yeah, there were slow aspects, I think especially Rhett and that girl he was crushing on, that whole storyline was a snoozefest and could have been entirely cut. Probably too much time dedicated to Rhett's rodeo shit overall too. But man the good weird stuff just got better as the show went along, this was overall a really fun and unique show. Though, I did see that one finale "reveal" coming a long time ago, so no surprise there - though Royal's reveal about his origin was unexpected. Really hope this gets a second season.
 
Last edited:
When Poots and her man are making out. That was a choice. Looks like 2 people that have never kissed.


Every time the singing guy and Autumn were on screen together it felt like a completely different show. In a bad way.

Yeah, there were slow aspects, I think especially Rhett and that girl he was crushing on, that whole storyline was a snoozefest and could have been entirely cut. Probably too much time dedicated to Rhett's rodeo shit overall too. But man the good weird stuff just got better as the show went along, this was overall a really fun and unique show. Though, I did see that one finale "reveal" coming a long time ago, so no surprise there - though Royal's reveal about his origin was unexpected. Really hope this gets a second season.


Agreed. A few of the side stories went nowhere and weren't interesting in the least bit. Thankfully, the main story was good enough to make me power through them. Actually, I began to fast forward through most of the side stories and it made little difference in the end. I'm also hoping we get a second season. So many questions left unanswered.
 

Valonquar

Member
I went into this show suspecting full well it would end without closure, and I wasn't wrong. This better get a 2nd season. The singing was really out of place with the rest of the show, and the gross kissing close-ups too. Everything else was great.
 
Last edited:

IntentionalPun

Ask me about my wife's perfect butthole
I went into this show suspecting full well it would end without closure, and I wasn't wrong. This better get a 2nd season. The singing was really out of place with the rest of the show, and the gross kissing close-ups too. Everything else was great.
The singing was amazing to me lol

Shows how batshit insane that character is.. the delusions of grandeur stuff fit right in with it to me. Dude is super into himself.
 
Last edited:

jason10mm

Gold Member
It got a second season?

What about that J.K. Simmons show (Dark Sky?).

I feel betrayed by this latest round of "prestige sci-fi" that turns out to be just quirky characters and melodrama.

Peacock better not f'up TEACUP!
 

NotMyProblemAnymoreCunt

Biggest Trails Stan
Yvonne is soooooo StraHOTski in it! How has that girl aged like fine wine!

I'm a big fan of the book it's based on
(and why that wasn't publized more is a mystery) so i have high hopes for it. If I like the next couple of eps I may even start a thread for it.

That's what I wanted to ask if it's based off a book. So far I'm surprised by how good the show is. I might just start reading the book soon since it's October
 

Calico345

Gold Member
I wish that shows would stop with the "different director" nonsense. It is bad enough when it is done across seasons, let alone within a season.
 
I wish that shows would stop with the "different director" nonsense. It is bad enough when it is done across seasons, let alone within a season.
That's just how most TV shows are produced. Even a legendary show like Breaking Bad had multiple directors in one season. If I had to guess, it's probably just a matter of efficiency since they have to film x amount of hours per season.
 

StueyDuck

Member
Shame that it was cancelled, although it did love to linger a little too much.

There is a fine line to balance between mystery and satisfaction, I thought the show did an ok job at it, but obviously it didn't do it well enough.

this is the nature with Sci-fi though, you either get one or two seasons or you are stupidly successful, there's no real middleground.
 

jason10mm

Gold Member
this is the nature with Sci-fi though, you either get one or two seasons or you are stupidly successful, there's no real middleground.
Thats mostly due to the cost of sci-fi shows, traditionally they were always on the higher end so they had to hit big or get wrapped up.

But my issue these days is the number of shows that seem like they were pitched like this:
writer: "Hey exec, I want to make a show about a dad who lost his son, in a tragic way that we will stretch out over 3 seasons, as he processes his grief he meets lots of other very damaged people, all with mysterious pasts we will stretch out over 4 seasons, and eventually they all love or hate each other."

Exec: "Awesome! But no one is gonna watch that shit! We need a hook to bring in a desperate audience that always shows up for their stuff and thats the sci-fi genre audience! So you need to add a genre hook to your show."

writer: "Uh, ok. How about if the dad is actually a werewolf? We will show him change once in the pilot and then NEVER address it till the season finale as a cliffhanger. We will not explore werewolf lore, have him try to find a cure, embrace his nature, or really do ANYTHING about lycanthropy (I'm shocked I even know this word!!) and I won't change anything about my scripts other than about 5 seconds of teaser every few eps to string this genre audience along."

Exec: "PERFECT! Lets order a full season!"

Thats my beef with a lot of the recent genre stuff. They do very little with the hook, its just set dressing around their character based mysteries and drama. Now obviously any sci-fi concept needs human conflict and emotion to sustain it, but the difference between a show like Stargate, which explores the gates and their ramifications CONSTANTLY even while it develops the dynamics of the cast (but has a proper ensemble composition and isn't relying on constant mystery boxes to fuel audience engagement) and a lot of the recent "prestige genre" shows is glaring.
 
Top Bottom