-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
The Michael Fassbender's android was also the highlight of Covenant as well. By intention from the Android's POV.
It should not have been a repeat in this one.
Last edited:
Big Baller
Al Pachinko, Konami President
I would entrust Alvarez to direct a sequel to Event Horizon 2.
Just let him do his thing and he will come up with something really good.
ForAcademicPurposes
Member
Miller is long gone. Either that, or he is being tortured in the darkest dimensions. The ultimate sacrifice for his crew. Stark, Justin, and Cooper.
Last edited:
ForAcademicPurposes
Member
Try writing a script for Event Horizon 2, dawg.
I honestly, couldn't do it.
I honestly, couldn't do it.
Last edited:
Alex11
Member
Fuck, I would kill for a sequel to Event Horizon, but not from Fede.I would entrust Alvarez to direct a sequel to Event Horizon 2.
Just let him do his thing and he will come up with something really good.
Also it may be an unpopular opinion, but IMO, Event Horizon is a better movie than Alien Romulus.
ForAcademicPurposes
Member
I don't disagree with you. Event Horizon is original but is clearly inspired by the ALIEN crew. That said, the casting choice for EH was on the money.
Romulus is a culmination of set designs (and ALIEN: Isolation) and then stitches them together pretty well. Which is a challenge in it of itself. It is really fucking difficult to make an ALIEN sequel in this day and age and I respect.
But the crew is not memorable at all. I couldn't name any of them from the top of my head. There's Andy....
Last edited:
Alex11
Member
I agree with this line, but it's not impossible, I've said my piece with this movie, I applaud the practical approach and that's about it, the rest is at best bearable on account of seeing the Xenomorph again
The cast didn't bother me, but I agree, it isn't memorable.
Mohonky
Member
Nah, I still have it at;I liked it a lot, yes it has problems, but not as many as Covenant.
My Ranking:
Alien = Alien 2
Romulus
Prometheus
Alien 3
Resurrection
Covenant
I hope there is another in this vein, which could be with theof this one or the inevitable:survivor
Bonus jokes:
This happened because they wanted to escape Latin America.
and
Alien /Aliens
Prometheus / Covenant
Romulus
Alien 3
Alien Resurrection
Don't care about the haters, Pro and Cov still do it for me. Sure there's some serious retardation going on in some of the characters decision making skills, but the movie give really good lore and I love the way they tie in the Engineers and concepts of intervening with Humanity. I find it am interesting concept.
I certainly wasn't disappointed by Romulus, it was much better than Resurrection and Alien 3 in concept and expanding on the Alien lore even if 'we found derelict space station entire company somehow missed so let's take companies ship with no reasonable explanation to loot it' had me trying to figure out how that made any sense.
That ending though, was not expecting that. I loved the tie-in and it was genuinely one of the most nightmarish things to come from the franchise since the original hit the screens. It was quite something and tied well to you know what.
Ulysses 31
Member
I'd rather see the original 2 hour cut of Event Horizon with all the hell sections intact that made the test audience sick than a sequel. Like where could they take the story?
Last edited:
Alex11
Member
I don't know really, it does seem that EH is a standalone type of movie, no?
But it would be possible, as long as it doesn't try to over explain or be full of quotes and similar scenes like Romulus is with the others Alien movies.
xrnzaaas
Member
Finally seen it and it's a 6/10 movie, probably on par with the first Prometheus. I loved the visuals, but not a fan of the cast (the black kid was by far the worst) or the story in general.
It's a shame how much the facehuggers got nerfed in the first scene and failed with their first 2 attempts, or how the characters managed to evade xenomorphs so they would be able to activate zero G and attack them without worrying about the acid.
Ripley's one-liner was so bad lol, they weren't even fighting the queen.
I liked the hybrid from the finale (the one from Alien 4 was still better though ;p), but the birth and "reaching maturity" were definitely rushed.
The acid death and cocoon scene were probably the best ones.
Ripley's one-liner was so bad lol, they weren't even fighting the queen.
I liked the hybrid from the finale (the one from Alien 4 was still better though ;p), but the birth and "reaching maturity" were definitely rushed.
The acid death and cocoon scene were probably the best ones.
Last edited:
Lucifers Beard
Member
The Escape Pod Podcast are fucking huffing on some serious shit. It's a really fun movie, but best in the franchise? Sorry, Alien and Aliens are still butting heads over that title.
Insane Metal
Member
Finally saw this and was utterly disappointed. I was hoping this would bring the franchise back to its feet but... nope. Cast was terrible, and the CGI on Ian Holm's face was scorpion king's levels of bad. Jesus Christ!
Last edited:
DragoonKain
Neighbours from Hell
Finally saw it. Liked it, but didn't think it was as good of the hype. Still, I think it's one of the better ones since the first two Alien movies. I'm a sucker for the franchise so I hope they continue to make more because I love the atmosphere and lore.
I think it started off very interesting. Starts at an off planet, and I'm really into the setting and feel of the movie immediately. Then the ship gave me old school Alien vibes. I love the set pieces in these movies. It was also cool to see an old friend. It was tense, it built up slowly, the stuff with the face huggers was really cool. Even tying it into Prometheus with the samples. Then it gradually started to devolve where I thought the second half of the movie was a major drop off and the last act in particular.
It just got way too out of control.
Overall I still enjoyed it, but those are the issues I had with it. I hope they still continue to make more and it actually made me realize how badly I want an open world Alien game where you can explore various locations and planets. If done well, it could be so good.
And Cailee Spaeny can act. She was good in Civil War, she has a bright future.
I think it started off very interesting. Starts at an off planet, and I'm really into the setting and feel of the movie immediately. Then the ship gave me old school Alien vibes. I love the set pieces in these movies. It was also cool to see an old friend. It was tense, it built up slowly, the stuff with the face huggers was really cool. Even tying it into Prometheus with the samples. Then it gradually started to devolve where I thought the second half of the movie was a major drop off and the last act in particular.
It just got way too out of control.
How quickly they went from one alien to dozens of aliens really killed the tense and scary nature of the movie. It's always more tense when there's one imposing threat in a movie that's lurking. They should have based the movie around that. Instead it turned into an action movie at the end. Mowing down hordes of aliens with the rifle made them feel cheap and weak. Dodging acid streams in zero gravity(c'mon), having a hybrid human/alien thing at the end. Kicking the acid pool so it burns through the ship, then it sucks the alien human thing out. They made the acid way too strong in this btw. You had it burning through entire ships in a matter of seconds. These are massive space crafts I'm sure incredibly thick built to withstand space elements and crashes, but somehow killing an alien can burn through an entire foundation of a ship in seconds. C'mon man.
Then somehow it clings on and they're dangling from a ship spiraling toward an asteroid belt and somehow Rain can keep her composure in all this and gather herself and knock it off. By the way, how it wasn't able to break through the glass on her space suit helmet is beyond me, it hit it like 2 or 3 times.
Then somehow it clings on and they're dangling from a ship spiraling toward an asteroid belt and somehow Rain can keep her composure in all this and gather herself and knock it off. By the way, how it wasn't able to break through the glass on her space suit helmet is beyond me, it hit it like 2 or 3 times.
Overall I still enjoyed it, but those are the issues I had with it. I hope they still continue to make more and it actually made me realize how badly I want an open world Alien game where you can explore various locations and planets. If done well, it could be so good.
And Cailee Spaeny can act. She was good in Civil War, she has a bright future.
Last edited:
FunkMiller
Gold Member
Such a tedious exercise in lack of imagination. Any good ideas the movie has are ruined by its inability to create anything resembling an original or compelling story. In a better movie, things like the zero gravity acid blood sequence, the directional rifle, the human genetic manipulation, the way synthetics behave and are programmed… all these things would land a lot better in a film that surrounded them with a compelling narrative.
But no. It’s another evil robot (with Disney’s patented ghoulish cgi resurrection) another final girl in her underwear suiting up sequence, another hybrid end boss, another elevator, another ammo running out sequence, another abandoned facility due to the alien, another decompression climax, ‘get away from her you bitch’ ‘you have my sympathies’ …on and on and on it goes. Like regurgitated food.
But no. It’s another evil robot (with Disney’s patented ghoulish cgi resurrection) another final girl in her underwear suiting up sequence, another hybrid end boss, another elevator, another ammo running out sequence, another abandoned facility due to the alien, another decompression climax, ‘get away from her you bitch’ ‘you have my sympathies’ …on and on and on it goes. Like regurgitated food.
FunkMiller
Gold Member
Last edited:
clarky
Gold Member
“Somehow .. the Event Horizon returned”
Thats how the first film starts though. It would have to be
“Somehow .. the Event Horizon returned.........again”
Fbh
Member
Watch it yesterday and this is pretty much my take too.
There are a few good ideas and interesting concepts but the movie wastes all of them in service of just being another uninspired modern sequel that's constantly pushing for "member berries". Once they enter the ship almost every scene boils down to either "hey remember this from the old movies?" or "Hey remember that scene you liked in the old movies? We did something similar!!!"
Overall I'd say it was still a 6/10 since despite all the flas it entertaining and visually pleasing (aside from the awkwardly de-aged Bilbo)
Hrk69
Member
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25689729/g_alienromulus_3216_5_3d7ca4d9.jpeg)
Alien: Romulus is getting a VHS release
Celebrating 45 years since Alien first (chest) burst into theaters.
www.theverge.com
Last edited:
To be fair, some sort of warp drive tech WOULD continue to be developed, just 'cause the first......100 or so folks to try it all went mad is not reason to dismiss the technology completely :
ForAcademicPurposes
Member
In other news. I disagree with many points in the video. But I'm just happy that it's in development.
Last edited:
The Cockatrice
I'm retarded?
Ill post my thoughts about Romulus here as well since i posted them on the 31 days of horror.
Im not sure where to put it. The goods are that whoever was in charge of the movie atmosphere and the details, they did a great job nailing the props, the sound effects, and environments just like the first movie and the game Alien Isolation. These things are super important for me and it's why I might consider it the third best Alien movie. The actors I didnt like anyone, no one memorable. Im not sold on the main chick yet, but the ending and the floating acid scenes were quite good, although the ending was clearly Ressurection all over again which everyone hated except me. Ill need to rewatch it someday to decide on it, but for now, it was pretty good.
Im not sure where to put it. The goods are that whoever was in charge of the movie atmosphere and the details, they did a great job nailing the props, the sound effects, and environments just like the first movie and the game Alien Isolation. These things are super important for me and it's why I might consider it the third best Alien movie. The actors I didnt like anyone, no one memorable. Im not sold on the main chick yet, but the ending and the floating acid scenes were quite good, although the ending was clearly Ressurection all over again which everyone hated except me. Ill need to rewatch it someday to decide on it, but for now, it was pretty good.
lmimmfn
Member
It was an ok movie, staeted off quite strong but its being said already:
- "get away from her you bitch" or similar in this movie, not needed, original was excellent, this was lame
- acid melting through the Hull in seconds, nope, not from previous movies
- tried to be a mish mash of Alien(horror) and Aliens(All out gunning) and failed at both.
- the human thing was terrible, like some cheap horror movie.
- blatant attempt at Sigourney Weaver strong female character, but the actress wasn't this
- the "bad" android is a terrible cliche in this franchise.
It was one of the better Alien movies is recent years but that's not saying much.
- "get away from her you bitch" or similar in this movie, not needed, original was excellent, this was lame
- acid melting through the Hull in seconds, nope, not from previous movies
- tried to be a mish mash of Alien(horror) and Aliens(All out gunning) and failed at both.
- the human thing was terrible, like some cheap horror movie.
- blatant attempt at Sigourney Weaver strong female character, but the actress wasn't this
- the "bad" android is a terrible cliche in this franchise.
It was one of the better Alien movies is recent years but that's not saying much.
This is my favorite Alien sequel. Nothing really lives up to the originality and polish of the original film but the sequels can still be great.
And yeah that means I prefer this to “Aliens”, which veers too cartoon’ish for my taste and made cannon fodder out of the xenomorphs much too quickly.
And yeah that means I prefer this to “Aliens”, which veers too cartoon’ish for my taste and made cannon fodder out of the xenomorphs much too quickly.
clarky
Gold Member
Nothing wrong with being wrong I guess.
John Marston
GAF's very own treasure goblin
I almost turned it off after this.
AJUMP23
Parody of actual AJUMP23
Ulysses 31
Member
Yeah, should the aliens have been very resistant to pulse rifle fire?
AJUMP23
Parody of actual AJUMP23
Yeah, should the aliens have been very resistant to pulse rifle fire?
They are like bugs, they just keep coming, no matter what you do to stop them they continue to come.
The Cockatrice
I'm retarded?
This is undeniable proof that Alien is the better movie which I've said it a million times. I finally won. Thank you.
Arsic
Loves his juicy stink trail scent
I loved Romulus. Hope we get another one. Haters can suck a dick.
Alien - GOAT
Prometheus/Covenent - Damn Good
Romulus- Fun times at the movies
Every other alien movie - Brain rot . Yes including Aliens. Aliens is a cheesy action movie only fitting its time era. It is not a timeless classic action flick either, and it isn’t a forever movie like the original Alien.
Alien - GOAT
Prometheus/Covenent - Damn Good
Romulus- Fun times at the movies
Every other alien movie - Brain rot . Yes including Aliens. Aliens is a cheesy action movie only fitting its time era. It is not a timeless classic action flick either, and it isn’t a forever movie like the original Alien.
ForAcademicPurposes
Member
Sorry to say this but that is pushing it.
Ulysses 31
Member
And even if he did copy it, he still made an excellent movie with the material.
ForAcademicPurposes
Member
Inspired is the word that I would use. I'm sure Ridley Scott was inspire by something as well. All the greats are.And even if he did copy it, he still made an excellent movie with the material.
Hawking Radiation
Member
The cast looking like teenagers bothered me and took me out of the experience. I just couldn't get passed that. Was hoping for a Dead Space meets Alien Isolation vibe. A movie where the characters are constantly being stalked by these creatures and them having to make use of the environment and tools to survive. I really dislike characters just getting hold of an assault rifle and blasting their way out of danger.
Was a meh movie overall.
Was a meh movie overall.
Last edited:
Puscifer
Member
I'm willing to let anyone have an opinion on whatever film they like but holy shit, dude.
DragoonKain
Neighbours from Hell
They announced a sequel is in the works with the same lead actors.
clarky
Gold Member
The Android was ok, the lead bird was completely forgettable.
Jobs fucked now as Romulus just knicked the best bits from Alien and Aliens but worse. What they going to steal the best from next ? AVP Requiem ? lol.
Last edited:
Who survived from Romulus? The lead girl and...the android? Right? All the others got dusted IIRC. Unless some shit got left on her ship (aka the sole surviving egg from Aliens into Alien3) then not sure how the same shit can happen to the same girl twice!
But overall I'd be down for more of the same, especially if they can shrug off Scott and move away from black goo nonsense and go back to more xeno stuff. I'm unsure what direction they should take, just sticking with horror and having a group of folks have to think their way out of a xeno outbreak is still a pretty damned good foundation for a film.