DownLikeBCPowder
Member
Tetra Master is great. I like Triple Triad better.. but still fun mini game.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
[Rumor]Final Fantasy 9 remake will be turn based, use the ATB gauge, and will be closer to the Crisis Core remake in ambition
Lokaum D+
Member
its no being greed, P5 has an amazing turn based combat, just do something like that, fast paced, great music, elemental weakness focused combat and we all ll hava an amazing modern turne based combat for a FF9 remake.
Historia
Banned
P5 combat is broken, the Royal version is even more broken. Buff/debuff is useless, passive skills are OP. It is just mindless critical/weakness for me. Maybe because the general playerbase are just there for the social dating sims aspect and not the gameplay
Lokaum D+
Member
it dosent need to be the same, but it can be used as a base for a fast and more dinamic turn based combat, thats what i m saying.
DownLikeBCPowder
Member
It can be improved without turning it into an action game.
Seyken
Member
Yeah, Zidane and co. already having a more realistic model is what makes me expect the graphical change, just to get it more in line with the other 3D Final Fantasies.I imagine any changes will cause division as usual. I'm sure there are many who like the "chibi" style characters of the original. I'd be fine either way though.
Also, I'm pretty sure Zidane already has a more realistic model thanks to Dissidia (though Nomura design)
FF9 sticks out a lot with the chibi style (negatively in my opinion, but like you said, people will be divided about this), so if the change does happen, I'm a happy camper.
Lokaum D+
Member
yeah, for a long time i was on the team "ff9 chibi style is awful" but nowadays i think is one of the strongest points of this game.
this "realist Zidane" is a nightmare fuel imo
Last edited:
PianistaMacabro
Member
DownLikeBCPowder
Member
VII at least runs pretty good these days, even with solid full voice acting mod. I just played through it earlier this year and it was pretty great.
Last edited:
Heimdall_Xtreme
Hermen Hulst Fanclub's #1 Member
I have to still play this game.
Garnet will be so beautiful.
How will be Beatrix?
Garnet will be so beautiful.
How will be Beatrix?
March Climber
Member
Don't worry
Larxia
, if this is a full fledged top to bottom remake, it won't be built specifically to please the old men on GAF. They will most likely make changes to grab younger audiences and people with less patience. If it costs as much as a full blown remake, they'll be wanting as much profit as possible.
For me personally, as long as they get rid of randomized encounters, I don't care too much about what they do from that point forward. If they end up making it feel more dynamic in gameplay, then that's even better news.
I still think FF9 is an odd pick if this is true, but maybe Square Enix is seeing what Capcom is doing with Resident Evil and they're thinking 'we can do that too'.
Larxia
, if this is a full fledged top to bottom remake, it won't be built specifically to please the old men on GAF. They will most likely make changes to grab younger audiences and people with less patience. If it costs as much as a full blown remake, they'll be wanting as much profit as possible.For me personally, as long as they get rid of randomized encounters, I don't care too much about what they do from that point forward. If they end up making it feel more dynamic in gameplay, then that's even better news.
I still think FF9 is an odd pick if this is true, but maybe Square Enix is seeing what Capcom is doing with Resident Evil and they're thinking 'we can do that too'.
PianistaMacabro
Member
When you need to downgrade something for an audience to enjoy, you start to encounter problems. The problem lies not in modernizing something or not. The easiest aspect of the game to discuss, its visuals, already becomes problematic. It's a game that is firmly rooted in its time, aesthetically well put together. Simply modernizing it for the sake of it can automatically break its charm. Square enix just can't do this todayI'm not interested enough to go back and play age old games, but when something is modernized I can give it a try because I'm part of the audience. Don't see the problem
FFIX is my all time favorite game. I can live with this. Hopefully it’s open world and airships are in.
Open world with this game would really work. In the original game, you can’t just go anywhere without passing through some sort of gateway or cave. The territories and kingdoms are separated by mountain ranges and ocean.
Open world with this game would really work. In the original game, you can’t just go anywhere without passing through some sort of gateway or cave. The territories and kingdoms are separated by mountain ranges and ocean.
pleaseinsertdisctwo
Member
I’m assuming it meant that the game won’t be a super high budget remake that ends up being a totally different experience.
Also: have you even played the PSP version of CC and/or the remaster?
There was A LOT of effort put into the Remaster. For one, the gameplay is so improved it isn’t even funny. The original PSP game was a boring slog, while the remaster was actually really fun to the point where I completed like 70% of the side missions. Graphics also received a total overhaul. Summons received new CG cinematics. All the voices were re-recorded.
It had a lot of effort put into it.
Last edited:
SakkanartSilentJealousy
Member
Hope to announce around TGS.
StylishMGTOW
Member
Hopefully it's nothing like the Secret of Mana remake:
LOLE if so. Hard pass.
LOLE if so. Hard pass.
pleaseinsertdisctwo
Member
FFIX, a game that’s very restrictive with a forced party set-up, forced switched perspectives, and a linear structure until like halfway through the 3rd disc, is something you claim to be your favorite game of all time, and you want it to be open world for the remake?
Unless by “open world” you just mean a little less restrictive, with more room for exploration in earlier segments of the game? I guess that could work but the devs would probably have to incorporate some additional side content.
Lokaum D+
Member
that would kill all the game atmosphere and art direction imoHopefully it's nothing like the Secret of Mana remake:
LOLE if so. Hard pass.
pleaseinsertdisctwo
Member
Have you played Crisis Core? It’s not a remake but it absolutely not just a remaster, either. There was a ton of effort put into it. I’m assuming it’ll be a more traditional type of remake, where it’s largely faithful to the original experience (in more than just its story). rather than something like VIIR where it’s a total(ly expensive) overhaul.
cartman414
Member
No mention of V or VI? You guys are doing it wrong.
Larxia
Member
I don't really think that's fair, I often see turn based described as this "strategic" and mature audience thing, but this was always not true to me, many turn based games are more easy than action games, and the only obstacle is not being high level enough.
In Kingdom Hearts III in Critical mode, I spent about 10 hours on the Yozora boss fight, if that's not "patience", I'm not sure what is. I'm not asking FF IX to be Kingdom Hearts, but I'm just saying action games can require patience, be strategic, and more challenging than the most basic versions of turn based / atb.
March Climber
Member
Maybe I used the wrong choice of words, but when I'm thinking of 'patience' in relation to FF 9, it's not patience based on a fun and difficult challenge of gameplay. Instead it's patience based on how slow the game generally moves, which is what you were partly bringing up as an issue. What you've said about Yozora is an example of the good kind of patience. There's challenge and reward. It's satisfying. It makes you want to try again and again. If you had to sit through a ton of longform text dialogue and fight random encounters before each time you attempted Yozora it would become more grating and that 10 hours would turn into possibly 2-4, based on a number of annoyances outside of the Yozora boss fight eating up your time.
I understand your gripe about over leveling. I don't know how to avoid that other than having a soft form of level scaling, which most people don't like because you lose that feeling of power.
FF 9 is an extremely slow game, and random encounters make it an even slower experience. Like you and others here have mentioned before, there are ways they can improve upon it all without it needing to be fully action. Regardless, my previous statement was more to ease your worries, because there are a lot of people here who make bad predictions and wrong calls when it comes to modern remakes of older video games. Again, if this is a full remake, there's maybe a 75% chance they will make changes to the game for newer audiences. It would be much easier to worry more about what those changes will be, and worry less about people on this small corner of the internet wanting everything to stay the same as it has in the 90s.
Ferdimage
Member
I dropped FFXVI and went back to FFIX using Moguri mod and I'm enjoying that so much more.I’ll take it!! I need to wash away the bitter taste of FF16 .
It will only really become open once you get the airship.
I want it to remain true to it’s restrictiveness. I think that they can pull an open world for this without sacrificing the narrative and story telling because the continents and areas are separated by mountain rangers and gateways anyway. Strictly speaking, you can’t go anywhere until the story progresses.
Edit: To clarify, by open world I mean the world map fleshed out. Not something akin to ffxvi world map although I also love that game for its lore and story.
Last edited:
Heimdall_Xtreme
Hermen Hulst Fanclub's #1 Member
I have to play this wonderful game.
skit_data
Member
By pure coincidence I actually just started playing FFIX yesterday (wanted some more FF after playing FFXVI). Better play the original before the remake comes.
I just got to the part when Zidane says "Oooh, soft..." while grabbing the princess ass. I was pretty shocked and wondered if I just misinterpreted what happened but no, it seems that's indeed what he does. I even found a GAF thread about it while googling:
www.neogaf.com
I imagine this remake will have to either completely remove it or they could make it more obvious he's just accidentaly bumping into her or something (it's still pretty damn wierd to comment on it's supposed softness though).
I just got to the part when Zidane says "Oooh, soft..." while grabbing the princess ass. I was pretty shocked and wondered if I just misinterpreted what happened but no, it seems that's indeed what he does. I even found a GAF thread about it while googling:
Did Zidane sexually assault Garnet in FF9?
You remember when Zidane gropes her ass near the beginning of the game and being all ''Ohh, so soft!'' and afterwards says he didn't do it on purpose cause Garnet is all mad and shit? Sexual assault or accident?
I imagine this remake will have to either completely remove it or they could make it more obvious he's just accidentaly bumping into her or something (it's still pretty damn wierd to comment on it's supposed softness though).
Kurotri
Member
I'm willing to give it a chance nonetheless, I mean, we haven't even seen any footage
from it. In the case it sucks that bad the original isn't suddenly gonna disappear.
Badlucktroll
Member
I have a feeling this isn’t going to be a full fledged, high budget remake. It’s going to be something like Octopath.
Drizzlehell
Banned
I just realized that Freya reminds me of something...I hope the remake is more faithful to Itahana's designs rather than making them look more life-like as FFVII Remake did.
Larxia
Member
If you really want the exact same game but prettier, isn't the Moguri mod on PC already enough for that?
It seems kind of a waste to make a remake if it's barely different from this.
Unless if by "2023 graphic" you also mean a free camera, getting rid of the pre rendered background with fixed cameras etc, but then it's not "the exact same fucking game" at all anymore, all the exploration would have to be redesigned.
GymWolf
Gold Member
I don't wanna risk another ff7repuke, that's all.
DownLikeBCPowder
Member
Yes, I've played the original on PSP and still own it. I don't agree that the original was a "boring slog", I still really enjoyed this game even back then. I do think the remaster is an improvement in various ways, but I can see how you would feel like it's more of an improvement than I do if you didn't like the original. There are a lot of QOL changes to the new version that are pretty definitive. I can see your perspective now and it's not a bad one.
Mephisto40
Member
It's bizarre that they would choose to remake 9 and completely skip 8
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
Day one
Zheph
Member
(sadly) 9 is more popular
Lokaum D+
Member
based on the art style i think 9 is way cheaper to remake then 8 would ever be.
Zheph
Member
I have to agree with that also, 8 would need a treatment like VIIR (I have dreams of Balamb Garden looking absolutely stunning) but despite being my favourite it is way less popular than 7 and 9
Lokaum D+
Member
agree and after playing FF16 i would never accept Balamb VS Galbadia beeing a CGI cutscene, imagine being in control of the "school" avoiding misseles and all the shit going on real time, the size and scale that would be needed to make a open world map where for sometime u control a gigantic school would be massive.
Last edited:
Zheph
Member
don't start me man
PianistaMacabro
Member
I love the original and i'm very excited all this years of rumors of a remake. Probably is gonna be terrible but WE CAN DREAM hahaha. The problem I see is to play only/first the remake, cause you need modernized stuff or you cannot finished the original. Tiktok times
hyperbertha
Member
Why is it missed potential? Are you one of those that unironically larp about how turn based is oUtDAteD?Nomura never even worked on FF IX, why are you even saying this? It really seems like people like to shit on Nomura for no reason, proof is the people who recently said FF XVI was confusing because of Nomura
He was a core member of FF VII development, it made sense for him to be there for VII Remake.
Anyway, it sounds like missed potential if you make a remake only to keep it turn based in the end, weird choice if they do. Unless it's a really improved "turn based" ATB system, like how XIII changed it for example, but if it's generic regular turn based... no thanks.
NotMyProblemAnymoreCunt
Biggest Trails Stan
If true, it's already sounding way better than how Final Fantasy VII Remake is turning out
Last edited: