Support NeoGAF

[Master Milk]

Yet another fairly generic shonen action mecha series with annoying characters, versus a great anime among the best of its kind? It's really not a very hard decision to make at all. Angel Beats is something I love. It has a few minor issues, but they don't blemish its greatness much. E7... that's something that I might consider watching if it was on TV and I couldn't find anything better on. It'll never be anything more than that, it can't be with its concept, genre, story, and characters.

Hahahahahahaha, this is great, but no. AB has more than a few minor issues, and you loving it doesn't change that. It's a terrible show. I hope you're not recommending it to people.

You liking it is one think, but making others suffer through that atrocity is wrong.

 

[Ultimadrago]

Hansode > Medaka. discuss.

Water is wet.

 

[cajunator]

Yet another fairly generic shonen action mecha series with annoying characters, versus a great anime among the best of its kind? It's really not a very hard decision to make at all. Angel Beats is something I love. It has a few minor issues, but they don't blemish its greatness much. E7... that's something that I might consider watching if it was on TV and I couldn't find anything better on. It'll never be anything more than that, it can't be with its concept, genre, story, and characters.

Wait I missed this. Sorry Legoman, but I don't agree.

I do like Angel Beats a lot though because it is batshit insane.

 

[Dead]

Yet another fairly generic shonen action mecha series with annoying characters, versus a great anime among the best of its kind? It's really not a very hard decision to make at all. Angel Beats is something I love. It has a few minor issues, but they don't blemish its greatness much. E7... that's something that I might consider watching if it was on TV and I couldn't find anything better on. It'll never be anything more than that, it can't be with its concept, genre, story, and characters.

idontwantotliveonthisearthanymore.jpg

 

[Ultimadrago]

wonzo posted 666 times. Truly a masochist of the Beast.

 

[wonzo]

I think I'll watch Angel Beats first before beginning any other Key anime.

 

[Instro]

I disapprove of this blatant Eureka Seven propaganda.

But Bones needs all the propaganda it can get in these trying times.

 

[trejo]

I wanna point you to Legend of Korra...

Anime is okay.

 

[Narag]

All this talk of Angel Beats being terrible has me the wrong kind of curious.

 

[SDBurton]

I wanna point you to Legend of Korra...

 

[cajunator]

Also, so far, Tsuritama is definitely my favorite show of the season.
So colorful. So bizarre. So playful.

 

[Risette]

I would like to respond to this post from the last thread: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=37116242&postcount=19994

Firstly, Inception has neither style nor substance and is a bad movie, which brings me to my next point,

Substance and style coexist. If you think one work does not have one, then it does not have the other either. Don't pick and choose.

 

[jman2050]

I think I'll watch Angel Beats first before beginning any other Key anime.

TURN BACK

TURN BACK

 

[Ultimadrago]

All this talk of Angel Beats being terrible has me the wrong kind of curious.

You are gaining the cajun spirit.

 

[madp]

All this talk of Angel Beats being terrible has me the wrong kind of curious.

It can't be worse than the type of curiosity that lead to you search the internet for Kirino ponies, so you might as well watch it.

 

[zeroshiki]

I blame AnimeGaf for not taking that AOTY poll seriously and letting Angel Beats win. Now everyone thinks we like it.

 

[jman2050]

It can't be worse than the type of curiosity that lead to you search the internet for Kirino ponies, so you might as well watch it.

Pretty sure Hito posted the Kirino pony.

The bastard...

 

[flawfuls]

Dammit duckroll you're jinxing it!

 

[Haly]

I blame AnimeGaf for not taking that AOTY poll seriously and letting Angel Beats win. Now everyone thinks we like it.

On the list of things we should feel bad about I think that ranks rather low really.

 

[Jarmel]

No joke. Counterculture is the definition of hipster.

The counterculture of the 1960s encompassed a lot more than the modern hipster movement. It involved politics not to mention the art and musical renaissance that it started. They're fundamentally different things. Just because two 'sub-cultures' oppose the mainstream doesn't make them similar. The counterculture stood for very specific things, I have yet to see anything similar from the hipster movement.

 

[cajunator]

All this talk of Angel Beats being terrible has me the wrong kind of curious.

I wholeheartedly recommend it for the music alone. GIrls Dead monster is the right kind of entertaining. Its hard to describe the show though. Think about what Haibane Renmei would be like if Yoshitoshi Abe was on acid and gave the characters weapons.

 

[Narag]

Pretty sure Hito posted the Kirino pony.

The bastard...

I may or may not have been the person that gave him the link.

 

[zeroshiki]

On the list of things we should feel bad about I think that ranks rather low really.

What's up top? School Days? Blood-C? BONES noitamina?

 

[hosannainexcelsis]

I think I'll watch Angel Beats first before beginning any other Key anime.

At least you'll be getting the worst stuff out of the way first.

 

[Steroyd]

Seems like there's some Animegaf Sengoku Collection endurance thing going on, interesting.

Recorder and Ransel 16

three episodes in a row without the dumb gag...how is this even possible?!

I know that feel bro, I know that feel...

And Cosmic is making me want to re-watch Hayate no Gotoku, while I enjoyed it, I watched it at a time when I was a level 1 scrub and didn't have 1/1000th of anime knowledge I do now, so all his screencaps make it seem like he's watching a completely different show to the one I watched wtf!?

 

[Hellsing321]

Guys quit talking about Angel Beats. It is not on the AnimeGAF approved masochistic shows list for a reason.

Spoiler

Because we aren't that cruel.

 

[Branduil]

Yet another fairly generic shonen action mecha series with annoying characters, versus a great anime among the best of its kind? It's really not a very hard decision to make at all. Angel Beats is something I love. It has a few minor issues, but they don't blemish its greatness much. E7... that's something that I might consider watching if it was on TV and I couldn't find anything better on. It'll never be anything more than that, it can't be with its concept, genre, story, and characters.

 

[cajunator]

I don't know, but honestly, I'm enjoying the FUCK out of Yami to Boshi.
Whoever recommended that, even if you did it with hatred in your heart, thank you.

 

[duckroll]

I blame AnimeGaf for not taking that AOTY poll seriously and letting Angel Beats win. Now everyone thinks we like it.

I regret nothing.

 

[Instro]

hahahaha

 

[Crash Station]

The counterculture of the 1960s encompassed a lot more than the modern hipster movement. It involved politics not to mention the art and musical renaissance that it started. They're fundamentally different things. Just because two 'sub-cultures' oppose the mainstream doesn't make them similar. The counterculture stood for very specific things, I have yet to see anything similar from the hipster movement.

Hipster is a much broader term than you're making it out to be. Non-mainstream=hipster.

 

[zeroshiki]

You guys should listen to me because I recommend only good shows. And in the event that you don't like a show I recommend then screw you, there's clearly something wrong with you.

 

[cajunator]

Seems like there's some Animegaf Sengoku Collection endurance thing going on, interesting.



I know that feel bro, I know that feel...

And Cosmic is making me want to re-watch Hayate no Gotoku, while I enjoyed it, I watched it at a time when I was a level 1 scrub and didn't have 1/1000th of anime knowledge I do now, so all his screencaps make it seem like he's watching a completely different show to the one I watched wtf!?

Im about to join the endurance race.
I've been curiousd about Sengoku Collection. How bad can it possibly be?

 

[madp]

I blame AnimeGaf for not taking that AOTY poll seriously and letting Angel Beats win. Now everyone thinks we like it.

We can always have a revote like the people on gaming side who couldn't accept that MGS4 won '08's GOTY. Of course, that did backfire...

Pretty sure Hito posted the Kirino pony.

The bastard...

He also delivered several moe antrho pug drawings to me with disturbing ease after the ill-advised request I made in the previous thread. Hito is the Batman of terrifying anthro art, always prepared to make someone regret any passing curiosity they may express.

 

[Hellsing321]

Hipster is a much broader term than you're making it out to be. Non-mainstream=hipster.

Which is why the term is meaningless and people should stop using it.

 

[Jex]

Damn, that's brutal!

 

[Crash Station]

Hahahahahahaha, this is great, but no. AB has more than a few minor issues, and you loving it doesn't change that. It's a terrible show. I hope you're not recommending it to people.

You liking it is one think, but making others suffer through that atrocity is wrong.

To be fair, A LOT of people like it.

 

[Regulus Tera]

On the list of things we should feel bad about I think that ranks rather low really.

Just below Pohana, and above all the School Days hazing.

 

[SDBurton]

You guys should listen to me because I recommend only good shows. And in the event that you don't like a show I recommend then screw you, there's clearly something wrong with you.

*remembers Marimite*

I support you.

 

[hosannainexcelsis]

Which is why the term is meaningless and people should stop using it.

You just say that because you're a hipster.

 

[wonzo]

hmmm, the latest ep of sankarea or the first episode of angel betas.....this is a pretty hard choice to make.

http://i.minus.com/iZN7fEtOX9eb8.jpg

ice cold

 

[trejo]

WALL OF SHAME:

cajunator 1,514
Jexhius 1,123
Ultimadrago 900
Branduil 765
duckroll 673
wonzo 666
Envelope 625
firehawk12 601
Mad Pierrot 547
Regulus Tera 460
frostbyte 420
hosannainexcelsis 418
cosmicblizzard 406
zeroshiki 352
chickdigger802 346
Femmeworth 320
Narag 263
Jarmel 258
RurouniZel 256
Dance In My Blood 254
EmmanuelMunoz 247
Instro 242
Hitokage 237
Defuser 236
Brazil 230
Thoraxes 228
Articalys 226
Dresden 225
Unknown Soldier 224
jman2050 223
Dedication Through Light 221
Steroyd 216
Miri 206
Jintor 198
Basileus777 192
Hellsing321 183
Haly 181
Lafiel 175
pizzaroll 170
Noirulus 153
icarus-daedelus 153
dakkumauji 151
PdotMichael 150
InfiniteNine 147
Lain 135
Firemind 135
darkside31337 123
SDBurton 116
KuwabaraTheMan 107
Uchip 105
/XX/ 101

What a bunch of weaboos.

 

[cajunator]

Somebody ratted me out I think, back in April. Who was it?

 

[Steroyd]

Im about to join the endurance race.
I've been curiousd about Sengoku Collection. How bad can it possibly be?

To put into perspective, not even Kana Hanazawa and Yuri could save this show.

 

[Jex]

But Bones needs all the propaganda it can get in these trying times.

They just need to make some new Sword of the Stranger!

 

[Jarmel]

Hipster is a much broader term than you're making it out to be. Non-mainstream=hipster.

That's way too broad of a term then. Certain political groups almost certainly wouldn't define themselves as hipster but your definition would put them under it.

 

[Ultimadrago]

Which is why the term is meaningless and people should stop using it.

Then Emmanuel would cease to exist! We can't have that!

 

[A Black Falcon]

Hahahahahahaha, this is great, but no. AB has more than a few minor issues, and you loving it doesn't change that. It's a terrible show. I hope you're not recommending it to people.

You liking it is one think, but making others suffer through that atrocity is wrong.

Angel Beats is an outstanding show, your hating it doesn't change that. I know animegaf has taken upon itself to be the internet's #1 Key-hater destination, and I've said plenty of times how much I disagree with that (because I think Key is great), but that doesn't make it in any way true or accurate. It just makes it your opinions.

This is going to be a good thread.

I think defending myself is completely fair.

You're right.

What does either have to do with Eureka 7 or Angel Beats though?

E7 is one, AB the other.

But yeah, sure, I'll admit that one thing that makes me dislike E7 is its genre -- shonen action mecha stuff? I've never cared for most such things. It's mecha stuff I DO like, like Escaflowne, that's the exception; generally I don't find them too interesting. E7 is of course not straight-average mecha, but that doesn't make it too much more interesting, for me. Mecha shows are often boring. As I said, it was watchable, but based on its genre and concept it would be incredibly difficult for it to be the kind of show I would love, or would consider for any kind of "best of anime" list. It'd need to be Escaflowne levels of great and original, pretty much, and it's most certainly not that.

As for comparing the two objectively? Not sure if I could do that, but neither can most people here, as their ridiculous hate for AB shows. I do think AB's objectively better, yeah... better plot, better characters, more interesting drama...

I should be clear, though -- I don't think E7 is a bad show. It's not bad. Average, maybe even above average. But that's no competition for something as great as Angel Beats. No way, ever.

I expect nothing less but the stupidest of AB hate from you (perhaps the most vocal hater of show here), so yeah, that doesn't surprise me that you'd do that.

 

[Jex]

What a bunch of weaboos.

It's almost like this list is missing something.

 

[Noirulus]

What a bunch of weaboos.

Only 153 posts. I've been a good boy!