• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Super Smash Bros. for Wii U POTD Thread 17: Smash 3DS Discussion @ OT PLS

Status
Not open for further replies.

Nanashrew

Banned
So I learned something from Nintendo support earlier and the reason why smash demo emails have been so slow.

It's automated and being sent out in batches periodically. But that's not the problem. The problem is that it's taking forever because people keep hammering Club Nintendo so it's slowing the whole process down. The emails will be sent out until 12am PST (2am CST my time) and If you qualified but didn't receive one then to give them a call.

That is what the guy told me and my brother over the phone.
 
For the new thread. I'll re-add the links later.
Man, I love the roster (save for the lack of Ice Climbers, which I'm pretty much relatively over), but I really can't get over the 3DS version's tiny and hole filled stage roster (and some of the large holes in music representation on top of it!). I really, really hope the Wii U version is better and more fully featured, no prominent character franchises without stages, and at least as large of a stage roster as Brawl. Less than that and the two games could never achieve greater than "good but disappointing wasted potential" to me.

EDIT: I'm liking this community split--much quieter in here now.

No SuperSah is a plus too.
 
total posts, the final pre-3DS release edition:
1. IntelliHeath-8814
2. theprodigy-5673
3. Horizon-5094
4. ffdgh-5008
5. foxuzamaki-4689
6. BGBW-4650
7. SuperSah-4589 (+1)
8. georly-4443 (-1)
9. Neiteio-4387
10. SmithnCo-4363
11. PadWarrior-4162
12. Beelzebufo-3795
13. OricWindstar-3742
14. Boss Doggie-3375
15. Troubled Bat-3299
16. Berordn-3243
17. MrSaturn99-3063
18. Toxi-2867
19. Loco4Coco-2696 (+1)
20. zroid-2679 (+2)
21. Village-2671 (-2)
22. Ryce-2626 (-1)
23. DaBoss-2398 (+1)
24. qq more-2397 (-1)
25. Kriken-2370
26. Red Arremer-2344 (+1)
27. I'M FINISHED-2333 (-1)
28. Kyzon-2132
29. BassForever-2116
30. SenorArdilla-2098
31. emb-2090 (+3)
32. The Great Gonzales-2082 (-1)
33. Pop-O-Matic-1970
34. Golnei-1964 (+2)
35. Azure J-1933 (-3)
35. JoeInky-1933
37. Caladrius-1780
38. Jawmuncher-1711 (+3)
39. Neoriceisgood-1692 (-1)
40. ShockingAlberto-1674 (-1)
41. Hatchtag-1665 (-1)
42. Neoxon-1592 (+4)
43. Dimitri LH-1589 (+2)
44. Sponge-1586 (-1)
45. Watch Da Birdie-1584 (-1)
46. GamerSoul-1564 (-4)
47. Kouriozan-1561 (NEW)
48. J@hranimo-1557 (NEW)
49. balladofwindfishes-1542 (NEW)
50. Baron von Loathsome-1540 (-2)

newcomers: Kouriozan, J@hranimo, balladofwindfishes
dropped out: Benzychenz, Anth0ny, Hyperactivity
biggest rise: Neoxon, 4 spots
biggest fall: Gamersoul, 4 spots

others: With the last pre-3DS release thread, we have 4 posters above 5000 posts! *high fives IntelliHeath, Horizon, ffdgh*

not much else of note here
 
My only disappointment was Dark Pit. I was lurking during the Thursday stream and saw people hating characters. I found it silly because the character is zero reason why your favorite did not get in.

I came to terms that Chorus Kids were gone. I think Ice Climbers and Chorus Kids were planned because Smash Run enemies and no trophy, but time ran out and they were not done.
 

Nanashrew

Banned
total posts, the final pre-3DS release edition:
1. IntelliHeath-8814
2. theprodigy-5673
3. Horizon-5094
4. ffdgh-5008
5. foxuzamaki-4689
6. BGBW-4650
7. SuperSah-4589 (+1)
8. georly-4443 (-1)
9. Neiteio-4387
10. SmithnCo-4363
11. PadWarrior-4162
12. Beelzebufo-3795
13. OricWindstar-3742
14. Boss Doggie-3375
15. Troubled Bat-3299
16. Berordn-3243
17. MrSaturn99-3063
18. Toxi-2867
19. Loco4Coco-2696 (+1)
20. zroid-2679 (+2)
21. Village-2671 (-2)
22. Ryce-2626 (-1)
23. DaBoss-2398 (+1)
24. qq more-2397 (-1)
25. Kriken-2370
26. Red Arremer-2344 (+1)
27. I'M FINISHED-2333 (-1)
28. Kyzon-2132
29. BassForever-2116
30. SenorArdilla-2098
31. emb-2090 (+3)
32. The Great Gonzales-2082 (-1)
33. Pop-O-Matic-1970
34. Golnei-1964 (+2)
35. Azure J-1933 (-3)
35. JoeInky-1933
37. Caladrius-1780
38. Jawmuncher-1711 (+3)
39. Neoriceisgood-1692 (-1)
40. ShockingAlberto-1674 (-1)
41. Hatchtag-1665 (-1)
42. Neoxon-1592 (+4)
43. Dimitri LH-1589 (+2)
44. Sponge-1586 (-1)
45. Watch Da Birdie-1584 (-1)
46. GamerSoul-1564 (-4)
47. Kouriozan-1561 (NEW)
48. J@hranimo-1557 (NEW)
49. balladofwindfishes-1542 (NEW)
50. Baron von Loathsome-1540 (-2)

newcomers: Kouriozan, J@hranimo, balladofwindfishes
dropped out: Benzychenz, Anth0ny, Hyperactivity
biggest rise: Neoxon, 4 spots
biggest fall: Gamersoul, 4 spots

others: With the last pre-3DS release thread, we have 4 posters above 5000 posts! *high fives IntelliHeath, Horizon, ffdgh*

not much else of note here

I have a long way to go to reach those numbers.
 

GamerSoul

Member
total posts, the final pre-3DS release edition:
1. IntelliHeath-8814
2. theprodigy-5673
3. Horizon-5094
4. ffdgh-5008
5. foxuzamaki-4689
6. BGBW-4650
7. SuperSah-4589 (+1)
8. georly-4443 (-1)
9. Neiteio-4387
10. SmithnCo-4363
11. PadWarrior-4162
12. Beelzebufo-3795
13. OricWindstar-3742
14. Boss Doggie-3375
15. Troubled Bat-3299
16. Berordn-3243
17. MrSaturn99-3063
18. Toxi-2867
19. Loco4Coco-2696 (+1)
20. zroid-2679 (+2)
21. Village-2671 (-2)
22. Ryce-2626 (-1)
23. DaBoss-2398 (+1)
24. qq more-2397 (-1)
25. Kriken-2370
26. Red Arremer-2344 (+1)
27. I'M FINISHED-2333 (-1)
28. Kyzon-2132
29. BassForever-2116
30. SenorArdilla-2098
31. emb-2090 (+3)
32. The Great Gonzales-2082 (-1)
33. Pop-O-Matic-1970
34. Golnei-1964 (+2)
35. Azure J-1933 (-3)
35. JoeInky-1933
37. Caladrius-1780
38. Jawmuncher-1711 (+3)
39. Neoriceisgood-1692 (-1)
40. ShockingAlberto-1674 (-1)
41. Hatchtag-1665 (-1)
42. Neoxon-1592 (+4)
43. Dimitri LH-1589 (+2)
44. Sponge-1586 (-1)
45. Watch Da Birdie-1584 (-1)
46. GamerSoul-1564 (-4)
47. Kouriozan-1561 (NEW)
48. J@hranimo-1557 (NEW)
49. balladofwindfishes-1542 (NEW)
50. Baron von Loathsome-1540 (-2)

newcomers: Kouriozan, J@hranimo, balladofwindfishes
dropped out: Benzychenz, Anth0ny, Hyperactivity
biggest rise: Neoxon, 4 spots
biggest fall: Gamersoul, 4 spots

others: With the last pre-3DS release thread, we have 4 posters above 5000 posts! *high fives IntelliHeath, Horizon, ffdgh*

not much else of note here

dat fall. wow I'm still on the list somehow lol
 

The Lamp

Member
This is now a Wii U thread.

tumblr_m4tgcf8TIx1r0wki4o1_1280.jpg

LMAO
 

Meffer

Member
Snapping is definitely either dramatically scaled back or flat out gone, because there's been a ton of times I figured I'd be able to grab a ledge which I would've been able to in Brawl and I've just fallen to my death.

Only negative thing I can say so far about the overall gameplay is everybody seems to die at a noticeably higher damage percentage than they would've in previous games. Just means things go on longer than they normally would, but I can't see why like something that couldn't be easily accommodated in tournaments.

Brawl has the largest openings when it comes to grabbing ledges in the series. 4 scales it down but edge hogging is nerfed.
 

Neiteio

Member
Greatest demo I've ever played. And I still can't believe Nintendo gave us a demo for this. Thank you Nintendo!!!
For me, the title of "Greatest Demo Ever" probably goes to Warhawk PS3. But yeah, this Smash demo is excellent. I hope you're all playing in 3D, it looks dazzling. But what a tease it is to only have access to six characters, lol.
 

Pikma

Banned
For me, the title of "Greatest Demo Ever" probably goes to Warhawk PS3. But yeah, this Smash demo is excellent. I hope you're all playing in 3D, it looks dazzling. But what a tease it is to only have access to six characters, lol.
5 actually ;_;
 
Man, I love the roster (save for the lack of Ice Climbers, which I'm pretty much relatively over), but I really can't get over the 3DS version's tiny and hole filled stage roster (and some of the large holes in music representation on top of it!). I really, really hope the Wii U version is better and more fully featured, no prominent character franchises without stages, and at least as large of a stage roster as Brawl. Less than that and the two games could never achieve greater than "good but disappointing wasted potential" to me.
Absolutely how I feel too, though throw Snake alongside the IC as the roster cuts I'm still sort of upset over. I feel this is the best batch of newcomers we've had in a Smash game and Uprising was too good for me to really feel upset over a quick and easy to make clone like Dark Pit... Honestly feeling like Alph or Brittany as a quick Olimar clone with his cut Brawl stuff (I get the extra pikmin would be out of the cards) could've been another neat way to pad out the roster.

New stages look really great but good god did DK, Metroid, Yoshi, Star Fox, hell even Kirby (that gameboy stage looks barebones as fuck) get fucked over in the stage and music department. I'll even take their new stages in the Wii U version getting ported back into the 3DS version like Mac and Shulk's were.

I'm holding up hope a 10 year GAF vet didn't just throw away their account over the Ridley/Dixie/Mewtwo/Chorus Kids stuff.
 

Watch Da Birdie

I buy cakes for myself on my birthday it's not weird lots of people do it I bet
Spainkiller saying that Chorus Kids, Ridley, Mewtwo, and Dixie are definitely playable and will be released when the Wii U version hits.

Honestly after the ESRB leak, I'll put my money with him.

Anyway, I really think this thread will probably be limp for about a month as Sakurai reveals the "secret" 3DS stuff. Hopefully the next Direct gives us a great new Wii U Trailer, and we start getting a bunch of new pics of the Wii U.

Man, I'm drooling. To think we still have 3 months of POTD left at least...and I haven't even got the 3DS Version yet.
 

Watch Da Birdie

I buy cakes for myself on my birthday it's not weird lots of people do it I bet
Would you even get banned if you're wrong?

I mean, you're not a random junior saying this, you have enough history that I'm sure they wouldn't flat out kill your account for one mistake.
 

Spainkiller

the man who sold the world
To be honest, I never even considered the fact that I could get banned for being wrong, but hey, it's a risk I took.

We'll see. Right now I'm just glad that the review code for the EU 3DS version is just a few days away :)
 
To be honest, I never even considered the fact that I could get banned for being wrong, but hey, it's a risk I took.

We'll see. Right now I'm just glad that the review code for the EU 3DS version is just a few days away :)
Honestly you'd probably be fine if it's more 'this is what my source is telling me' rather than giving a definitive EVERYBODY SHOULD EXPECT A DIXIE AND RIDLEY TAG-TEAM MECHANIC FOR THE WII U statement.

We had someone back in 2013 before E3 claim they saw the new Smash, made a new thread about it and was almost completely off base about every single thing they said and they got banned. Sorry if I'm being a bit alarmist saying you're risking your account on this, again it probably just comes down to how you say it really. :X
 

Sponge

Banned
Ho there, buddy, I never said definitely :)

But yeah, I have faith for good reasons.

You mentioned your source told you about the Bowser Jr. alts. Was there anything else that was told ahead of time? I remember the alts were a part of another text leak as well.
 
At this point I am happy with the roster, getting mewtwo as DLC would just be the icing on the cake.
Basically, the newcomer roster's great, even for as much as I'd like Ridley and Dixie. Fake DLC claims about the cut veterans getting back in are going to annoy me way more than claims about even more newcomers getting in that wind up being fake.
 

Spainkiller

the man who sold the world
Honestly you'd probably be fine if it's more 'this is what my source is telling me' rather than giving a definitive EVERYBODY SHOULD EXPECT A DIXIE AND RIDLEY TAG-TEAM MECHANIC FOR THE WII U statement.

Yeah, just to make things clear: I never saw anything myself.

You mentioned your source told you about the Bowser Jr. alts. Was there anything else that was told ahead of time? I remember the alts were a part of another text leak as well.

Yeah, when the Gematsu leak was a big thing he kept telling me that Chrom's model was in the game but was not gonna be a playable character. He knew this WEEKS before the Robin/Captain Falcon trailer. He also knew about Ganondorf being pretty much identical to his Brawl counterpart, at least model wise. And a lot more stuff. He hasn't been wrong about anything and I know for a fact* that he did some localization thing for the game.

*this is actually the only thing I know for a fact
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom