After reading through this whole thread, I think the REAL problem on GAF is the whole "Nintendrone vs. Sonybot vs. Xbot" mentality that everyone tends to conform to.
In sales threads, you see a few "Hey, good sales for Kirby!"s or "Interesting how a few new colors can make the DS's sales double."s. However, the majority of posts are "Nintendo is going to dominate if they keep this up!" or "Nintendo is doomed. The DS sucks" or "Good thing that the PSP is kicking the DS's ass."
There's this whole "Nintendo vs. Sony vs. Microsoft" mentality that is manifested into the forum-goers posts. Instead of focusing on the things that the consumers should be worried about (the games and game quality), gaf focuses on the whole business aspect, the one-upsmanship that Sony, Microsoft, and Nintendo are all trying to do to each other, and this consequently results in an all out war of endless flaming and trolling. People take sides and praise the side that they're on consistently while deleteriously slamming the other side.
I'm a Nintendo fanboy, and I clearloy show a bias towards Nintendo in my posts. But instead of pointlessly flaming Sony and Microsoft's efforts, I focus on the positive and negatives of the GBA, the GC, and other Nintendo systems, because I'm more familiar with them. Now, that's not to say I completely ignore Sony and Microsoft, but when I do focus on them, I don't just say "They suck." I admit that the PSP's lineup is better at the moment, but it's a lot pricier than the DS, and the upcoming DS lineup interests me more. Instead of simply describing the bad parts of the PSP, I focus on the goods and the bads, how they compare to my personal interests, and how the DS's current and future lineup stacks up.
I'd like to quote a post I made earlier today.
GaimeGuy said:
Monk said:
Not really, neither of them do, yet. Well the DS has with fucking kirby, the lemmings fan in me is dying for it. I dont want to buy the DS though. As it stands the DS has more games that interest me.
And this is what matters.
Whichever system has more appealing games is the system which each individual should invest in.
Myself? I'm a Nintendo fanboy, I love platformers like Kirby and Mario as well as arcadey racers like Mario Kart and Wipeout. I love Strategy games like Advance Wars, and yes, good card games like Metal Gear Acid and Baten Kaitos. Same with RPGs, although I usually only like having one or two RPGs every three months or so (otherwise I get bored of them. :lol )
Both systems appeal to me, but the facts remain that the PSP is a little heavier on the sports titles and FPSes compared to the DS, the DS in my eyes has a better upcoming lineup, and the lower prices of the games and hardware are easier on my wallet. Thus, I chose the DS. I have no doubt I will get the PSP when it price drops to 150-200 and games are more regularly priced between 35 and 40 dollars. Just that now isn't the time.
Instead of just saying "PSP is too pricey and the games don't interest me," which is a bit shallow, I actually EXPLAIN my position.
SantaCruzer, another poster who's clearly biased towards Nintendo, tends to post the same way, and few people seem to have a problem with his postings.
Now, I'm sure that I have strayed from this posting style and simply flamed something I don't like (I can remember posting in a Conker thread about a month back and pretty much just being a complete troll), but for the most part, I try to be a little more civilized in my posts.
I think more posts on GAF should be focused more on the good
and the bad of video games, or just the good, instead of focusing on just the bad, like most of us tend to do.
*goes back to playing FFVII*