• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

TheGamer: A Persona 4 Remake Is Looking Likelier By The Minute

Thick Thighs Save Lives

NeoGAF's Physical Games Advocate Extraordinaire
2s2Ty8l.png


While it seems that we're a long ways off from that project being confirmed by Sega, there is some convincing evidence that something is in the works. Over on the GamingLeaksAndRumours subreddit, Redditor Trem45 shared a detailed breakdown from Twitter user rudiger__tw, who highlights a few suspicious goings-on.



The Twitter user notes that singer Shihoka Hirata, known for her vocals on Persona 4, has recently revealed that she's recording for an unannounced project. Her teases include photos from MIT Studio in Tokyo, which can be seen in the Persona 5 Strikers making-of documentary and is where most Persona soundtracks have been recorded in the past.

That's already some mounting evidence, but rudiger__tw also pointed out that Hirata has been liking replies to her posts that include references to Persona 4. While it could just be the singer showing appreciation to fans who want to see it return, it's hard to deny that the evidence is there for the project potentially being a Persona 4 remake.

 

Gaiff

SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
I want persona 6

Persona 5 showed how much better it was than older persona games
I think Persona 6 will dunk on all of the previous entries. I love 3, 4, and 5, but you can just see how budget-constrained they are. The series is no longer some niche, second-tier JRPG only weebs know about. The sales forecast will be high and there will be proper funding. I'm of course not expecting it to be full-on AAA with $150M+ in budget, but I could see something in the $50-75M range. It would have significantly more production values than 5, and of course, it wouldn't be shackled by the PS3. It will probably come to the PS4 and be cross-gen though.
 
I think Persona 6 will dunk on all of the previous entries. I love 3, 4, and 5, but you can just see how budget-constrained they are. The series is no longer some niche, second-tier JRPG only weebs know about. The sales forecast will be high and there will be proper funding. I'm of course not expecting it to be full-on AAA with $150M+ in budget, but I could see something in the $50-75M range. It would have significantly more production values than 5, and of course, it wouldn't be shackled by the PS3. It will probably come to the PS4 and be cross-gen though.

Persona 5 was held back by being developed originally for the ps3 which i agree hurt it from the get go. Persona 6 on next gen should look like persona 3 remake graphically and budget wise if i had to guess.
 
Last edited:

Mibu no ookami

Demoted Member® Pro™
Let's be real, we're more surprised it hasn't happened yet

I'm surprised but not stunned.

They were working on the following projects

Persona 3
Metaphor Refantazio
Persona 6

So getting Persona 4 up and going was not going to be the biggest priority, but it should also be easier than Persona 3. If Metaphor wasn't as big a hit as it was, I think they would have focused more on getting P4 out, but they're going to look to keep essentially 3 franchises going, Persona, Metaphor, and Persona Remakes. This is on top of SMT.

So surprised but not stunned.
 
I think Persona 6 will dunk on all of the previous entries. I love 3, 4, and 5, but you can just see how budget-constrained they are. The series is no longer some niche, second-tier JRPG only weebs know about. The sales forecast will be high and there will be proper funding. I'm of course not expecting it to be full-on AAA with $150M+ in budget, but I could see something in the $50-75M range. It would have significantly more production values than 5, and of course, it wouldn't be shackled by the PS3. It will probably come to the PS4 and be cross-gen though.

We could see it be next gen exclusive but also target switch 2

I hope they ditch switch 1

But yeah after so many years of development I’m expecting big things from persona 6

What they achieved with P5R is remarkable
 

Gaiff

SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
We could see it be next gen exclusive but also target switch 2

I hope they ditch switch 1

But yeah after so many years of development I’m expecting big things from persona 6

What they achieved with P5R is remarkable
Fuck, had completely forgotten about the original Switch. It might as well be a PS3. With 140M+ units out, it also cannot be ignored, especially with how strong the sales are in Japan. If it's the baseline, which honestly, it might be, we're probably looking at something closer to Persona 3 Reload. If we're lucky, they'll ditch it and focus on just the Switch 2. They didn't release P3R on the Switch after all.

Fingers crossed it doesn't massively hold back the scale and scope of the game.
 
Fuck, had completely forgotten about the original Switch. It might as well be a PS3. With 140M+ units out, it also cannot be ignored, especially with how strong the sales are in Japan. If it's the baseline, which honestly, it might be, we're probably looking at something closer to Persona 3 Reload. If we're lucky, they'll ditch it and focus on just the Switch 2. They didn't release P3R on the Switch after all.

Fingers crossed it doesn't massively hold back the scale and scope of the game.

I wouldn't count on it. Persona 4 and 5 released 2 and 3 years after the launch of a new console respectively and still came out on last gen.
 

NeoIkaruGAF

Gold Member
Pretty unnecessary. I played it on Xbox not two years ago and I think a fresh coat of paint would be enough. It doesn’t need a full remake.
Btw, like others already said, there’s some elements in the game that just wouldn’t fly today, even with the tides turning a bit recently.
 

Mibu no ookami

Demoted Member® Pro™
Persona 5 royal looks better to me than persona 3 remake, graphically and artistically

Persona 3 is a pretty low effort remake. There are a lot of areas where I feel like they could have done a better job. Not being able to fast forward through all out attacks and theurgy attacks makes the game more of a slog. And the transition screens are massively annoying for this level of graphics. I feel like they must have still used the original game's code base or something, because a modern game could have probably been essentially open world.

I think they should aim to release at least 1 persona game a year.

2025 - Persona 4
2026 - Persona 6
2027 - Persona 1 Remake
2028- Persona 2 Remake
2029 - Persona 7

Maybe throw Metaphor 2 in there somewhere and that takes you to 2030.
 

Mibu no ookami

Demoted Member® Pro™
Fuck, had completely forgotten about the original Switch. It might as well be a PS3. With 140M+ units out, it also cannot be ignored, especially with how strong the sales are in Japan. If it's the baseline, which honestly, it might be, we're probably looking at something closer to Persona 3 Reload. If we're lucky, they'll ditch it and focus on just the Switch 2. They didn't release P3R on the Switch after all.

Fingers crossed it doesn't massively hold back the scale and scope of the game.

I wouldn't count on it. Persona 4 and 5 released 2 and 3 years after the launch of a new console respectively and still came out on last gen.

Neither Persona 3 reload or Metaphor released on the Switch. I can't imagine Persona 6 will either. Switch 2, sure, but definitely not Switch 1.
 

Danjin44

The nicest person on this forum
game is goaty goat goat

but hard to imagine complex characters like Kanji and Naoto surviving "modernisation"
It wasn’t about “complexity” and more about some people wanted Kanji to be gay and Naoto to be trans when actual story behind them is not about that.

Kanji despite his appearance he likes cute things to people see that they think of him being “girly” or gay this and TV word collective subconscious of people, so shadow Kanji look and acts very over the top gay because that how collective people see him as when find out he like “cute” things.

Naoto
is not only young but girl working in male dominated career which her colleagues don’t take her seriously.
She want to be guy not because tans or she is girl, it’s simply she want taken seriously as proper detective.
 
Last edited:

Lee49

Neo Member
Love all the Personas I've played but this is the one with my fav cast.

If it happens I just hope they don't tone down the difficulty like they did with Reload and Royal but no doubt it will be.
 

GametimeUK

Member
I need to play Persona, but unsure if to start at 4 or 5. Really don't want to start a long RPG either, but I keep putting it off. I'm not too sure if I'd want a remake since I can already play P4 Golden.
 

Danjin44

The nicest person on this forum
If it happens I just hope they don't tone down the difficulty like they did with Reload and Royal but no doubt it will be.
The issue they always add very over power mechanics which throws entire difficulty out the window.

Shin Megami Tensei 5 Vengeance did it perfectly, in my opinion it’s one of Atlus’s best re-release.
 
Last edited:

Gambit2483

Member
I think Persona 6 will dunk on all of the previous entries. I love 3, 4, and 5, but you can just see how budget-constrained they are. The series is no longer some niche, second-tier JRPG only weebs know about. The sales forecast will be high and there will be proper funding. I'm of course not expecting it to be full-on AAA with $150M+ in budget, but I could see something in the $50-75M range. It would have significantly more production values than 5, and of course, it wouldn't be shackled by the PS3. It will probably come to the PS4 and be cross-gen though.
I like your optimism, but this is still SEGA. They aren't exactly known for "big budget"...not saying you're wrong about Persona's rise in popularity/relevance.

I guess we'll see...
 
My first Persona game. P4G's position is on another level in my heart. Like Dragon Age Origins.

If they wanna do a remake, they need to remake directly the Golden version. Not follow P3 Remake + The Answer expansion. I really hate Sega because of this policy.
 

Danjin44

The nicest person on this forum
I think Persona 6 will dunk on all of the previous entries. I love 3, 4, and 5, but you can just see how budget-constrained they are. The series is no longer some niche, second-tier JRPG only weebs know about. The sales forecast will be high and there will be proper funding. I'm of course not expecting it to be full-on AAA with $150M+ in budget, but I could see something in the $50-75M range. It would have significantly more production values than 5, and of course, it wouldn't be shackled by the PS3. It will probably come to the PS4 and be cross-gen though.
When was the last time Atlus did “big budget” with any of their games?

Only few Japanese devs are willing to put lot of resource on graphics, thats Square Enix, Capcom and Kojima.

Rest don’t care about high tech graphics.
 
It wasn’t about “complexity” and more about some people wanted Kanji to be gay and Naoto to be trans when actual story behind them is not about that.

Kanji despite his appearance he likes cute things to people see that they think of him being “girly” or gay this and TV word collective subconscious of people, so shadow Kanji look and acts very over the top gay because that how collective people see him as when find out he like “cute” things.

Naoto
is not only young but girl working in male dominated career which her colleagues don’t take her seriously.
She want to be guy not because tans or she is girl, it’s simply she want taken seriously as proper detective.
that's what I mean

it's more complex than "this is a gay character" which is pretty much all a modern westerner industry imploding localizer would see
 

Gaiff

SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
I like your optimism, but this is still SEGA. They aren't exactly known for "big budget"...not saying you're wrong about Persona's rise in popularity/relevance.

I guess we'll see...

When was the last time Atlus did “big budget” with any of their games?

Only few Japanese devs are willing to put lot of resource on graphics, thats Square Enix, Capcom and Kojima.

Rest don’t care about high tech graphics.
50-75M in this day and age isn't exactly big-budget. I think Alan Wake 2 cost $50M and that's certainly not big-budget when we have AAA games in excess of $200M these days. Maybe I'm being optimistic, but I think Persona 6 has the potential to surpass 10M copies sold within just a few year.

Maybe you guys are right and it remains relatively low-budget and isn't much of an improvement over P5 when it comes to production values, but I do hope Sega sees this franchise is ready for the big leagues. Then again, maybe it's best left in the A space where there's less pressure to sell gangbusters.
 
Last edited:

Danjin44

The nicest person on this forum
50-75M in this day and age isn't exactly big-budget. I think Alan Wake 2 cost $50M and that's certainly not big-budget when we have AAA games in excess of $200M these days. Maybe I'm being optimistic, but I think Persona 6 has the potential to surpass 10M copies sold within just a few year.

Maybe you guys are right and it remains relatively low-budget and isn't much of an improvement over P5 when it comes to production values, but I do hope Sega sees this franchise is ready for the big leagues. Then again, maybe it's best left in the A space where there's less pressure to sell gangbusters.
That wouldn’t matter devs like Atlus and FROM mostly prioritize different things instead of high tech graphics and I don’t think that’s going to change.

I personally much more interested in art direction over raw graphics power and that Atlus always delivers.
 
Last edited:

Gaiff

SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
That wouldn’t matter devs like Atlus and FROM mostly prioritize different things instead of high tech graphics and I don’t think that’s going to change.

I personally much interested in art direction over raw graphics power and that Atlus always delivers.
Oh, I'm not even talking about high-tech graphics. I'm more concerned about how small and constrained the Persona games have felt thus far. It's a bunch of small maps with an NPC here or there and doesn't feel like a city proper. The games aren't fully voice acted, with minor cutscenes having no voice overs at all. Persona 5 is much better than 4 in that regard, but I'd wish every line spoken by characters was voiced, even minor ones.

What I'd love above all else is a proper city with larger areas that feel more alive and interconnected rather than separate and disconnected maps. I'm not asking for GTA level of realism here, but something more in line with what you'd expect from a 2025 game.

I don't care all that much for the graphics. It's an anime style and cutting-edge tech doesn't necessarily mesh with it. I have no doubt the art will deliver, it always does.
 
Last edited:

Danjin44

The nicest person on this forum
What I'd love above all else is a proper city with larger areas that feel more alive and interconnected rather than separate and disconnected maps. I'm not asking for GTA level of realism here, but something more in line with what you'd expect from a 2025 game.
Metaphor’s city was much bigger and more people walking around and they were not faceless like Persona 5 and P3Reload so I would say there is good chance they improve that even further in P6.
 
Last edited:
What I'd love above all else is a proper city with larger areas that feel more alive and interconnected rather than separate and disconnected maps. I'm not asking for GTA level of realism here, but something more in line with what you'd expect from a 2025 game.

Yep, that’s what I’m hoping for too. A more organic social link system would be awesome too.
 
Top Bottom