• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Winter Anime 2017 |OT| John Wick cleaning up KyoAni's mess

Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Jarmel

Banned
The Dragon Dentist-1
SyW8iRF.jpg
Click to expand...
This is a 45 minute special which is an expanded version/re-imagining of the Animator Expo short. It is directed by Tsurumaki of FLCL and Diebuster fame. My first impression of this isn't good. I feel like this was written originally as a full cour TV show and they later truncated it down to fit the 90 minute slot. This episode jumps around so often in tone that it seems as if parts of this episode were supposed to have been broken up into individual episodes and that necessary character work to make certain moments feel emotionally just weren't there.
The character death and ending don't work because the audience doesn't spend enough time with these characters to particularly care
. On top of that, there are multiple 'ending points' in the episode that give it an even more segmented feeling. It doesn't feel like a cohesive work.
EGTaEyv.jpg
Click to expand...
I found the first half to be really good as it focuses on the world-building and establishing this sort of magical place inside the dragon's mouth. I wanted more of the daily lifestyle of the Dragon Dentists however instead they use a montage to speed past those parts. There's a peaceful flow early on where I'm intrigued by the setting and art. The show introduces a male character called Bell who is the most boring human being alive. At times he threatens to be interesting but that's all it amounts to. Nonoko on the other hand seems to be the main character while Bell is just a tool used for exposition purposes. Bell isn't given enough screen time to be an captivating character in his own right and is more a waste of time than anything else. Nonoko though is delightful and charmed me with her wide range of expressions.
1CctSTD.jpg
Click to expand...
The second half is largely an action bonanza and reminded me of Kill La Kill with how the Dentists' weapon designs. I found this segment to be kind of flat as the action isn't staged well enough to be that entertaining nor was I that impressed with the action. That's not to say it's badly animated (there are some good cuts) but considering the super staff working on this, I was underwhelmed. It does transition though into this melancholic look at what makes a Dragon Dentist, in that their test is being able to accept their fate. I thought that segment was encaptivating but then the climax happens and that atmosphere is wiped out.
2OR5gQY.jpg
Click to expand...
The background art was great, which was to be expected from Studio Pablo. I think on the visual side I was most impressed by the background stuff actually. There's a light pastel texture to the initial backgrounds in the dragon's mouth that I was entranced by. There was more CGI than I expected, which makes sense since it's Khara and they need to put their in-house CGI team to work I guess. I found the smaller cavity designs to be attractive but was less enamored with the larger ones. The larger ones are just too angular and look like some sort of polygonal monster I would have seen in the 90's. The music is uh diverse and I can see some people having issues with it. I personally didn't mind the insert song during the montage.
PRABWZX.jpg

lol okay bro
Click to expand...
That ending though, just straight Xam'd. MetroidPrimeRib is going to be very happy with Dragon Dentist. That's all I'll say.
 
V

Vincent Alexander

Member
Narag said:
I had dropped it at 2 my first time around due to it not grabbing me initially. Episode 3 is what sold me later on.
Click to expand...
LotusHD said:
Report back to us :D
Click to expand...

Mob Psycho 100 - Episode 3

Well, you weren't lying. Episode 3 is a drastic improvement and enough to hook me into the show. It nailed some key elements I felt the first 2 episodes lacked. This episode had focus. Coherence. And a great theme that paralleled well with Mob's search for happiness/love. This is also the first episode where the music really played into the scenes and enhanced them. I hardly noticed music the first 2 episodes...and not in a good way. And finally...the episode was funny. It was goofy, silly, and fun. I think the fact it was a very focused episode hitting on a specific theme helped the goofiness land because it had something material and real for it's foundation we could all relate to. What strikes me the most odd about my own opinion of the episode is that the action was my least favorite part. It wasn't bad, as the animation is great. It just doesn't have the "oomph" of One Punch Man. Not yet anyway. And yeah...I hate comparing shows, but it is going to be really hard to keep One Punch Man out of my mind, not only because it's the same creator, but mostly because it's my last anime watched.

OK. Ramble over!
 
H

hosannainexcelsis

Member
Tiger Mask W 8

Yellow Devil already? I have to expect that either Tiger Mask will lose, or more likely some unexpected event will prevent Tiger Mask from confronting Yellow Devil at this tournament. I can't imagine the show would spend its major conflict now when there's still so long to go.
 
A

Aki-at

Member
Vincent Alexander said:
Mob Psycho 100 - Episode 3

Well, you weren't lying. Episode 3 is a drastic improvement and enough to hook me into the show. It nailed some key elements I felt the first 2 episodes lacked. This episode had focus. Coherence. And a great theme that paralleled well with Mob's search for happiness/love. This is also the first episode where the music really played into the scenes and enhanced them. I hardly noticed music the first 2 episodes...and not in a good way. And finally...the episode was funny. It was goofy, silly, and fun. I think the fact it was a very focused episode hitting on a specific theme helped the goofiness land because it had something material and real for it's foundation we could all relate to. What strikes me the most odd about my own opinion of the episode is that the action was my least favorite part. It wasn't bad, as the animation is great. It just doesn't have the "oomph" of One Punch Man. Not yet anyway. And yeah...I hate comparing shows to anything else, but it is going to be really hard to keep One Punch Man out of my mind, not only because it's the same creator, but mostly because it's my last anime watched.

OK. Ramble over!
Click to expand...

Oh don't worry, that was just an opening act to the better fights in the series :p
 
L

LotusHD

Banned
Vincent Alexander said:
Mob Psycho 100 - Episode 3

Well, you weren't lying. Episode 3 is a drastic improvement and enough to hook me into the show. It nailed some key elements I felt the first 2 episodes lacked. This episode had focus. Coherence. And a great theme that paralleled well with Mob's search for happiness/love. This is also the first episode where the music really played into the scenes and enhanced them. I hardly noticed music the first 2 episodes...and not in a good way. And finally...the episode was funny. It was goofy, silly, and fun. I think the fact it was a very focused episode hitting on a specific theme helped the goofiness land because it had something material and real for it's foundation we could all relate to. What strikes me the most odd about my own opinion of the episode is that the action was my least favorite part. It wasn't bad, as the animation is great. It just doesn't have the "oomph" of One Punch Man. Not yet anyway. And yeah...I hate comparing shows, but it is going to be really hard to keep One Punch Man out of my mind, not only because it's the same creator, but mostly because it's my last anime watched.

OK. Ramble over!
Click to expand...

I feel like you'll find it's a better show, in terms of writing at the very least.
I feel like it has better animation as well, when everything is said and done. More dynamic or whatever, I don't know how exactly to phrase it.
Not that I dislike OPM, but that's how it went for me. Read/watched it first, then I slowly realized that Mob Psycho was just better, mainly because it goes far beyond OPM's tendency to rely on the gag of Saitama being unbeatable and not much else. But we'll see. Glad you're sold now though!
 
A

Aikidoka

Member
hosannainexcelsis said:
K-ON!! 15

The school makes the entire student body run a marathon? How cruel!



It's a highlight of the show for sure. A simple concept that's at the core of classic science fiction, but for that very reason it was enjoyable to see it so solidly executed. You could say that about the entire show, really.



Akira is in the running for the best animated Japanese film ever. (Redline is usually thrown out as the other big contender.) A lot of care went into it. The character designs are quintessential Otomo.



Hopefully this will be a good lesson to never trust MAL recommendations.
Click to expand...

At first, I thought that Yamato was just kind of silly with its space ships being literal battleships and the Navy aesthetic. But, that, with the Japanese big band music, comes together very well. It feels very unique with a degree of "camp" but still a persistently heavy atmosphere. Edit: Also, I kind of love the way the episodes end with replaying certain snapshots of the episode with the music.

I've never even heard of Redline. I'll have to watch it. I imagine with Madhouse behind it, the animation is spectacular.

Narag said:
Following MAL recommendations just makes you a Nazi collaborator.
Click to expand...

oh fuck, I completely forgot about that thread.
 
S

sonicmj1

Member
John Wick 2

The Hotline Miami of action movie franchises.

Not a perfect comparison because the action here is still really damn good while Hotline Miami 2 got too exacting.

Well worth the price of admission.
 
H

hosannainexcelsis

Member
Aikidoka said:
At first, I thought that Yamato was just kind of silly with its space ships being literal battleships and the Navy aesthetic. But, that, with the Japanese big band music, comes together very well. It feels very unique with a degree of "camp" but still a persistently heavy atmosphere. Edit: Also, I kind of love the way the episodes end with replaying certain snapshots of the episode with the music.
Click to expand...

You realize, of course, that Yamato 2199 is a remake of a much older anime series from 1974? It's a modernized version, but it has great respect for the original and pays homage to it in many ways, such as retaining the iconic Yamato design even while making the ship not be a rebuilt version of the actual World War II battleship anymore. The soundtrack consists substantially of arrangements of the original's soundtrack. I wouldn't call the music "big band" though, since that implies a jazz ensemble which the music in Yamato isn't really.

I've never even heard of Redline. I'll have to watch it. I imagine with Madhouse behind it, the animation is spectacular.
Click to expand...

Redline is directed by star animator Takeshi Koike and features an incredible lineup of animators doing really high-effort work throughout. It took incredibly long to make because of how high a standard Koike set for the film. I'm not a big fan of it personally, but it's worth watching just to see the animation.
 
A

Aikidoka

Member
hosannainexcelsis said:
You realize, of course, that Yamato 2199 is a remake of a much older anime series from 1974? It's a modernized version, but it has great respect for the original and pays homage to it in many ways, such as retaining the iconic Yamato design even while making the ship not be a rebuilt version of the actual World War II battleship anymore. The soundtrack consists substantially of arrangements of the original's soundtrack. I wouldn't call the music "big band" though, since that implies a jazz ensemble which the music in Yamato isn't really.



Redline is directed by star animator Takeshi Koike and features an incredible lineup of animators doing really high-effort work throughout. It took incredibly long to make because of how high a standard Koike set for the film. I'm not a big fan of it personally, but it's worth watching just to see the animation.
Click to expand...

Yes, I know it's a remake, but I didn't know that the Yamato was an actual class ship, which is interesting. Regardless, my thought is that a naval ship design would be a poor choice for a space ship.
I just used big band as a catch all as I wasn't sure of the genre.
 
L

LotusHD

Banned
Narag said:
Production issues. Shirobako isn't for everyone but seeing the issues faced by the production staff in the show provides a lot of context for thoughts like that.
Click to expand...

Shirobako really helped to make me appreciate a lot of the shit I take for granted lol
 
C

Chindogg

Member
Branduil said:
Monster girls were a mistake.
Click to expand...

That's in the manga too. It's an isolated one off regarding the overall issue involving monster girls in general in regards to law which works for the world it's in, but when related to the real world causes problems. Unfortunately, nothing is ever considered isolated anymore and now we have this fiasco.

Meanwhile no one on Twitter wants to point out sexualizing kids in Dragon Maid because that's a "cute, gay love story" in it's own world.
 
V

Vincent Alexander

Member
LotusHD said:
I feel like you'll find it's a better show, in terms of writing at the very least.
I feel like it has better animation as well, when everything is said and done. More dynamic or whatever, I don't know how exactly to phrase it.
Not that I dislike OPM, but that's how it went for me. Read/watched it first, then I slowly realized that Mob Psycho was just better, mainly because it goes far beyond OPM's tendency to rely on the gag of Saitama being unbeatable and not much else. But we'll see. Glad you're sold now though!
Click to expand...
I'm afraid to click spoiler...! Is that for OPM or Mob Psycho?
 
C

Chindogg

Member
Cornbread78 said:
This double standard is great, huh.

Gross...
Click to expand...

Hey the same thing happened when evidence started alluding that Mercy may be grooming Phara in the Pharmercy ship for Overwatch considering Mercy was close to Ana while appearing to be around Phara as a child. When I pointed that out, my liberal friends accused me of linking gay people to sexual predators.

*shrug*

TUSR said:
Found your problem.

We discussed this a decent amount on Wednesday.
Click to expand...

That we did.

Don't wanna open up another massive can of worms, but shit like that is what old white people see as reasons to vote conservative.
 
H

hosannainexcelsis

Member
Chindogg said:
That's in the manga too. It's an isolated one off regarding the overall issue involving monster girls in general in regards to law which works for the world it's in, but when related to the real world causes problems. Unfortunately, nothing is ever considered isolated anymore and now we have this fiasco.

Meanwhile no one on Twitter wants to point out sexualizing kids in Dragon Maid because that's a "cute, gay love story" in it's own world.
Click to expand...

I have seen quite a few people on Twitter, not to mention in this thread, express discomfort with the nature of the material in episode 6 of Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid.
 
K

KraytarJ

Member
K-ON!! 3
Ritsu's existential crisis bums me out.

K-ON!! 4
Skull..................?

K-ON!! 5
Ui simultaneously proving that she's too good for this world, while also being a perfect pair with Yui.
 
Cornbread78

Cornbread78

Member
Chindogg said:
Hey the same thing happened when evidence started alluding that Mercy may be grooming Phara in the Pharmercy ship for Overwatch considering Mercy was close to Ana while appearing to be around Phara as a child. When I pointed that out, my liberal friends accused me of linking gay people to sexual predators.

*shrug*
Click to expand...


Well, the bottom is and should be contained to "sexualizing children" is sexualizing children be it gay, straight or bi.. Unacceptable.


But yeah, as others have mentioned, we covered this heavily earlier this week.
 
B

Big Papa Husker

Member
Not sure if this is the place to ask but are there any sci-fi anime series this season? I really enjoyed ReZero and was interested in Erased and Orange last year.
 
N

Narag

Member
Magic Knight Rayearth 12

Umi's come a long way and is unrecognizable from her prissy beginning. Anyhow, fit an ep of his in because haly got mad at me in irc for watching fantasy mecha anime so thought I'd mix it up a bit.
 
B

Basileus777

Member
Qurupeke said:
Koi to Uso PV, Summer 2017.

Hmm, has anyone read the source material? It looks interesting and it kind of gives me the same vibe as Scum's Wish. I mean, the characters even look like Hanabi and Moca, just with bigger eyes...
Click to expand...

It's nothing like Scum's Wish. The source material is a slow paced and boring love triangle featuring indecisive and dense characters. It's not particularly racy and there really aren't many "lies."
 
M

MetroidPrimeRib

Banned
sonicmj1 said:
John Wick 2

The Hotline Miami of action movie franchises.

Not a perfect comparison because the action here is still really damn good while Hotline Miami 2 got too exacting.

Well worth the price of admission.
Click to expand...

It has like the same flow with how fast John moves through weapons, even with the reloading

He even throws a gun at a dude once to disorient him
 
T

ThatChairMan

Member
Hyouka 3

I was enjoying how comfy and mundane the first two episodes were, but this whole Chitanda motivation is really taking me out of it. I didn't even really like her to begin with, and everything being overly dramatic this episode only made it worse. I do hope this gets resolved quickly.
 
P

PshycoNinja

Member
Wait. People saying Mob Psycho 100 is better than One Punch Man? Crazy! OPM is awesome from episode one. While I now like MP100, it took a few episodes for me to get into it. That automatically makes OPM superior. I also like both in terms of animation, but Mob though has instances where it's animation would get inconsistent or weird.

I dunno. I just enjoyed OPM from beginning to end more than Mob.
 
Z

zulux21

Member
Big Papa Husker said:
Not sure if this is the place to ask but are there any sci-fi anime series this season? I really enjoyed ReZero and was interested in Erased and Orange last year.
Click to expand...

https://myanimelist.net/anime/32615/Youjo_Senki?q=tanya isn't scifi, but the magic system used in the anime feels a bit more scifi tech wise than normal magic to me since the magic is mostly based on technology (at least through the first four episodes as I am watching the funimation dub of it.)

it has a person changing worlds after death like re:zero, and supernatural beings messing with stuff.

really it's been surprisingly decent so far.

PshycoNinja said:
Wait. People saying Mob Psycho 100 is better than One Punch Man? Crazy! OPM is awesome from episode one. While I now like MP100, it took a few episodes for me to get into it. That automatically makes OPM superior. I also like both in terms of animation, but Mob though has instances where it's animation would get inconsistent or weird.

I dunno. I just enjoyed OPM from beginning to end more than Mob.
Click to expand...

the crazier thing is people trying to say mp100 has the better opening song >.>
I mean it's not a bad opening but it's no OPM opening.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Media Create Sales: Week 35, 2020 (Aug 24 - Aug 30)
Sales-Age
0
1K
ZSaberLink replied
Winter Anime 2019 |OT| Your waifu is safe, no more Goblins
2
53
9K
petran79 replied
Media Create Sales: Week 26, 2019 (Jun 24 - Jun 30)
Sales-Age
0
813
ZSaberLink replied
Media Create Sales: Week 27, 2019 (Jul 01 - Jul 07)
Sales-Age
0
907
ZSaberLink replied
  • Locked
Spring Anime 2017 |OT| Don't be a SukaSuka for Gacha
301 302 303 304 305
15K
2M
TUSR replied
Top Bottom