• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Naughty Dog Announces Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
If people are still ragging on him, that's because he has yet to prove to gamers his next big game (Intergalactic) will be awesome with no politics, no killing off likeable characters etc... Just prove to gamers Intergalactic is much different than LOU2.

Gamers can totally change. COD games used to universally get awesome reviews, then it changed to hit and miss. Last years revamped MWIII got drilled into the dirt. I think it was the worst rated COD ever even worse than trash Vanguard.

BO6 comes out and it's back to old form with a good rated game. Not as good as the old 360 days when they'd get 90/100, but it got 83. It rebounded and nobody cares about MWIII anymore.

Guys like Druckmann are in a tougher spot to rebound because his games take 5 years to come out. So if the last game pissed off people, he'll have to endure 5 years of backlash. COD doesn't. It can rebound a year later. That's why myself and others have stressed having a good trailer is important especially for new IPs. And so far, this trailer didn't do that as people are ragging on it. And not just gaffers. Go to YT and popular game streamer channels are too. And they are criticizing valid points. Skinhead lead who isn't attractive (some people will claim she is, but not to many of us and not to conventional gaming characters or real life), zero gameplay (unless that final 5 second clip is supposed to represent gameplay? It might), character already has a gen z defiant attitude (sucking a straw in someone's face not giving a shit), and people remember the product placements more than the game.

They could had avoided all the bad backlash by just having a good looking character, some kick ass battle scenes and gameplay snip. And a gameplay snip is the least important because gamers know many games are 100% CGI until later on when real clips come out. So ND didn't even have to include real gameplay footage yet.

People are comparing Intergalactic to GotG. Might not be a totally accurate comparison but close enough. There's reasons why people are ragging on Druckmann/Intergalactic while GotG trailers and movies get high ratings. And heck, GotG even has cheesy shit like a tree dude and fighting raccoon.

This is why your post doesn't make any sense.


If people are still ragging on him, that's because he has yet to prove to gamers his next big game (Intergalactic) will be awesome with no politics, no killing off likeable characters etc... Just prove to gamers Intergalactic is much different than LOU2.

They could had avoided all the bad backlash by just having a good looking character, some kick ass battle scenes and gameplay snip. And a gameplay snip is the least important because gamers know many games are 100% CGI until later on when real clips come out. So ND didn't even have to include real gameplay footage yet.

You're saying people are still raging because he has yet to prove that his "next big game" will be awesome with no politics, killing likable characters etc.

THEN you tell me this could have all been avoided with a good-looking character and some kick ass battle scenes.

That wouldn't work because people would still assume his game is filled with politics and he wouldn't be able to prove it UNTIL the game is released. This means people are still going to hate it regardless.


People are comparing Intergalactic to GotG. Might not be a totally accurate comparison but close enough. There's reasons why people are ragging on Druckmann/Intergalactic while GotG trailers and movies get high ratings. And heck, GotG even has cheesy shit like a tree dude and fighting raccoon.

I believe those people are dumb because GotG is an action comedy and this game doesn't give any hints about being a comedic video game. The only thing similar is that they're both set in space.

This gives off vibes of an 80's sci-fi action movie.
 

mckmas8808

Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
Do you remember how people use the dislike/like ratio to prove people don't like the film?

FURIOSA : A MAD MAX SAGA | OFFICIAL TRAILER #1
Like: 232k
Dislike: 22k

FURIOSA : A MAD MAX SAGA | OFFICIAL TRAILER #2
Like: 117k
Dislike: 13k

FURIOSA : A MAD MAX SAGA | Sneak Peek “Chapters” Trailer
Like: 12k
Dislike: 760

Wicked - Official Trailer
like: 288k
Dislike: 105k

Wicked - Official Trailer 2
Like: 41k
Dislike: 30k

There were more positive reactions to Wicked Trailers only on, but it got progressively worse up until the movie was officially released.





The Anti-woke content creators blasted it, but it turned out to be one of the biggest movies of the year.

I don't know why Furiosa failed. It was also blasted as "woke" but the trailers had a more positive reaction.

You have two examples of movies that people labeled as woke, and one was highly successful. If "wokeness" destroys movies then it would be consistent throughout, but it's not. This is proof it doesn't turn off people as much as the anti-woke crowd thinks.


Bro.... You doing the lord's work!
 

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
This is why your post doesn't make any sense.






You're saying people are still raging because he has yet to prove that his "next big game" will be awesome with no politics, killing likable characters etc.

THEN you tell me this could have all been avoided with a good-looking character and some kick ass battle scenes.

That wouldn't work because people would still assume his game is filled with politics and he wouldn't be able to prove it UNTIL the game is released. This means people are still going to hate it regardless.




I believe those people are dumb because GotG is an action comedy and this game doesn't give any hints about being a comedic video game. The only thing similar is that they're both set in space.

This gives off vibes of an 80's sci-fi action movie.
Wrong.

Intergalactic would had gotten way more likes and not trolled to death with memes with even YT streamers making fun of it if then made the trailer with a better looking character, and more gameplay, or at least more CGI action. Instead, you got a skinhead girl who looks like a guy (lesbian red flag), gen z attitude (not a likeable trait), and more time spent on product placements and Pet Shop Boys than a game. At least if the trailer is all cut scenes (common for new games), make it a kick ass one like Witcher 4. The trailer was 4 minutes of basically nothing.

ND failed. There's zero info in that trailer it'll be something different. That's why people are laughing at it. Heck, the first scene is someone shaving their head in the sink to look like a thug.

And until Druckmann proves otherwise, it'll continue. Even right now, ND is double downing on it. Look at this laughable cover art. Gamers prefer playing good looking characters (esp if it's female lead). Not many people are craving to play a skinhead girl with attitude.

Intergalactic_The_Heretic_Prophet_poster.png
 
Last edited:

TGO

Hype Train conductor. Works harder than it steams.
So with all this talk I decided to Upgrade my copy of TLOU2 to the PS5 version and check out it's Pro Enhancements and I'm really not impressed, in fact I don't remember it looking this bad.
I mean at first glance it looks great and cutscenes are look fine too.
But during game play if you really look at it there is this mosaic look to parts of the rendering.
I first noticed it with Dina as I was wondering what the fuck was going on with her face, but it's actually all over the place
And just looks bad even for a PS4 game.
Thing is, I don't remember it looking like this so maybe this is a PS5 Pro thing or am I miss remembering 🤔
 
Last edited:
Uncharted in space sounds like shit.

Uncharted 4 was 80% climbing 10 % cutscenes and 10% action.

The action was great. But I can't find nothing worse than the repetitive climbing/exploring crap.
 

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
Wrong.

Intergalactic would had gotten way more likes and not trolled to death with memes with even YT streamers making fun of it if then made the trailer with a better looking character, and more gameplay, or at least more CGI action. Instead, you got a skinhead girl who looks like a guy (lesbian red flag), gen z attitude (not a likeable trait), and more time spent on product placements and Pet Shop Boys than a game. At least if the trailer is all cut scenes (common for new games), make it a kick ass one like Witcher 4. The trailer was 4 minutes of basically nothing.

ND failed. There's zero info in that trailer it'll be something different. That's why people are laughing at it. Heck, the first scene is someone shaving their head in the sink to look like a thug.

And until Druckmann proves otherwise, it'll continue. Even right now, ND is double downing on it. Look at this laughable cover art. Gamers prefer playing good looking characters (esp if it's female lead). Not many people are craving to play a skinhead girl with attitude.

Intergalactic_The_Heretic_Prophet_poster.png

No, you said they would have avoided ALL of the backlash.

It wouldn't stop the Druckmann haters from attacking his game, even if people considered the trailer good.

Even if they release one of their best gameplay trailers next year, you're still going to have a group of people hating on it.

CD Project released a trailer and people are STILL calling Ciri ugly and that she's a female lead of the game.
 

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
No, you said they would have avoided ALL of the backlash.

It wouldn't stop the Druckmann haters from attacking his game, even if people considered the trailer good.

Even if they release one of their best gameplay trailers next year, you're still going to have a group of people hating on it.

CD Project released a trailer and people are STILL calling Ciri ugly and that she's a female lead of the game.
Awww. Did I say All? Did I hurt your feelings?

Ok, I change it to Almost All. Lol

You have a weird fascination with YT video like and dislike ratios. Who cares if druckmann will always get laughs at and Ciri has critics. Druckmann does that to himself with another crap trailer and Witcher 4 trailer likes much more than intergalactic.

Onimusha trailer had a like ratio of 99:1. So what if 1% of people on YT didn’t like it. No video is going to get perfect ratio. It did way better than I intergalactic too.

Oh let me guess you’re going to find a video….. duhhhh here’s a video with zero dislikes. Ok fine post it.

Let’s face it. You just don’t like intergalactic being made fun of. And you know since the game won’t be out for a while as more news will be drip fed for maybe a year or two it means gamers will have open season to laugh more.

You can tell it already bugs druckmann as he already did another tweet trying to cement it as a new blockbuster franchise (the other thread). The guy rushed it out so quick he posted uncharted twice.
 
Last edited:

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
Awww. Did I say All? Did I hurt your feelings?

Ok, I change it to Almost All. Lol

You have a weird fascination with YT video like and dislike ratios. Who cares if druckmann will always get laughs at and Ciri has critics. Druckmann does that to himself with another crap trailer and Witcher 4 trailer likes much more than intergalactic.

Onimusha trailer had a like ratio of 99:1. Do what if 1% of people on YT didn’t like it. No video is going to get perfect ratio.

Oh let me guess you’re going to find a video….. duhhhh here’s a video with zero dislikes. Ok fine post it.

Let’s face it. You just don’t like intergalactic being made fun of. And you know since the game won’t out for a while and more news will be drip fed for maybe a year or two it means gamers will have open season to laugh more.

You can tell it already bugs druckmann as he already did another tweet trying to cement it as a new blockbuster franchise (the other thread). The guy rushed it out so quick he posted uncharted twice.

That's not going to work here.

I'm poking holes in your argument because it's simply just flawed. It's obvious they were going to receive backlash after what happened with The Last of Us Part II, so no one should be surprised.

What happened to all the PS5 Pro backlash?
What happened to the PS Protal backlash?


They're almost nonexistent outside of the people criticizing the PSSR.

I'm showing you how online criticism doesn't mean much because it's completely different than how the majority of gamers will feel about the game. You're saying I have a weird fascination with the dislike/like ratio when you're putting a lot of weight on people's YouTube comments.

Horizon Forbidden West, God of War Ragnarok, Spider-Man 2, and Ghost of Yotei all received backlash. People disappear when the game turns out to be successful.

You can tell it already bugs druckmann as he already did another tweet trying to cement it as a new blockbuster franchise (the other thread). The guy rushed it out so quick he posted uncharted twice.

This is like the second time you mention Neil's tweets about something bothering him.

He rarely tweets and responds to criticism, but you're acting like he's always on Twitter responding to backlash from gamers when he doesn't.
 

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
That's not going to work here.

I'm poking holes in your argument because it's simply just flawed. It's obvious they were going to receive backlash after what happened with The Last of Us Part II, so no one should be surprised.

What happened to all the PS5 Pro backlash?
What happened to the PS Protal backlash?


They're almost nonexistent outside of the people criticizing the PSSR.

I'm showing you how online criticism doesn't mean much because it's completely different than how the majority of gamers will feel about the game. You're saying I have a weird fascination with the dislike/like ratio when you're putting a lot of weight on people's YouTube comments.

Horizon Forbidden West, God of War Ragnarok, Spider-Man 2, and Ghost of Yotei all received backlash. People disappear when the game turns out to be successful.



This is like the second time you mention Neil's tweets about something bothering him.

He rarely tweets and responds to criticism, but you're acting like he's always on Twitter responding to backlash from gamers when he doesn't.
Relax naughty dog defence force.

Go ahead. Poke holes in my opinion. Doesn’t change the fact intergalactic has got laughed at more than all the top games at the show combined. So your opinion is no better than mine. At least I can see why the trailer bombed and has been made fun of by everyone including streamers. You can’t.

Witcher 4 and onimusha got great feedback and hype. Copy those trailers.
 

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
Relax naughty dog defence force.

Go ahead. Poke holes in my opinion. Doesn’t change the fact intergalactic has got laughed at more than all the top games at the show combined. So your opinion is no better than mine. At least I can see why the trailer bombed and has been made fun of by everyone including streamers. You can’t.

Witcher 4 and onimusha got great feedback and hype. Copy those trailers.

Horizon Forbidden West, God of War Ragnarok, Spider-Man 2, and The Last of Us Part II received more criticism than most of the game trailers at the VGA, and it didn't stop the games from being a success.

Some streamers said the trailer wasn't good, but they're still interested to see more of the game. Tons of streamers were happy because it's a Naughty Dog game.

But you don't point that out because it doesn't fit your narrative.

If this game turns out to be a success then all that criticism won't even matter. The only thing people are convinced of is that The Last of Us Part II underperformed despite showing zero evidence and ignoring Neil Druckmann's comments calling the game profitable and successful.
 

Nickolaidas

Member
All the successful "woke" games are ignored because it doesn't fit the narrative. People were shitting on Hades II for their designs, but it has over 100k peak CCU on Steam was swept under the rug. No one brings up Spider-Man 2 or God of War Ragnarok after the sales announcement. Baldur's Gate 3 and Hogwarts Legacy are both used by the anti-woke crowd, but those games would be considered "woke" as well. People bashed ugly character designs in Silent Hill 2, but Konami considers it a success and it was never mentioned again.
Wokeness doesn't sell. That is an undisputed fact. But it's also not a dealbreaker because, in actuality, wokeness is - in video game terms - a nerf. A 10/10 game will become a 9 or less / 10. A 4/10 will become a 3 or less / 10, depending on HOW much woke the game is (how many 'woke points', if you will). Baldur's Gate III didn't sell a bazillion units because a gay vampire can fuck a druid in bear form. It sold that well because it had a LOT of content, devs who listened to feedback, is based on the greatest RPG IP of all time, had good written characters and had a good deal of NSFW content for those who want to live their rpg sex fantasies with their waifus and husbandos.

BG3 didn't succeed because it was woke - it succeeded because it had a LOT of pros which vastly outnumbered the cons of it being woke. But if BG3 had MORE woke points than it already had (very ugly character models, especially for the females, inoffensive writing, total emasculation of white male characters, preaching about non-binaries, etc.), then it would have sold less.

So yeah, while a game being woke isn't an automatic death sentence for its sales, it needs to be a very, very VERY good game in order to make one handwave/tolerate/stomach its wokeness.
 
Last edited:

Cakeboxer

Member
Horizon Forbidden West, God of War Ragnarok, Spider-Man 2, and The Last of Us Part II received more criticism than most of the game trailers at the VGA, and it didn't stop the games from being a success.
Didn't they all sell less than their predecessor even though FBW and Ragnarok had the advantage that like 80% or so of the 2022 sold PS5s (when it was constantly sold out) were bundled with one of those 2 games?
 

EDMIX

Banned
You just don’t like intergalactic being made fun of. And you know since the game won’t be out for a while as more news will be drip fed for maybe a year or two it means gamers will have open season to laugh more.
Well you've made this claim about a few users on here

Not everybody actually cares about the majority public perception, put it this way the youtubers that talk about the subject have obsessively targeted so many developers that it's gotten to the point where it's having the opposite of fact a lot of us have started to tune them out. They are free to have the opinions that they have but I don't know how much stock you think many of us put in those opinions to purchase games based on them.

We're talking about a crowd of individuals that seems to always have some reason for disliking a developer so why would we then objectively believe that their views on a game are real honest and legitimate? You could only make so many of those videos before we just believe you have a hate for that developer


So why the did you think we were going to care that these same exact people dislike this new game that's being shown? What evidence exist that they were going to even praise this game when they've been attacking the developer for this long?

So when you look at a lot of the community that just plays games you'll start to realize most of us are not out here telling you about YouTube or Twitter or telling you we're buying a game because of this person off a social media or something strange like this, So this idea that any of us genuinely care what the public perception is about this is quite humorous.

That's like trying to fucking say the person that gave Hogwarts a 0 it's going to tell you something about another game coming out and you should listen to them.....

Are you sure you're going to take that person seriously?

Why did you think we would care about YouTube or Twitter then? Lol

When I find some game is getting a tone of attention by a certain type of youtuber and glance over into that playlist history, its hard to take what they are saying seriously anymore then I would the person that gave Hogwarts a zero trying to tell me that Space Marine is a zero too....

Its not having the effect you might think Streets.

Using the ScreamingRageFace Youtuber metric bullshit, Fortnite, Far Cry 5, Battlefront 1 and 2, every Call Of Duty, every Assassin's Creed should have all failed lol
Horizon Forbidden West, God of War Ragnarok, Spider-Man 2, and The Last of Us Part II received more criticism than most of the game trailers at the VGA, and it didn't stop the games from being a success.
^ This part.

Making a bunch of triggered videos about a game or obsession over a developer and doxing actor doesn't really mean everyone will just magically stop playing games.
 
Last edited:

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
Wokeness doesn't sell. That is an undisputed fact. But it's also not a dealbreaker because, in actuality, wokeness is - in video game terms - a nerf. A 10/10 game will become a 9 or less / 10. A 4/10 will become a 3 or less / 10, depending on HOW much woke the game is (how many 'woke points', if you will). Baldur's Gate III didn't sell a bazillion units because a gay vampire can fuck a druid in bear form. It sold that well because it had a LOT of content, devs who listened to feedback, is based on the greatest RPG IP of all time, had good written characters and had pretty of NSFW content for those who want to live their rpg sex fantasies with their waifus and husbandos.

BG3 didn't succeed because it was woke - it succeeded because it had a LOT of pros which vastly outnumbered the cons of it being woke. But if BG3 had MORE woke points than it already had (very ugly character models, especially for the females, inoffensive writing, total emasculation of white male characters, preaching about non-binaries, etc.), then it would have sold less.

So yeah, while a game being woke isn't an automatic death sentence for its sales, it needs to be a very, very VERY good game in order to make one handwave/tolerate/stomach its wokeness.

No one is saying games like BG3 succeeded because of its wokeness, we're pointing out that wokeness has little impact on overall sales.

Most of these games are failing because they're bad games. It also doesn't have to be a very, very, very good game, it just has to be a good game and there's a good chance it's going to succeed.
 

Fess

Member
AI is awesome lol.

The last resort to save entertainment media if wokists are still in charge in another 20 years.
The combination of AI and mods could become a wonderful thing going forward. Maybe we can fish out the in-game models and use AI to tweak them to our liking as if the games have a character creator, would solve so many things when designers are pushing an agenda.
 

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
Well you've made this claim about a few users on here

Not everybody actually cares about the majority public perception, put it this way the youtubers that talk about the subject have obsessively targeted so many developers that it's gotten to the point where it's having the opposite of fact a lot of us have started to tune them out. They are free to have the opinions that they have but I don't know how much stock you think many of us put in those opinions to purchase games based on them.

We're talking about a crowd of individuals that seems to always have some reason for disliking a developer so why would we then objectively believe that their views on a game are real honest and legitimate? You could only make so many of those videos before we just believe you have a hate for that developer


So why the did you think we were going to care that these same exact people dislike this new game that's being shown? What evidence exist that they were going to even praise this game when they've been attacking the developer for this long?

So when you look at a lot of the community that just plays games you'll start to realize most of us are not out here telling you about YouTube or Twitter or telling you we're buying a game because of this person off a social media or something strange like this, So this idea that any of us genuinely care what the public perception is about this is quite humorous.

That's like trying to fucking say the person that gave Hogwarts a 0 it's going to tell you something about another game coming out and you should listen to them.....

Are you sure you're going to take that person seriously?

Why did you think we would care about YouTube or Twitter then? Lol

When I find some game is getting a tone of attention by a certain type of youtuber and glance over into that playlist history, its hard to take what they are saying seriously anymore then I would the person that gave Hogwarts a zero trying to tell me that Space Marine is a zero too....

Its not having the effect you might think Streets.

Using the ScreamingRageFace Youtuber metric bullshit, Fortnite, Far Cry 5, Battlefront 1 and 2, every Call Of Duty, every Assassin's Creed should have all failed lol

^ This part.

Making a bunch of triggered videos about a game or obsession over a developer and doxing actor doesn't really mean everyone will just magically stop playing games.
That’s fine. People can ignore all the external criticism if they want.

Even ignore gaf too if this site is included since this game has got more negativity than probably the rest of the games shown at the awards show combined.

If some gamers don’t care about any of the criticism, they can just ignore all of it if it is so inconsequential.

Or even better, just convince gamers the trailer is so good they are missing out.
 
Last edited:

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
Also, about the Mad Max Furiosa / Wicked point:

Mad Max Furiosa flopped because it was a Mad Max movie without Mad Max.

Wicked did well because it was a movie which didn't betray its target demographic.

Barbie and Wicked are two movies that are considered woke. If you're giving reasons why they were successful despite being woke, then you're only proving my point most people don't care.
 

Cakeboxer

Member
It was already reported that bundles didn't have a major impact on sales.


Where did i say majority? Bundles in general have not much impact. But if the hardware is sold out all the time and when it's available and you have to buy an additional game it certainly has an impact on the sales. Like i said, not the majority, but 100% a couple of millions.
 

EDMIX

Banned
Didn't they all sell less than their predecesso
? huh? yea...I don't know about that one bud.

God Of War 2018 moved 23 million units as of 2022, so it took 5 years to move that

God Of War Ragnarok moved 15 mullion units in 1 year....

Lets make this make sense lol That is like saying GTA6 sold less then GTA5 and its like 5 days into the game's launch lol I mean, use some context here next time. I don't now of any IP that is out of the game matching LIFE TIME SALES of something past 20 million units, not even Call Of Duty is doing something so absurd to be making this weird claim

If some gamers don’t care about any of the criticism, they can just ignore all of it if it is so inconsequential.
True, but the point I'm getting at is DForce DForce and many of us may not buy games based on anything occurring in that space

After the 10000th rage video by a youtuber, why would we magically start to care about their views on games we've been playing for generations? If they don't like Naughty Dog or CDPR or Rockstar etc, nothing is wrong with that, but acting as if their view should be seen as something serious or objective is a bit wild.

Thats like asking you to believe that Hogwarts reviewer that gave it a zero lol

There is a limit to how much someone can force that to the point of the bias being so extreme, that a lot of us simply can no longer take their word for it.
 
Last edited:

Nickolaidas

Member
No one is saying games like BG3 succeeded because of its wokeness, we're pointing out that wokeness has little impact on overall sales.
The problem is that we have very little way of verifying whether wokeness does or doesn't impede a particular game's sales because we cannot go back in time and launch BG3 without pronouns, without heavy LGBTQ representation, without any kind of woke content and see the impact in its sales.

I mean, I GUESS we could compare the sales between AC Shadows and the last three AC games, once Shadows is out for a year? If the last three AC games sold like, 9, 8 and 9 million copies each, and Shadows sells like, 2 million, one could make the argument that most of the blame goes into the Yasuke debacle, which was clearly created for woke points. It's not like people suddenly got bored of AC, when it has a steady (more or less) fanbase ...

This is of course, estimation until the game is out.
 

Cakeboxer

Member
? huh? yea...I don't know about that one bud.
That was a question, i'm not an expert in console game sales, but i think i've read here and there they sold less and some of the games were even on PS4 + PS5 and therefore had a bigger user base. But not gonna fight on this one, you guys know the numbers better than me.
 

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
Where did i say majority? Bundles in general have not much impact. But if the hardware is sold out all the time and when it's available and you have to buy an additional game it certainly has an impact on the sales. Like i said, not the majority, but 100% a couple of millions.

You said didn't HFW and GOW:R have an advantage because they were bundled and I said they didn't have much an impact on sales.

You also have to realize HZD and GOW 2018 were also bundled, so there was really no advantage.
 

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
? huh? yea...I don't know about that one bud.

God Of War 2018 moved 23 million units as of 2022, so it took 5 years to move that

God Of War Ragnarok moved 15 mullion units in 1 year....

Lets make this make sense lol That is like saying GTA6 sold less then GTA5 and its like 5 days into the game's launch lol I mean, use some context here next time. I don't now of any IP that is out of the game matching LIFE TIME SALES of something past 20 million units, not even Call Of Duty is doing something so absurd to be making this weird claim


True, but the point I'm getting at is DForce DForce and many of us may not buy games based on anything occurring in that space

After the 10000th rage video by a youtuber, why would be magically start to care about their views on games we've been playing for generations? If the don't like Naughty Dog or CDPR or Rockstar etc, nothing is wrong with that, but acting as if their view should be seen as something serious or objective is a bit wild.

Thats like asking you to believe that Hogwarts reviewer that gave it a zero lol

There is a limit to how much someone can force that to the point of the bias being so extreme, that a lot of us simply can no longer take their word for it.
If people brush off negativity from streamers who might have 100,000 or 1M views as insignificant in the grand scheme of things, then why do people get mad defending a game if the post got viewed maybe 1,000 times on the forum?

It’s all in good fun. Some games people like, some don’t.

As I said in my last post (maybe you missed it as I edited the post to add it at the end), why not just convince gamers the trailer is good. It’s 4 min long. Gamers got a lot of material to use to change minds.
 
Last edited:

Cakeboxer

Member
You also have to realize HZD and GOW 2018 were also bundled, so there was really no advantage.
You still don't get the point.

PS4 available = bundles have no impact
PS5 sold out all of 2022 = bundles had an impact

You wanted a PS5 in 2022? Sure, but in most cases you also had to buy FBW or GOWR, non bundled PS5s in 2022 were super rare.
When Spider-Man 2 was released end of 2023 the PS5 was fully available, so Spider-Man 2 bundles had no impact. Spider-Man 2 also didn't have the advantage of the PS4 user base like FBW and GOWR.
 
Last edited:

Nickolaidas

Member
Barbie and Wicked are two movies that are considered woke. If you're giving reasons why they were successful despite being woke, then you're only proving my point most people don't care.
A feminist movie about a feminist icon which mocks/attacks the patriarchy wasn't going to meet resistance from its target audience - girls. Wokeness - in general - tends to annoy straight men, because it mainly attacks them and empowers the others. So straight men have no problems with Barbie or Wicked movies because they were never the target audience to begin with.

In general, female fans of male IPs are the majority of females who will oppose wokeness.
 

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
The problem is that we have very little way of verifying whether wokeness does or doesn't impede a particular game's sales because we cannot go back in time and launch BG3 without pronouns, without heavy LGBTQ representation, without any kind of woke content and see the impact in its sales.

I mean, I GUESS we could compare the sales between AC Shadows and the last three AC games, once Shadows is out for a year? If the last three AC games sold like, 9, 8 and 9 million copies each, and Shadows sells like, 2 million, one could make the argument that most of the blame goes into the Yasuke debacle, which was clearly created for woke points. It's not like people suddenly got bored of AC, when it has a steady (more or less) fanbase ...

This is of course, estimation until the game is out.

We already have enough examples.

We're seeing successful titles that people considered woke. If these games are succeeding then there are different reasons why these other games failed. Baldur's Gate 3 far exceeded Baldur's Gate 2 sales and that means it found a completely new audience of gamers.


If you want more data then fine, but it's not only AC Shadows you have to look out for.

Assassins Creed Shadows
Ghost of Yotei
Intergalactic The Heretic
 

llien

Banned
The Anti-woke content creators blasted it, but it turned out to be one of the biggest movies of the year.
Wicked is a movie I have barely heard of. It is no huge success by any metric, at 540 million worldwide and 175-ish million budget.
(curiously, 70% of the box office income is US domestic)

I got your point that "some conservatives blasted it, but it did not flop".
But what does it really prove, besides "there still are some DEI movies, that do not flop".

Is DEI injection a negative or positive factor?

I don't know why Furiosa failed. It was also blasted as "woke" but the trailers had a more positive reaction.
It is an excellent movie with nothing woke in it that I can recall.
Except the gender swap.

Protagonist being a woman made no difference to my wife, who didn't want to watch it.
But obviously it has pissed off quite a number of Mad Max fans.

Can we agree on this being an example of "gender swaps hurt"?

Is there an example of a successful post 2000 gender swap?
 
Last edited:

kindaGoth

Member
Real question. Why does it matter? You're that annoyed that it's a bald bad ass chick? I honestly don't understand the issue. These are video games. I can name so many ganes that don't even give real representation options for so many people and people either skip it or just play it.

I need to also remember the internet is not real life and definitely isn't a voice for the majority. It's a trailer with no gameplay and we already have this much discourse?
Regarding the bald chick aspect: No one actually cares if the character is bald.

They just know it’s a sign of the game’s politics, which can affect the game, narrative, and hiring process that determines the development team and whether they were hired for talent or diversity points.
 

PeteBull

Member
Barbie and Wicked are two movies that are considered woke. If you're giving reasons why they were successful despite being woke, then you're only proving my point most people don't care.
Barbie was targetted and marketted to girls/women, ofc it sold well, thats our point, if u make game for the target audience, said target audience will love it/buy it.
Woke games target arent teenage boys/adult males, coz we for the most part are disgusted by that whole ideology.
What we saying- make games that target us- players just like u did before and that made u/games succesful, dont target 2% minority of weirdos coz of diversity/inclusion and if u do expect ur game gonna receive nasty backlash and most likely bomb.
That is why tons of woke games hide all the wokeness, like tlou2 and spiderman2, even horizon zd/fw did hide it, but guess what, it has long lasting effects for future games in the franchise coz gamers do remember :)

Lets check how much wokeness was in TLOU2 reveal trailer, back from 2016 playstation experience:


Guess what, 0, u had Joel, looking good and strong, a mentor, and grown up a bit but still very young Ellie playing guitar wanting revenge+ tons of massacred in all kinds of ways bodies.

No preggo woman going to fight, no bulky abby on steroids dosages so high she lost all womenly curves, yet she didnt experience any side effects of becoming a man in terms of hormones- still feminine voice, no increased facial/bodyhair, and no enlarged clitoris...

And surprise surprise, players loved the trailer and were hyped for the game: 10m views, 329k likes/5k dislikes ;)
 
Last edited:

EDMIX

Banned
As I said in my last post (maybe you missed it as I edited the post to add it at the end), why not just convince gamers the trailer is good. It’s 4 min long. Gamers got a lot of material to use to change minds.

I was able to read it, no worries.

I'm not going to convince anyone the trailer is good anymore then someone can convince me its bad lol

It is what it is. I feel the trailer should just be what anyone makes of it, it should never be this thing were anyone has to convince someone.

I accept that someone can dislike it, thats ok, but I merely expect that same respect back if we happen to like it.

Can we agree on this being an example of "gender swaps hurt"?
maybe, maybe not lol Maybe to a degree, but I think people put way too much focus on this stuff in trying to say if something flopped or not.

Films can flop even with none of that stuff in it.

Putting a man in Mad Max doesn't mean all the films will be slam dunks anymore then putting a female as lead in all Tyler Perry movies means they will all be slam dunks (I wish I had a better example, but im tired lol)
 
Last edited:

Nickolaidas

Member
We're seeing successful titles that people considered woke.
But HOW woke were they? Those successful games?

Besides having pronouns in the character select screen, did they raceswap 1/3rd of the cast? Did they completely emasculate the male characters? Were the female characters in those games insufferable stoic flat chested girl bosses while the men were useless cucks or toxic assholes? Were the women ugly? Did they stress the fact that whites should denounce their privilege and let women take charge? Were there sermons about non-binary characters?

Or did they simply have a woman as the main character?

Baldur's Gate 3 far exceeded Baldur's Gate 2 sales and that means it found a completely new audience of gamers.
No, it just means that gamers in general are a lot more than they were 25 years ago.
 
Last edited:

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
A feminist movie about a feminist icon which mocks/attacks the patriarchy wasn't going to meet resistance from its target audience - girls. Wokeness - in general - tends to annoy straight men, because it mainly attacks them and empowers the others. So straight men have no problems with Barbie or Wicked movies because they were never the target audience to begin with.

In general, female fans of male IPs are the majority of females who will oppose wokeness.

That's not the point I was making.

The Wicked trailer showed an unfavorable ratio on YouTube compared to Furiosa. This means people will dislike the video even though they have no interest in the movie. This shows people will dislike something because they "consider" it woke.

This was just one example. I also pointed out TLOU Episode 3 where people refused to watch it because of the Frank and Bill relationship, but the viewership wasn't impacted.
 

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
Barbie was targetted and marketted to girls/women, ofc it sold well, thats our point, if u make game for the target audience, said target audience will love it/buy it.
Woke games target arent teenage boys/adult males, coz we for the most part are disgusted by that whole ideology.
What we saying- make games that target us- players just like u did before and that made u/games succesful, dont target 2% minority of weirdos coz of diversity/inclusion and if u do expect ur game gonna receive nasty backlash and most likely bomb.
That is why tons of woke games hide all the wokeness, like tlou2 and spiderman2, even horizon zd/fw did hide it, but guess what, it has long lasting effects for future games in the franchise coz gamers do remember :)

Lets check how much wokeness was in TLOU2 reveal trailer, back from 2016 playstation experience:


Guess what, 0, u had Joel, looking good and strong, a mentor, and grown up a bit but still very young Ellie playing guitar wanting revenge+ tons of massacred in all kinds of ways bodies.

No preggo woman going to fight, no bulky abby on steroids dosages so high she lost all womenly curves, yet she didnt experience any side effects of becoming a man in terms of hormones- still feminine voice, no increased facial/bodyhair, and no enlarged clitoris...

And surprise surprise, players loved the trailer and were hyped for the game: 10m views, 329k likes/5k dislikes ;)


Abby reveal
No complaints about her appearance all over the comment section.

The Last of Us 2 Trailer (4K) - Paris Games Week 2017
The Last Of Us Part II Trailer #2 | Paris Games Week 2017


12k/ 447
9.5k/3.7k

The Last of Us Part II – Release Date Reveal Trailer | PS4
461/15k
Ellie's new girlfriend Dina is revealed.

This means the actual problem was Joel's death, not the "woke" elements in the game.

These are not hidden. These are things people considered woke.

Most of the backlash from Spider-Man 2 was from Mary Jane and that wasn't hidden. People complained BEFORE the game was released.
 

Nickolaidas

Member
The Wicked trailer showed an unfavorable ratio on YouTube compared to Furiosa. This means people will dislike the video even though they have no interest in the movie. This shows people will dislike something because they "consider" it woke.
No, no - Wicked is not just "considered" woke, it IS woke. But it doesn't affect sales because the target demographic (in its majority) doesn't care about, or endorses, wokeness.

In order to make a good case, you must present me a fully woke movie (or any piece of media for that matter) whose fanbase is predominately male, where that piece of media fully attacks masculinity, fully elevates women in girlboss roles, lectures you on pronouns, race, white privilege and conservative values, etc. AND that utterly kills it in the box office or sales.

Basically, show me an Acolyte which succeeded and sold millions.

Show me such an example, and we can talk.
 

Bernardougf

Member
LoL at trying to use a Barbie movie as a victory against "the chuds" ... movie
theaters around the world were packed by mostly two kind of people ... females....and males having to endure feminist porn for two hours on a date so they could try to fuck some of those females.

Thank god I have a girlfriend so she just went with my daughter and I didnt had to endure this shit.

Whats next on the "we beat the chuds" list ? Sex and the City ?..fuck off

Edit:
In fact now that I remember My girlfriend loved Sex and the City the Original show and the movies ... it had some woke elements but nothing to egregious or out of ordinary .. mainly a couple of gay dudes and feminist elements which for a show about fashion and woman should be expected...now they released a new show recently with the WOKE turned to eleven, everybody was freacking gay and trans ... my girl hated couldn't finish. Said it was too much... Dont know about the overall success of the show but I know it didn't last long.
 
Last edited:

PeteBull

Member
Abby reveal
No complaints about her appearance all over the comment section.

The Last of Us 2 Trailer (4K) - Paris Games Week 2017
The Last Of Us Part II Trailer #2 | Paris Games Week 2017


12k/ 447
9.5k/3.7k

The Last of Us Part II – Release Date Reveal Trailer | PS4
461/15k
Ellie's new girlfriend Dina is revealed.

This means the actual problem was Joel's death, not the "woke" elements in the game.

These are not hidden. These are things people considered woke.

Most of the backlash from Spider-Man 2 was from Mary Jane and that wasn't hidden. People complained BEFORE the game was released.
When we realised what game tlou2 gonna be- betrayal of loyal fanbase, then ofc ppl started to hate, and justified so.
Now with intergalactic trailer since we know what kind of meal druckmann is cooking and we know it right from the very start, especially with this kind of protagonist backlash is there imediatelly xD
Thankfully now in 2024 ppl adjust to what devs presenting, aka many of us stopped going in blind/pre-ordering just coz we liked previous games of the dev studio, made decade or longer ago ;)
 
Last edited:

DForce

NaughtyDog Defense Force
Wicked is a movie I have barely heard of. It is no huge success by any metric, at 540 million worldwide and 175-ish million budget.
(curiously, 70% of the box office income is US domestic)

I got your point that "some conservatives blasted it, but it did not flop".
But what does it really prove, besides "there still are some DEI movies, that do not flop".

Is DEI injection a negative or positive factor?

People are frustrated so I cannot say it doesn't discourage people from buying the game.

The point I'm making is HOW MUCH it impacts the overall sales of a video game or a movie.

It is an excellent movie with nothing woke in it that I can recall.
Except the gender swap.

Protagonist being a woman made no difference to my wife, who didn't want to watch it.
But obviously it has pissed off quite a number of Mad Max fans.

Can we agree on this being an example of "gender swaps hurt"?

Is there an example of a successful post 2000 gender swap?

I don't believe it's that simple.

Black Panther: Wakanda Forever succeeded, but Furiosa failed. I don't consider this a "gender swap" because they're completely different characters. Black Panther succeeded because it's a Marvel movie and Shuri is an established character in the franchise. There could be also something to do with the actress being cast in her role. I believe it would've done better if actress was known for her action roles in films.
 
Top Bottom