• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The 12 days of Gafmas |OT| The year in thread popularity!

cormack12

Gold Member
List view from least to most popular:
  • FFVII: Rebirth OT
  • Dragon's Dogma II OT
  • Hellblade 2 Review Thread
  • Concord being taken offline
  • The steam curator, Kabrutus, starting the DEIDetected website
  • The PS5 Pre-order go live thread
  • The PS5 Pro list of enhanced games
  • The Game Awards OT
  • Phil Spencer Announcement Thread of Xbox exclusives starting to come to other platforms
  • The Helldivers II OT
  • The reveal of Intergalacticf
  • The PS5 Pro leaks being real and release date of 2024!!!






I reached out to the mods to do a little 12 days of gafmas countdown based on the most popular threads of 2024. Thought it would be interesting to reflect and see how the year unfolded. I'll update it each day. It is a snapshot of like an hour ago so a couple may move slightly, but in the meantime:

DRjvhzE.jpeg




On the first day of Gafmas, M mortal gave to us.......the FFVII: Rebirth OT and what a follow up it was as well to Remake. Highly acclaimed and with the PC announcement also just made, it looks like there will life in this thread into 2025

5nsdzU.jpg
giphy.gif


On the second day of Gafmas, R6Rider R6Rider gave to us, the Dragon's Dogma 2 OT and what a beautiful well crafted thread it was too. A game I've still got to get round to playing:

WRE9zw.jpg
pleased-to-riddle-with-you-maam-v0-14bqlxtk3zbc1.gif


On the third day of gafmas, Draugoth Draugoth could not have possibly known the explosion that would arise from the Hellblade II Review Thread. A divisive game where the steam charts were monitored, game length was discussed and the quantity of gameplay.

IsGfbg.jpg
9fc882e3d8fabafaf5a3694340261d011f02d289.gif


Rocking up on the fourth day of Gafmas is concord being taken offline on 6th September, also started by our resident Draugoth Draugoth - who could have thought at the timeit would lead to such a long thread. We all thought it needed to be done but didn't know how big Sony's balls were and they moved swiftly.

Wwz8lj.jpg
JDFGKve.gif


On the fifth dasy of Gafmas, Kabrutus started his movement that would resonate across trhe gaming landscape and the thread was started by GrayChild GrayChild - it's still a hot topic today and spawned many discussions on gaf the last year: https://www.neogaf.com/threads/stea...-if-sweet-baby-is-involved-in-a-game.1667887/

3z5IiD.jpg
4f6h2ejw43qd1.gif


On the sixth day of gafmas, Lunatic_Gamer Lunatic_Gamer started the PS5 Pre-orders go live thread. The drama of the queues, the lack of 30th anniversary edition availability etc. made this a fingernail biting time for gaffers but we all got one in the end I think it's safe to say!

On the seventh day of Gafmas, HeisenbergFX4 HeisenbergFX4 started to compile the popular 'List of PS5 Pro Enhanced games'. Each game listed and catalogued and discussions about various patches and their impact.

On the eighth day of Gafmas, Draugoth Draugoth gave to us TGA OT which surprisingly delivered this year. Big reveals with Naughty Dog and CDPR both revealing their next major project sneak looks. A new Okami in production. Ueda's new project came in clutch, Fares' new co-op game looks like it will deliver another best in class for the genre and Elden Ring proved it's still not done yet!
XroD6q.jpg
giphy.webp


spons spons startesd the innocuous looking Phil Spencer announcemennt thread in February which exploded as Xbox announced a few changes in strategy as they went forward. Leaks, speculation, tears and blinking eyes of disbelief were all evident as we got confirmation of the first four games that would make their way from xbox exclusivity. These were Grounded, Hi-Fi Rush, Pentiment and Sea of Thieves.

I7f5JY.jpg


Coming in at number 10, was the Helldoivers II OT, made by yours truly cormack12 cormack12 - who would have thought this PvE co-op shooter would have had the legs it did? Genius greenlighting by SIE when we've seen so many similar attempts fail (Second Extinction, Back 4 Blood, Earthfall, Payday 3 etc)

oAl6JfR.gif
giphy.gif


Roaring into the eleventh day of gafmas and proving a contentious topic that took only a week or so to enter the largest threads territory was the reveal of Naughty Dog's Intergalactic title from our very own Draugoth Draugoth

mvZMoH.jpg
intergalactic-naughty-dog.gif


And on the twelfth day of gafmas, the mpost popular thread of all the year goes to jm89 jm89 who started the post about the PS5 Pro leaked specs being real and being released in 2024. With a whopping 125 pages which went from excitement and imagining marvellous new hardware to quizzical on a controversial price.
source.gif


Happy Gafmas everyone!!
 
Last edited:

spons

Gold Member
Very cool thread, OP. Assuming "most popular" is defined by comment count?
If that's the case then threads on the "future of Xbox" bullshit in February this year must've made the list as well.
That really was an enormous troll-fest and I enjoyed every second of it.
 
Last edited:

ReBurn

Gold Member
I reached out to the mods to do a little 12 days of gafmas countdown based on the most popular threads of 2024. Thought it would be interesting to reflect and see how the year unfolded. I'll update it each day. It is a snapshot of like an hour ago so a couple may move slightly, but in the meantime:

QcohiNp.jpeg




On the first day of Gafmas, M mortal gave to us.......the FFVII: Rebirth OT and what a follow up it was as well to Remake. Highly acclaimed and with the PC announcement also just made, it looks like there will life in this thread into 2025

5nsdzU.jpg
giphy.gif
The order of those squares is an OCD nightmare
 

cormack12

Gold Member
On the second day of Gafmas, R6Rider R6Rider gave to us, the Dragon's Dogma 2 OT and what a beautiful well crafted thread it was too. A game I've still got to get round to playing:
 
Concord finally won something
It won a place in gaming history as the biggest flop made by a AAA studio and publisher. Sony believed the Concord dream to the point of acquiring the studio behind it, producing out-of-the-game media for it, wasting 8 years in development and U$400 million in expenses to see the game going offline in less than 2 weeks after release. They fumbled so hard that made a few live service projects from different studios to end their fundings in fear of flopping the same.

Concord became synonym of a cautionary tale on what not to do when making a live-service game. Not even Astro Bot launching the same day as Concord shutdown, and after winning the game of the year award, will clean the stain on Sony's records.
 

cormack12

Gold Member
On the eighth day of Gafmas, Draugoth Draugoth gave to us TGA OT which surprisingly delivered this year. Big reveals with Naughty Dog and CDPR both revealing their next major project sneak looks. A new Okami in production. Ueda's new project came in clutch, Fares' new co-op game looks like it will deliver another best in class for the genre and Elden Ring proved it's still not done yet!
XroD6q.jpg
giphy.webp
 

cormack12

Gold Member
spons spons startesd the innocuous looking Phil Spencer announcemennt thread in February which exploded as Xbox announced a few changes in strategy as they went forward. Leaks, speculation, tears and blinking eyes of disbelief were all evident as we got confirmation of the first four games that would make their way from xbox exclusivity. These were Grounded, Hi-Fi Rush, Pentiment and Sea of Thieves.

I7f5JY.jpg
 

cormack12

Gold Member
List view from least to most popular:
  • FFVII: Rebirth OT
  • Dragon's Dogma II OT
  • Hellblade 2 Review Thread
  • Concord being taken offline
  • The steam curator, Kabrutus, starting the DEIDetected website
  • The PS5 Pre-order go live thread
  • The PS5 Pro list of enhanced games
  • The Game Awards OT
  • Phil Spencer Announcement Thread of Xbox exclusives starting to come to other platforms
  • The Helldivers II OT
  • The reveal of Intergalacticf
  • The PS5 Pro leaks being real and release date of 2024!!!

Got to say there is a good mix in there, I did worry at first that every thread would be a concord or anti woke thread but there's quite a diverse set of topics in there. PS5 was obviously a big hitter with lots of interest maintained from speculation to purchase to game improvemnents. The concord debacle was represented. A handful of OTs. One cross platform, two for PlayStation with Helldivers right up there. The movement started by Kabrutus for DEID. The bombshell that Xbox will be offering their exclusives to other platforms, and the topic that is still lighting up GAF, Bald girl!!!!

images
 

LectureMaster

Gold Member
List view from least to most popular:
  • FFVII: Rebirth OT
  • Dragon's Dogma II OT
  • Hellblade 2 Review Thread
  • Concord being taken offline
  • The steam curator, Kabrutus, starting the DEIDetected website
  • The PS5 Pre-order go live thread
  • The PS5 Pro list of enhanced games
  • The Game Awards OT
  • Phil Spencer Announcement Thread of Xbox exclusives starting to come to other platforms
  • The Helldivers II OT
  • The reveal of Intergalacticf
  • The PS5 Pro leaks being real and release date of 2024!!!






I reached out to the mods to do a little 12 days of gafmas countdown based on the most popular threads of 2024. Thought it would be interesting to reflect and see how the year unfolded. I'll update it each day. It is a snapshot of like an hour ago so a couple may move slightly, but in the meantime:

DRjvhzE.jpeg




On the first day of Gafmas, M mortal gave to us.......the FFVII: Rebirth OT and what a follow up it was as well to Remake. Highly acclaimed and with the PC announcement also just made, it looks like there will life in this thread into 2025

5nsdzU.jpg
giphy.gif


On the second day of Gafmas, R6Rider R6Rider gave to us, the Dragon's Dogma 2 OT and what a beautiful well crafted thread it was too. A game I've still got to get round to playing:

WRE9zw.jpg
pleased-to-riddle-with-you-maam-v0-14bqlxtk3zbc1.gif


On the third day of gafmas, Draugoth Draugoth could not have possibly known the explosion that would arise from the Hellblade II Review Thread. A divisive game where the steam charts were monitored, game length was discussed and the quantity of gameplay.

IsGfbg.jpg
9fc882e3d8fabafaf5a3694340261d011f02d289.gif


Rocking up on the fourth day of Gafmas is concord being taken offline on 6th September, also started by our resident Draugoth Draugoth - who could have thought at the timeit would lead to such a long thread. We all thought it needed to be done but didn't know how big Sony's balls were and they moved swiftly.

Wwz8lj.jpg
JDFGKve.gif


On the fifth dasy of Gafmas, Kabrutus started his movement that would resonate across trhe gaming landscape and the thread was started by GrayChild GrayChild - it's still a hot topic today and spawned many discussions on gaf the last year: https://www.neogaf.com/threads/stea...-if-sweet-baby-is-involved-in-a-game.1667887/

3z5IiD.jpg
4f6h2ejw43qd1.gif


On the sixth day of gafmas, Lunatic_Gamer Lunatic_Gamer started the PS5 Pre-orders go live thread. The drama of the queues, the lack of 30th anniversary edition availability etc. made this a fingernail biting time for gaffers but we all got one in the end I think it's safe to say!

On the seventh day of Gafmas, HeisenbergFX4 HeisenbergFX4 started to compile the popular 'List of PS5 Pro Enhanced games'. Each game listed and catalogued and discussions about various patches and their impact.

On the eighth day of Gafmas, Draugoth Draugoth gave to us TGA OT which surprisingly delivered this year. Big reveals with Naughty Dog and CDPR both revealing their next major project sneak looks. A new Okami in production. Ueda's new project came in clutch, Fares' new co-op game looks like it will deliver another best in class for the genre and Elden Ring proved it's still not done yet!
XroD6q.jpg
giphy.webp


spons spons startesd the innocuous looking Phil Spencer announcemennt thread in February which exploded as Xbox announced a few changes in strategy as they went forward. Leaks, speculation, tears and blinking eyes of disbelief were all evident as we got confirmation of the first four games that would make their way from xbox exclusivity. These were Grounded, Hi-Fi Rush, Pentiment and Sea of Thieves.

I7f5JY.jpg


Coming in at number 10, was the Helldoivers II OT, made by yours truly cormack12 cormack12 - who would have thought this PvE co-op shooter would have had the legs it did? Genius greenlighting by SIE when we've seen so many similar attempts fail (Second Extinction, Back 4 Blood, Earthfall, Payday 3 etc)

oAl6JfR.gif
giphy.gif


Roaring into the eleventh day of gafmas and proving a contentious topic that took only a week or so to enter the largest threads territory was the reveal of Naughty Dog's Intergalactic title from our very own Draugoth Draugoth

mvZMoH.jpg
intergalactic-naughty-dog.gif


And on the twelfth day of gafmas, the mpost popular thread of all the year goes to jm89 jm89 who started the post about the PS5 Pro leaked specs being real and being released in 2024. With a whopping 125 pages which went from excitement and imagining marvellous new hardware to quizzical on a controversial price.
source.gif


Happy Gafmas everyone!!
My man, this is such a cool idea to review the year on GAF. Huge kudos!
 
Top Bottom