SEVEN ESSENTIAL FANTASY READS: GOING TO SECOND BASE
Ive read a few best-selling fantasy seriesHarry Potter, The Lord of the Rings, His Dark Materials, Twilight, Narnia, A Wrinkle in Time, The Dark Is Risingbut I would never describe myself as an aficionado. First because all these books are on about a fourth-grade reading level, and second because I read them for their best-sellerness, not their fantasy-ness (to stay in the loop, I tell myself). I doubted whether the genre had more to offer adultsliterary adults, adults who enjoy reading bonafide novels. If you happen to be a fantasy aficionado, you are no doubt shaking your head at the ignorance of that statement, as my friend Hugh Lippincott did recently. Hugh is a graduate student in physics at Yale, (hopefully) in the final year of a Ph.D. He spends his days searching for dark matterIm not sure what happens when he finds someand his nights, apparently, reading fantasy books. He is also the author of the blog Physics for Mom, a guide to what he does written for the scientifically impaired.
I asked Hugh what he would recommend for someone like mea beginning fantasy reader ready to graduate to more serious (but not too serious) fare. Here are his picks, complete with explanations of their greatness. He sent them to me with the reassurance that there is no shame in being a real fantasy reader. Thanks, Hugh.
The Dragonbone Chair, the first book in the Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn series, by Tad Williams.
This is the stereotypical epic fantasy that begins with a young, inexperienced, immature youth toiling away as a kitchen boy in a castle, daydreaming his life away. Outside of his limited range of experience, events are taking place that will turn his entire world upside down, and somehow this young boy becomes the key to preventing the end of life as he knows it. That pretty much sums up half the books one finds in the fantasy section of the bookstore. This one has everything youd expect from epic fantasymagical swords, dragons, an elvish race, a dwarvish race, love of a princess, internal mythology, and strong drink spread over three books and several thousand pages. And its easily the best in the genreif you want to read a classic epic fantasy series that is not the Lord of the Rings, start here. Williams has several other books (the Otherland series, The War of the Flowers) that are also worth reading.
Anything by Guy Gavriel Kay, but particularly Tigana, The Lions of Al-Rassan, Sailing to Sarantium, and The Fionavar Tapestry (a trilogy that begins with The Summer Tree).
For those who dont want to jump into a long series right away, Kay has written a number of standalone novels that take place in alternate worlds with a similar geography and history to our own, and they are all excellent. His strengths are strong characters and fantastic set piecesextended scenes based in one geographical location where various plot lines are resolved and new ones are generated to provide the impetus for the next section of the book. I love these scenes, which are always clever and multi-layered. Kay also has a rather flowery writing style, which in most cases adds to the romance of the novel, although in some books (not listed here) he can get a bit carried away. Two of the books in the Fionavar Tapestry were the last books that I can remember making me cry.
Wizards First Rule, by Terry Goodkind.
A fabulous single-volume epic fantasy. Theres the usual plot of a young, unlikely hero becoming involved with wizards and attractive, powerful women before discovering that hes descended from a line of heroes (naturally), but there are some twists that make this one better than most, including a darker-than-usual section where things go badly for the protagonist. Sadly, Goodkind did so well on this completely self-contained fantasy that he wrote ten sequels, each one worse than the one before and more prone to excruciatingly long Ayn Randian monologues from the main characters (needless to say, I read them all). Read this book, and then pretend the others dont exist.
Assassins Apprentice, by Robin Hobb.
The first book in another trilogy. Im sure there have been riffs on this before, but for some reason eighty per cent of fantasy comes in trilogy form. I suppose Tolkein decreed that three books was just the right amount for a fantasy series, and everyone has been following suit. Hobb puts a slight twist on the usual starting point, as her protagonist is a royal bastard (and therefore not the unknown kitchen boy who secretly is the son of a king) who must find his place in court as an assassin. Hobb can be pretty hard on her characters, but its definitely worth the effort.
The Scions of Shannara, by Terry Brooks.
Terry Brooks is one of the old names in fantasy, having written one of the templates, The Sword of Shannara, back in 1977, one of the first (rather explicit) copies of Tolkien, complete with Sauron in the form of the Warlock Lord and Ringwraiths as Skull Bearers. Brooks improved with experience, and wrote The Scions of Shannara, the first of a much better four-book series (starring the descendants of the previous books), in 1990. When I was nine years old, I wrote a fantasy story for class with a mongoose and a walking chainsaw as the heroes (coincidentally matched up against a snake and an evil treeevil tree?as the villains). In that story (which eventually reached some thirty unfinished pages), I directly lifted names and places from the Shannara books, thereby imitating an imitation of Tolkein.
The Name of the Wind, by Patrick Rothfuss.
This is the only recent book on this list, it came out last year (and is the first of an as-yet-unfinished series). This book made a big splash on the fantasy scene, and we all await the sequels with great anticipation. The main character, Kvothe, is already an infamous figure in semi-retirement at the beginning of the novel (known as the King-killer), and the book is centered on his telling the story of how he became who he is. It is well-executed and paced, and it has a section that takes place at a schoolI always love a school setting.
Gardens of the Moon, by Steven Erikson.
This book really isnt for beginners, but if one reads the others and decides, like so many have before, that fantasy is where its at, then Erikson will be the reward. Gardens of the Moon is the first of ten books (the last two as yet unpublished) in the Malazan Book of the Fallen series. Its impossible to describe this series, except to say that Erikson manages to throw together hundreds of characters, gods, myths, the history of millennia, giant battles, betrayals, etc. etc. into one series and make it work. No one is safe in these books, and yet the reader never feels betrayed when a favorite character drops out of the story (unlike in some other series Ive read). Simply fantastic.
Honorable mention: Glen Cook, J. V. Jones, Lois McMaster Bujold, R. Scott Bakker, George R. R. Martin.