• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Jet collides with helicopter near D.C.

AJUMP23

Parody of actual AJUMP23
The black hawk flew into an aircraft. Something doesn’t sit right.

Rumor helicopter didn’t have on its transponder. Which would seem odd for DC.
 

HoodWinked

Member
crazy but this is the first fatal US domestic passenger fatal crash in 16 years.



weird thing is the origin of the helicopter flight showing it took off from some rich suburbs but maybe the data is only partial.

 

LordCBH

Member
How the fuck does this happen? What was ATC doing? What was that fucking helicopter doing? The insane amount of sensors onboard these modern crafts and the helicopter couldn’t get out of the way?
 

IFireflyl

Gold Member
Holy shit. That’s right by my office. Guess I’ll work from home tomorrow.

GIF by ABC Network
 

AJUMP23

Parody of actual AJUMP23
What pilot takes the route in front of a busy airport.

I think you would avoid active airspace. I know the pentagon is not far from the airport.
 

Digital-Aftertaste

Gold Member
For people wondering Air Traffic Control is one of the most mentally demanding jobs due to high amount of air traffic and low amount of staff members in any given airport. There are people that quit due to stress and high responsibility because this very accident that occurred is what they try to avoid from happening all the time.
 
Last edited:

jason10mm

Gold Member
For people wondering Air Traffic Control is one of the most mentally demanding jobs due to high amount of air traffic and low amount of staff members in any given airport. There are people that quit due to stress and high responsibility because this very accident that occurred is what they try to avoid from happening all the time.
This is an area where AI can really help.
 

StreetsofBeige

Gold Member
Dumb question since I know nothing about planes and helicopters.

But why would the heli pilot be flying on (I think human eye visuals) instead of whatever radar stuff they got which youd think would show multiple planes around him?
 
A lot of people are putting on their tinfoil hats but I think this sounds plausible.



TLDR: ATC asks helicopter if they have visual on the plane. Helicopter pilot confirms but they see the plane departing, not the plane approaching.

So he just didn’t see the plane that he crashed into? Don’t they have a ton of lights?
 

Gp1

Member
The Warzone and ATClive.net got the ATC audio from the time of the crash

We now have chilling air traffic control audio from the time of the collision, you can listen to it below (credit ATCLive.net). Also note, the “Blackjack” callsign is a USCG MH-65, which fly out of Reagan International and sit alert to respond to slower-flying aircraft that breach the restricted airspace around the capital. The other military callsign, “Mussel,” is likely a USAF UH-1N from the 1st Helicopter Squadron out of nearby Andrews AFB.




 

Shifty1897

Member
For people wondering Air Traffic Control is one of the most mentally demanding jobs due to high amount of air traffic and low amount of staff members in any given airport. There are people that quit due to stress and high responsibility because this very accident that occurred is what they try to avoid from happening all the time.
I know now it sounds like this wasn't on Air Traffic Control at all, but just to reiterate how difficult of a job it is, my college roommate who had straight A's, was promoted to management and senior management roles at huge companies and is the most financially successful friend I have, studied for and failed the air traffic controller test. It's apparently brutal.
 

Hookshot

Member
Rip, seems a tragic mistake if it is human error from the helicopter pilot to not notice both planes and fly into the path of one of them.
 
Sounds like a massive fuckup by the helo crew. Apparently, they're supposed to be at 200ft and the collision was more like 350ft. It sounds like they fly without the transponder in the mode that feeds ATC with telemetry? Possible that prevented ATC giving a better callout to the helo on where the CRJ they needed a visual was relative to them.
I know now it sounds like this wasn't on Air Traffic Control at all, but just to reiterate how difficult of a job it is, my college roommate who had straight A's, was promoted to management and senior management roles at huge companies and is the most financially successful friend I have, studied for and failed the air traffic controller test. It's apparently brutal.
You don't need college smarts for ATC. You need elite gamer skills.
 

kruis

Exposing the sinister cartel of retailers who allow companies to pay for advertising space.



MOSCOW, Jan 30 (Reuters) - Russian ice skating coaches and former world champions Yevgenia Shishkova and Vadim Naumov were on board the American Airlines plane that crashed into the Potomac River in Washington on Wednesday night, Russian state media reported.
Shishkova and Naumov, who were married to each other, won the world championships in pairs figure skating in 1994 and had reportedly lived in the United States since at least 1998, where they trained young ice skaters.

Their son Maxim, who competed for the United States in singles, was also feared to have been on board the plane, Russia's TASS and RIA news agencies reported. He had been competing at the U.S. figure skating championships in Wichita, Kansas from Jan. 20-26, according to the event's website.
The couple were reported to have been returning from the competition and traveling with a group of young skaters. Russia's Mash news outlet published a list of 13 skaters, many of them the children of Russian emigres to the United States, who it said were believed to have been on the plane.

Inna Volyanskaya, a former skater who competed for the Soviet Union, was also reported to have been on board, TASS said. She was a coach at the Washington figure skating club, according to its website.

=====

Awful to think of what happened to these young promising kids. :messenger_pensive:
 

BlackTron

Member
Of course a military helicopter crashed into a plane full of Russian nationals so their state media can call us incompetent or nefarious. Whataboutism fuel for when they shot down an airliner.

That Heli crew were really special and screwed up royally...
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
Hold on, you’re telling me that a military that for the last four years was more focused on transgender tanks had a helicopter crew that couldn’t look to the left AND right to spot a landing plane?
Don’t make everything about politics.

People who get to fly these black hawks have earned it.
 
I know now it sounds like this wasn't on Air Traffic Control at all, but just to reiterate how difficult of a job it is, my college roommate who had straight A's, was promoted to management and senior management roles at huge companies and is the most financially successful friend I have, studied for and failed the air traffic controller test. It's apparently brutal.

ATC is a notoriously difficult career, sounds like a prime candidate for AI integration. Even the best humans make mistakes/errors, having an AI backup or even running the show will probably be something we see in the future.
 
ATC is a notoriously difficult career, sounds like a prime candidate for AI integration. Even the best humans make mistakes/errors, having an AI backup or even running the show will probably be something we see in the future.
Yeah, with AI it can perform the jobs like that easier - plus if planes and helicopters can connect to each other they can in theory receive signals and automatically avoid collisions.
 
I don't get why people go straight to the damn blame game. We literally know nothing of anything right now except for the fact a military helicopter crashed with a passenger plane. How about we WAIT till we have all the facts before we start apportioning blame.
 
Top Bottom