-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Jet collides with helicopter near D.C.
- Thread starter kruis
- Start date
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Dr.Guru of Peru
played the long game
Rest in peace to all the souls on board.
Can't believe people are politicizing this. Jesus christ. Social media is a plague - every hair brain with an agenda trying to break some morsel of "news" so they can twist it to support the narrative they've been pushing. It completely poisons the discourse. Just wait for the fucking investigation.
Can't believe people are politicizing this. Jesus christ. Social media is a plague - every hair brain with an agenda trying to break some morsel of "news" so they can twist it to support the narrative they've been pushing. It completely poisons the discourse. Just wait for the fucking investigation.
Last edited:
Pegasus Actual
Member
And right here is the final piece of the puzzle, Vladimir Putin, angry with the state of his nation's figure skating program, ordered his secret asset codename: Orange Man to have a drone Blackhawk autonomously intercept and neutralize a flight of essentially defectors from the Russian Figure Skating Program and their progeny, thus getting vengeance but also crippling US prospects in future Winter Olympics.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
And right here is the final piece of the puzzle, Vladimir Putin, angry with the state of his nation's figure skating program, ordered his secret asset codename: Orange Man to have a drone Blackhawk autonomously intercept and neutralize a flight of essentially defectors from the Russian Figure Skating Program and their progeny, thus getting vengeance but also crippling US prospects in future Winter Olympics.
This is where your mind decided to go.
Dr.Guru of Peru
played the long game
"Just asking questions"?
Really?
Who the fuck is this guy "asking"?
Now we have 600 morons who think this plane was downed by some DARPA conspiracy shit because an autonomous helicopter was publicly tested in Connecticut a few weeks ago. Brilliant fucking idea broadcasting your cloak and dagger conspiracy to the entire world a few weeks before you carry out the murder of 60+ people.
Pegasus Actual
Member
You tell your boss, Orange Man (whoever the hell that is), that he won't get away with it.
This is where your mind decided to go.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
I'm not going down that road, it could also have been as simple as a training accident with the tech. If it were used, of course.
It was tested to the public last year, not a few weeks ago.
Last edited:
Paltheos
Member
GAF cannot help themselves. The number of dumpster-tier posts in this thread is pissing me off. I won't deny part of the reason is not because it's inappropriate but because I personally disagree with a lot of the takes, but this is why politics are supposedly banned on GAF to begin with (because people just get into angry shouting matches).
Some people I disagree with btw are being more level-headed, but unveiled political favoritism and hate speech are pretty fucked. Not really surprising either unfortunately but today I felt like saying something about it.
Some people I disagree with btw are being more level-headed, but unveiled political favoritism and hate speech are pretty fucked. Not really surprising either unfortunately but today I felt like saying something about it.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Who's doing this?
Susurrus
Member
I live here. While I can't speak specifically on this helicopter, it is very common for helicopters from many organizations to fly up and down the Potomac river, which is where this landing path goes. The helicopters provide security for the area, look at a Google Maps where this was and you'll see exactly why. This is nothing new, it has been this way since the beginning of air navigation. Now why an Army helicopter was doing a training mission at night? I'm not sure.
Wildebeest
Member
Probably space aliens did it and in no way the US military messing up.
Tams
Member
If you think any of that would have had an effect in a week, then you are truly stupid.
You are silly for bringing those issues up; just as Trump is silly for bringing up DEI (even as a response to reporters' questions).
EverydayBeast
ChatGPT 0.001
RIP.
Not smart on the helicopter to be there, you can fly anywhere and you choose next to a busy airport with planes flying in and out.
Not smart on the helicopter to be there, you can fly anywhere and you choose next to a busy airport with planes flying in and out.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
I'm hearing reports that when they're in that area (the helis), they're only supposed to be at 200 feet. Why was the helicopter climbing and turning into the landing path at 400 feet, is the million dollar question.
Last edited:
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Everything we know so far about DC plane crash victims
The names of the 60 passengers and four crew members on board began to emerge Thursday as authorities revealed there were likely no survivors of the fiery tragedy that was shaping up to be the dead…nypost.com
RIP
One of the school board members in our area died in this crash, RIP
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Air traffic controller was doing the job of two people during crash, FAA says
The air traffic controller working at the time of the deadly plane-helicopter crash in Washington was doing the work of two people, the Federal Aviation Administration said.
nypost.com
DrFigs
Member
Yeah as if air traffic controllers being short staffed and having the Aviation Safety Advisory Committee disbanded would have any immediate effects on aviation safety.
Last edited:
Dacvak
No one shall be brought before our LORD David Bowie without the true and secret knowledge of the Photoshop. For in that time, so shall He appear.
Oh shit we’re neighbors. (Ish… my fiancée’s office is also very close by)
Last edited:
Robot Carnival
Member
this most likely doesn't have anything to do with DEI or Trump, as much as I hate both. and from the ATC recording, it dooesn't sound like it's an ATC issue. probably just the person flying the Blackhawk misidentified the flight ATC told him/her to beware of and focused too much on the departing flight instead of the incoming landing flight.
Kacho
Gold Member
Dacvak
No one shall be brought before our LORD David Bowie without the true and secret knowledge of the Photoshop. For in that time, so shall He appear.
I live up in silver spring, but am often in the DC area
SlimySnake
Flashless at the Golden Globes
Typical government incompetence. They need to shut down airports if they dont meet minimum staffing requirements.Air traffic controller was doing the job of two people during crash, FAA says
The air traffic controller working at the time of the deadly plane-helicopter crash in Washington was doing the work of two people, the Federal Aviation Administration said.
WTF are rules even for if they are not enforced.
Last edited:
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
READ:
The airport’s air traffic control facilities have been understaffed for years, with only 19 fully certified controllers on deck as of September 2023, according to Congress’ Air Traffic Controller Workforce Plan report.
Donald mac Ronald
Member
Me. I hate these damn helicopters, deport them.
SlimySnake
Flashless at the Golden Globes
Yep. This is one of the toughest jobs to get. I highly doubt they were letting DEI people get hired there. The staffers, managers and admins around the ATCs? sure. But the actual Air Traffic Controllers? Nah. It's like the Navy Seals. You cant DEI your way into it. You have to earn it.
We have had several close calls over the years at other airports. there was one just a couple of weeks ago that was all over twitter. This was only a matter of time. lets hope they get the funding and personnel they need going forward.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Except for the Apaches.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Oh but they were (the FAA the last 4 years) and why there is a lawsuit.
SlimySnake
Flashless at the Golden Globes
This is our nation's capital people. An airport literally handling congressmen and foreign dignitaries. Understaffed despite warnings from FAA themselves.
i understand its difficult to train these guys and it can take several years, but there has to be a way around these staff shortages. You have army bases everywhere in that area flying black hawks. get some of the army guys to come in handle traffic there.
Kenneth Haight
Member
Horrendous. RIP
Kacho
Gold Member
They will magically find a way to resolve this issue immediately.
WhamBamThankYouMaam
Member
Tragic accident. American voters instantly start spinning conspiracy theories.
Tajaz2426
Psychology PhD from Wikipedia University
My assumption is they are going to audit where any money has gone. What training funds have been used on and if said training costs are what has hindered the hiring process to have more certified ATC’s, etc.
When we lose an aircraft, everything is frozen. The books that maintenance control use for sign offs by every member that touched the helicopter, pieces of gear, proper training, Avionics books, power line books, airframes, etc.
I think that is where they will start.
Guardian Monkey
Member
During his first term (2017–2021), President Donald Trump proposed significant changes to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and its operations. In 2017, his administration unveiled an infrastructure plan that included a $2.4 billion cut to federal transportation programs, aiming to eliminate subsidies for long-distance trains and commercial flights to rural communities. Additionally, Trump advocated for privatizing the FAA's air traffic control system, suggesting it be transformed into a private nonprofit corporation.
en.wikipedia.org
In 2019, the FAA announced $840 million in grants to improve airport facilities, and President Trump proposed $17.1 billion in funding for the FAA. This proposal passed the House Appropriations Committee with an additional $614 million, totaling $17.7 billion for the FAA. These funds were allocated to over 380 airports across 47 states for various improvement projects.
en.wikipedia.org
Furthermore, the Trump administration pursued deregulation efforts, including executive orders to reduce regulatory oversight and shift supervision to industry. The 2019 budget proposed an 18% cut to the Department of Transportation's budget, which could have impacted the FAA's resources and oversight capabilities.
en.wikipedia.org
These initiatives reflect the administration's broader goals of reducing government involvement in certain sectors and promoting privatization and deregulation within the aviation industry.
SlimySnake
Flashless at the Golden Globes
What the fuck is a biographical test. Fucking hell.
Tams
Member
Again, a week is not ling enough for that to have an effect. The understaffing goes back years, and if it were the other way around, no administration could increase staffing within a week.
Zathalus
Member
Terrible tragedy all around. Been a pretty bad streak for aircraft safety these past months.
Regarding the cause, the FAA has been underfunded for years. It’s quite amazing something hasn’t happened sooner. Disbanding the safety committee and freezing hiring probably didn’t cause this, as those actions happened a few days ago, but I fail to see how it could have any benefit in the long term.
Regarding the cause, the FAA has been underfunded for years. It’s quite amazing something hasn’t happened sooner. Disbanding the safety committee and freezing hiring probably didn’t cause this, as those actions happened a few days ago, but I fail to see how it could have any benefit in the long term.
IntentionalPun
Ask me about my wife's perfect butthole
Yeah it didn’t cause it but I’d hope people would go “why are we doing this?” In general, crash or no crash.
Root cause isn’t 100% figured out yet but it appears to be based on understaffing, as one person was handling helicopters and other aircraft when usually 1 person should be dedicated to helicopters.
But they arent increasing staffing. In fact, with hiring freezes and retirement demands its obvious that they are doing the opposite. This will most likely not have caused this disaster, but enacting these measures one week before this - makes them look real bad.
David Ricardo
Member
The helicopter was told to watch out and go behind the plane. But there were two planes in sight. Maybe they were looking at one of them and didn't know the other one was coming?
violence
Member
Which makes me think the copper had malfunctioning instruments or a distracted pilot. I wouldn't go near an airport.
Tajaz2426
Psychology PhD from Wikipedia University
If it was one controller doing that doing takeoff traffic and landing, then it could have just been a mistake that he didn’t say incoming or outgoing aircraft and just said aircraft seen the outgoing and never seen the incoming aircraft.
StreetsofBeige
Gold Member
Dont planes and helicopters have radar so you can see blips around you?
Or is that all TV and movies Hollywood fakery?
If the heli pilot saw one plane, but didnt see another, wouldnt there be radar in the heli showing multiple pings around him? I dont know. I dont know how big planes and military heli instrument panels are like.
Or is that all TV and movies Hollywood fakery?
If the heli pilot saw one plane, but didnt see another, wouldnt there be radar in the heli showing multiple pings around him? I dont know. I dont know how big planes and military heli instrument panels are like.
David Ricardo
Member
I also think not enough information was given to the chopper or there was a misunderstanding, maybe because there were not enough controllers
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
The controller also radioed that mere seconds before the collision. Not nearly enough time for any adjustment.
Where that heli was, however, they should not have been at the same height that planes landing and taking off would be. They should be maintaining 200ft, not 400-500ft in landing airspace, a plane there or not.
Gp1
Member
As a laymen, when you hear ATCs audio you feel that these guys are handling tons of instructions under immense pressure. And how they switch from normal workload to shit hits the fan mode in a mere second still is impressive.
A single ATC is giving tons of instructions,then someone yells in the back "did you see that?" and before anyone process the wtf happened the guy enters in a crisis mode, diverting other approaches and get other chopper in the area to assist.
They could be understaffed and the cause could be an ATC mistake, but still one hell of a job.
A single ATC is giving tons of instructions,then someone yells in the back "did you see that?" and before anyone process the wtf happened the guy enters in a crisis mode, diverting other approaches and get other chopper in the area to assist.
They could be understaffed and the cause could be an ATC mistake, but still one hell of a job.
Last edited: