I think it's reasonable but I'd just repeat as in my original post that it hasn't been tried under these circumstances or scale.
I'm looking around the world at the United States suppliers and seeing beautiful new state of the art cities. Those who supply us oil, manufactured goods. All of them tariff the United States and rely on them as a customer. Realizing that Detroit was incredible when the US supplied and didn't shift. Look at American cities now?
I want American prosperity back because as a border town Canadian growing up I love the United States. Deeply. And I understand that American prosperity ALWAYS has translated to Canadian prosperity in short order without exception.
Many in here talk about how Americans no longer want to work. Maybe that's a result of a problem and not the cause of one.
According to this alot of jobs in detroit relocated inside of the United states not all of them sure but still.
The short answer: **more jobs were lost to other parts of the U.S.** than to other countries — but **both played major roles** over different time periods.
Here's the breakdown:
---
### **1. Jobs Lost to Other Parts of the U.S.**
This was the *initial* and **larger chunk of job losses**, especially from the 1950s–1990s.
- **Southern States (Sun Belt):**
Automakers moved plants to states like **Tennessee, Kentucky, Alabama, and Texas**.
- Lower wages
- Non-union labor (right-to-work laws)
- Cheaper land, fewer regulations
- **Suburban Sprawl:**
Many companies also moved just **outside Detroit** to the suburbs where taxes were lower and land was more available.
- **Impact:**
This migration gutted Detroit's tax base and contributed to urban decay while the companies stayed profitable.
---
### **2. Jobs Lost to Other Countries**
This wave hit harder in the **1990s–2000s**, especially with **NAFTA (1994)** and globalization.
- **Key countries:**
- **Mexico:** Huge shift in auto manufacturing post-NAFTA.
- **China:** For electronics, parts, and general manufacturing.
- **Canada:** Some plants moved here due to favorable trade and labor costs.
- **Why the shift?**
- Lower wages
- Fewer environmental/labor regulations
- Tariff-free exports back to the U.S. under trade deals
---
### **So, which was bigger overall?**
- In **raw job numbers**, **domestic relocation (to other U.S. states)** likely caused **more job loss in Detroit**.
- But **offshoring** had a **longer-term impact** on wages, benefits, and the sustainability of manufacturing careers.