Hey guys, Happy New Year's!
Was wondering how I could do a Yakuza type DnD and what system I would use? Pathfinder? Cypher?
Happy New Year!
The Cypher System could work very well for a game like this, whether as a more realistic modern setting or a more urban fantasy kind of setting (it's easy to just not use the magical stuff, for example.) Actually sounds like a fun setting for this, imo.
However, while it can swiftly handle the combat and social interactions a Yakuza game would almost certainly have in abundance, there might not be enough crunch to it to provide a deep martial arts system, if that's important to you. Combat mechanics here are pretty simple (but flexible,) so if you wanted a more detailed representation of fighting styles, you would prolly have to plug it into the system yourself. Gunplay is fast and simple in CS, so that part is good-to-go out of the box.
If you want more of a narrative focus with some combat crunch, it could work great. If you want some narrative with a lot of martial arts-y combat crunch, it might not be the best choice without doing some design work of your own to create things like fighting styles, stances, etc.
GURPs 4th edition with the Martial Arts supplement is said to be great for detailed martial arts combat rules. I've not used GURPS in forever, though, so I can't really speak to anything other than its reputation.
As a more general commentary, a Yakuza setting sounds interesting. I could see someone making anything from a gritty, realistic game to something with a bit of a supernatural undercurrent operating behind the scenes. The possibilities for cool social narratives seems huge, with all the ranks and types of scams and relationships between different syndicates and different roles within them, etc. I would probably make it a more narrative-focused game with some big, dramatic set-piece combat scenes. The discovery of secrets and leveraging them would play heavily into it, and the general premise of a "secret war going on all around us" would be a big focus. That's just spitballing, though, since I don't know a lot about the Yakuza.
I wouldn't be able to resist having some supernatural elements, personally. Flaming fists, shadow step, premonition, etc, but that's just how I roll.