Dennou Coil- fin
I have a much more favorable impression coming out of the final 6 or so episode then I did going into them. Around episode 20 or so, I was actively starting to get annoyed with the show as it was seemingly breaking with the earlier scifi roots and taking a more fantastical and spiritual element. In fact, there is a short conversation that points out how illogical the events that were taking place were. That said, the show did come around and gave out the answers in a logical manner that didn't really 'break' the scifi element although it certainly stretched it. I would have probably preferred the technology component being a bit 'harder'. Despite my issues with the show, I can say that the show was made with love and that element comes through on pretty much every level.
Writing-
Here is probably my biggest issue with the show. The pacing in the first half is pretty much a bore. The mystery angle isn't all that interesting and it drags on and on. That said, it was interesting seeing the elaborate world-building that the director and co. had planned. Small touches such as the hand-motion for telephones were fairly cool and a possible real-life solution to stuff like the Google Glasses. There is one rather consistent issue that the show has though and that's the heavy use of jargon that isn't really properly explained until near the end. It reminded me of Ron Moore and his complaint about how ridiculous Tekkie jargon got at times. It also served to make the dialogue feel kinda exposition heavy, which isn't inherently bad but it felt clunky at times in the show. The show also telegraphed certain moments a bit too heavily such as having it rain in the middle of a dramatic confession.
The second half was more the revelation part of the mysteries and at times, seemed rather twist heavy. I also felt that the information handed out wasn't done so in an organic manner in regards to timing. It really created this 'crunch' aspect in regards to the pacing. The show also really shifted gears and lost a lot of the fun aspect the earlier episodes had. So what ended up was a show that goes too slow in the first half and a bit too fast in the later half.
Theme-wise, there certainly were a few good elements. This was something the show focused in on and really delivered. The first is what is real? I found the parents version of something you touch as being real as being strongly outdated. The children come to this realization also that it is the feelings that matter moreso than a physical object. The other theme about letting go was pretty strong and realized exceptionally well in the show. Not only is pain part of the growing up process, it's also a necessity for a relationship.
The highlight of the show are the series of stand-alone episodes in the middle that discuss the personalities of the voids. The plesiosaur and bearded ones were great episodes that were not only funny but also sad at the same time. One thing the show absolutely nailed is pet ownership. It also served to illustrate the technology itself in a simplistic but fun way.
As for the characters, they pretty much all had their moments. Fumie definitely got the shaft in the later half as the show shifted focus to Isako. I'm also not wholly fond of Yasako as she's a rather boring lead, due to her more mellow personality. One real issue I had with the characters was the villain, who was pretty much way over-the-top and somewhat shallow in that regards. He needed a lot more development than what he got.
Soundtrack-
It's definitely a more laidback and atmospheric soundtrack. I'm more of a fan of 'louder' soundtracks so I can't see it goes on my favorites list however
it is well done. I've been listening to pieces separately for the past half-an-hour and I'm warming up to it. A stand-out to me is
Hyouryuu. There's a couple that stand in my mind while watching the show, the primary one being in episode 26. There's a pretty strong emphasis on strings which I've always been partial to.
Animation-
Yea this is the star of the show moreso than anything else. The two strongest words I can use to describe it are consistent and fluid. The fluidity is probably the most remarkable thing about the show and really gives it its life. It really helps make things dynamic and gave certain scenes an extra 'oomph'. The special effects at times were really noticeable. That said, I didn't like the use of the CG and it served to yank me out at times, mainly in regards to the Sachi. That said, sometimes it was used effectively in order to convey the 'otherworldiness' of the VR. The character designs are relatively simplistic but still somewhat distinctive. The coloring reminded me of pastels actually and seemed rather muted, which I'm sure was a deliberate choice in order to fit with the mystery component of the show.
Conclusion-
Could I recommend this? Depends on the person/audience. The main issue is with the pacing, primarily in the first half, that I could see some people getting annoyed. I also didn't find the core mysteries altogether that interesting. That said, it is a very solid title in the scifi anime genre.
Now onto Serial Experiments Lain.