• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Avowed art director calls Elon Musk a "sad little shit" over Avowed gender pronoun complaints, indicates more of the same in final product

Heisenberg007

Gold Journalism
Gotdamn my brother, you have sure come a long way from last year :messenger_neutral:



A game which featured practically the same scenario in a side quest.


Yes. At that point, I was ignoring these things. I think the whole woke thing was over-blown.

In hindsight, I was wrong. Even Spider-Man 2 was quite woke now that I look back at it. Now look at games like Dragon Age Veilguard. Horrible.

This thing is now negatively affecting the quality of games. Even Spider-Man 2 could have been much better without all this.
 
Last edited:

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Yes. At that point, I was ignoring these things. I think the whole woke thing was over-blown.

In hindsight, I was wrong. Even Spider-Man 2 was quite woke now that I look back at it. Now look at games like Dragon Age Veilguard. Horrible.

I bet.


smirk drinking GIF
 
Yes. At that point, I was ignoring these things. I think the whole woke thing was over-blown.

In hindsight, I was wrong. Even Spider-Man 2 was quite woke now that I look back at it. Now look at games like Dragon Age Veilguard. Horrible.

This thing is now negatively affecting the quality of games. Even Spider-Man 2 could have been much better without all this.
So from now on you wont ignore any upcoming Sony game with woke elements?🤔
 

LectureMaster

Gold Member
Yes. At that point, I was ignoring these things. I think the whole woke thing was over-blown.

In hindsight, I was wrong. Even Spider-Man 2 was quite woke now that I look back at it. Now look at games like Dragon Age Veilguard. Horrible.

This thing is now negatively affecting the quality of games. Even Spider-Man 2 could have been much better without all this.
Spider man 2 is the first first party game that I don't own. Borrowed copy from friend, finished it in 25 hours and never looked back.
 

Heisenberg007

Gold Journalism
I get a feeling you will be ignoring this stuff again, a few months into 2025.
So from now on you wont ignore any upcoming Sony game with woke elements?🤔

It's not the gotcha you guys think it is. I was already criticizing Concord even before Avowed. Will continue to do so if another company (including Sony) releases another game like this.

Exactly this. So many devs are being obtuse about what we want.

But this is really good news as people are voting with their wallets. This is really the only way we can make our voices heard.

Both Concord and Black Myth Wukong launched on the same day. Concord is shutting down, while BMW has sold over 15 million copies already. Let this be a lesson to game studios and publishers about what we want.
Concord was generic AF. It flopped, and deservedly so as their focus was more on DEI than the actual game.
The gameplay itself was okay-ish. Nothing extraordinary, but nothing bad either. It was just fine.

The main issue for the game was (1) its price and (2) aesthetics / character design
 

Heisenberg007

Gold Journalism
Spider man 2 is the first first party game that I don't own. Borrowed copy from friend, finished it in 25 hours and never looked back.
The gameplay was a big step up. But the main story / writing / side-quests etc. were downgraded, and I think that's because of their focus on DEI.

Could have been much better. Looking back at everything, SM1 had a much better story.
 

Ozriel

M$FT
It's not the gotcha you guys think it is. I was already criticizing Concord even before Avowed. Will continue to do so if another company (including Sony) releases another game like this.

‘DEI’ and character design is a different conversation altogether.

you basically went from complaining about ‘homophobia’ to sneering about lesbians in one year. That’s not DEI or ‘character design’

You seemed to have zero issues with lesbianism in games just last year, defending it enthusiastically

Heck, here’s your post from last year.
She is not. Do not be swayed by these Internet trolls and salty fanboys.

It is an RPG, and the game offers you a choice of making it romantic if you want to. The same choice is offered for both a guy (Avad) and a girl (Seyka).

Similar to how it is done in Assassin’s Creed, Cyberpunk 2077, or Mass Effect.

You can make her straight, lesbian, bi, or nothing.

6zdIDoK.jpg




Do not be swayed by fake outrage by these salty fanboys.

But now, you’re happy to say that a quest in Obsidian’s 2019 game that involved helping lesbian lovers is proof that the devs are ‘woke’.

Have you turned to one of those ‘salty fanboys’ you complained about last year?
 

GymWolf

Member
Yeah whoever defended sp2 has no right to talk shit about the woke in awoved.

Btw that collage of characters from the outer world looks like a buffet of butch boys for a priest convention :lollipop_grinning_sweat:
 
Last edited:

REDRZA MWS

Member
No developer “art director “ can hold Elon Musks dick. Hess a sad liitgle shit because the other 99.999999 % of humanity don’t give a fuck about made up “pronouns” which is ridiculous to even have to type that shit let alone say it.

Are you going to KNOW your CUSTOMERS and MARKET? Or should a dec/pub in business to make money give a fuck about the .00000000000000000001 % of humanity that is mentally ill?
 

Trilobit

Member
Yes. At that point, I was ignoring these things. I think the whole woke thing was over-blown.

In hindsight, I was wrong. Even Spider-Man 2 was quite woke now that I look back at it. Now look at games like Dragon Age Veilguard. Horrible.

This thing is now negatively affecting the quality of games. Even Spider-Man 2 could have been much better without all this.

I think it's important to bring these things up so that people can notice it. They are of course free to like or dislike woke stuff, but some people don't want anyone shining a spotlight on it. I remember when I was an adult and I was made aware of how entertainment media very often makes dads look stupid and incompetent. Until then in my whole life I hadn't even reflected over how weird that was or how accepted it was. Something just clicked in me.
 

Kokoloko85

Member
This is what Obsidian makes now.

And some people are still being wilfully ignorant with a long list of excuses:

- "It's just pronouns."
- "It's just this guy."
- "He is just the Art Director, not the Game Director or the Narrative Director."

Totally ignoring that their characters looked like this even back in 2019 and quests included helping two lesbian lovers. It's their entire team that has gone woke.

It’s just typical xbox Defence team.
You see these same people talk about Concord lol..This game is gonna end up way more “woke” than Concord
 
Last edited:

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
‘DEI’ and character design is a different conversation altogether.

you basically went from complaining about ‘homophobia’ to sneering about lesbians in one year. That’s not DEI or ‘character design’

You seemed to have zero issues with lesbianism in games just last year, defending it enthusiastically

Heck, here’s your post from last year.


But now, you’re happy to say that a quest in Obsidian’s 2019 game that involved helping lesbian lovers is proof that the devs are ‘woke’.

Have you turned to one of those ‘salty fanboys’ you complained about last year?

dayum ...

Robert Garcia GIF by GIPHY News
 
Last edited:
This is what Obsidian makes now.

And some people are still being wilfully ignorant with a long list of excuses:

- "It's just pronouns."
- "It's just this guy."
- "He is just the Art Director, not the Game Director or the Narrative Director."

Totally ignoring that their characters looked like this even back in 2019 and quests included helping two lesbian lovers. It's their entire team that has gone woke.

This is like the fourth time you’ve brought up this companion quest from Outer Worlds. Weren’t you the one whining about “woke mind virus”? 😆😆



Gotdamn my brother, you have sure come a long way from last year :messenger_neutral:



A game which featured practically the same scenario in a side quest.



‘DEI’ and character design is a different conversation altogether.

you basically went from complaining about ‘homophobia’ to sneering about lesbians in one year. That’s not DEI or ‘character design’

You seemed to have zero issues with lesbianism in games just last year, defending it enthusiastically

Heck, here’s your post from last year.


But now, you’re happy to say that a quest in Obsidian’s 2019 game that involved helping lesbian lovers is proof that the devs are ‘woke’.

Have you turned to one of those ‘salty fanboys’ you complained about last year?

Oh man I am totally shocked by this complete turn now that it isn’t a Sony game. I never ever would have guessed this was coming. Oh man I am totally shocked /s

The best part is how he goes from defending an optional quest that has homosexuality in it to being completely negative about the same kind of quest now that it’s a MS game. Oh man he must have grown so much in between when Spider-Man 2 launched and when Outer Worlds launched. Oh wait, Outer Worlds came out four years before Spider-Man 2 🤭

And this clown had the audacity to try and claim I was playing favorites with a Microsoft game because I intend to buy Avowed and will only try South of Midnight… both Microsoft games.

This is why you don’t let your kids go full warrior.
 

Heisenberg007

Gold Journalism
Western games have gone full shit

Gta6 and next Cory game are the last hope
I am not sure Cory's game will be the opposite of this. It'll likely have some of these elements. But I hope they don't f-up GTA 6.

GTA's real beauty has always been so unhinged (in a good way). It always felt fresh. If it keeps its identity (like San Andreas and GTA 4), it will feel even fresher in today's landscape. I'm very excited for GTA 6. Will be super sad if that also turns out to be idiotic. :(
 

Ozriel

M$FT
Most of the time woke means fucking stereotype character at best. So on average I would expect a mid game out of this.

“they put the ability to choose pronouns in the character creator as a toggle, so the game has to be mid”

Fucking lol

Western games have gone full shit

Gta6 and next Cory game are the last hope

Sweet Baby lists Santa Monica studios as one of their clients, so it’ll be interesting to see if you’ll boycott Cory’s game out of hand.

But i fully expect thatwasdifferent.gif
 

GHG

Member
can "woke" be "well written"?... can actual Nazi Propaganda be "well written"? and if so... should be accepted and celebrated?

I'd argue that if its well written then it's not "woke" at all (considering "woke" is considered an insult in today's world).

There was diversity, gay and lesbians etc in PS1 games for goodness sake (along with a whole host of other mature themes), but the people writing those stories took care to make them both entertaining and believable. What we typically get now is preachy agenda driven nonsense, that is neither entertaining or believable. Which unfortunately comes as no surprise considering the absolute state of the people involved in these projects these days.
 
Last edited:

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
I'd argue that if its well written then it's not "woke" at all (considering "woke" is considered an insult in today's world).

There was diversity, gay and lesbians etc in PS1 games for goodness sake (along with a whole host of other mature themes), but the people writing those stories took care to make them both entertaining and believable. What we typically get now is preachy agenda driven nonsense, that is neither entertaining or believable. Which unfortunately comes as no surprise considering the absolute state of the people involved in these projects these days.

Just out of curiosity, can you name a couple of PS1 games where gay / lesbian / LGBT characters were well written in your opinion?

Cause when I think of older games, it just seems like there were cases of bad stereotypes, eg the Honeybee Inn in FF7, written and played for laughs, or games like Fear Effect where the marketing heavily played on the implied lesbian-ism as a selling point.


g3uo3cwdjub01.jpg



lcqy14aopgo3ue8jrwox.jpg
 
Last edited:

Fabieter

Member
“they put the ability to choose pronouns in the character creator as a toggle, so the game has to be mid”

Fucking lol



Sweet Baby lists Santa Monica studios as one of their clients, so it’ll be interesting to see if you’ll boycott Cory’s game out of hand.

But i fully expect thatwasdifferent.gif

They said there is gonna be more of it in the final release so yes this is gonna be another dragon age situation and yes Cory is going in that direction than fuck his new game the same as obsidian. Why would you make an exception if you don't like this shitty writing.
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
i think this topic is way above your head. but what can we expect.

JAhvgIc.png

1qW6W6E.jpeg

GJOSXiI.jpeg

vCPot31.jpeg

N0JvXYc.png

WIBKzNw.jpeg









Instead of posting random, un-related article pictures, show an example of how you correlated 'woke' writing with Nazi-writing.

Gina Carano being fired from a privately owned company projects does not equate Nazi-ism, FYI.
 
Last edited:
I'd argue that if its well written then it's not "woke" at all (considering "woke" is considered an insult in today's world).
that's the point, something "woke" is inherently flawed (just like racism or discrimination).

i dunno how many times this need to be said: Diversity, inclusion and representation are not the issue, but the extreme ideology held by people on positions of power.
 

Humdinger

Gold Member
can "woke" be "well written"?... can actual Nazi Propaganda be "well written"? and if so... should be accepted and celebrated?

My definition of "woke" includes forced, agenda-driven diversity and inclusion - as opposed to something organic, natural, flowing from the story itself. So to me, a game that is woke is by definition poorly written (hamfisted, modern politics inserted obtrusively). Others seem to define "woke" differently, though, so to them, woke might still be good. I don't see it that way, but I'm not going to fuss over it.
 
My definition of "woke" includes forced, agenda-driven diversity and inclusion - as opposed to something organic, natural, flowing from the story itself. So to me, a game that is woke is by definition poorly written (hamfisted, modern politics inserted obtrusively). Others seem to define "woke" differently, though, so to them, woke might still be good. I don't see it that way, but I'm not going to fuss over it.
exactly
 
My definition of "woke" includes forced, agenda-driven diversity and inclusion - as opposed to something organic, natural, flowing from the story itself. So to me, a game that is woke is by definition poorly written (hamfisted, modern politics inserted obtrusively). Others seem to define "woke" differently, though, so to them, woke might still be good. I don't see it that way, but I'm not going to fuss over it.

This is fine and dandy but the crybaby mob doesn’t look at it this way. Or, at least, there is no such thing as “forced” diversity or inclusion with them, it’s anll encompassing. Any minority or female character is immediately woke. Unless she’s dressed like a whore, then it’s like totes based my man.
 

GHG

Member
Just out of curiosity, can you name a couple of PS1 games where gay / lesbian / LGBT characters were well written in your opinion?

Cause when I think of older games, it just seems like there were cases of bad stereotypes, eg the Honeybee Inn in FF7, written and played for laughs, or games like Fear Effect where the marketing heavily played on the implied lesbian-ism as a selling point.


g3uo3cwdjub01.jpg



lcqy14aopgo3ue8jrwox.jpg

Saga frontier and Parasite Eve. And as a kid I didn't think anything of it, either way.

What's wrong with the marketing for Fear Effect? It was 100% appropriate for the time period.

Just because the marketing wouldn't be appropriate for today's "modern audiences", it doesn't then mean the games themselves were poorly written.

And well done completely ignoring the point I made about entertainment. There is nothing wrong with approaching sensitive themes from a more jovial point of view.

The whole point of videogames is to entertain, but fools like Matt Hansen instead think videogames are now a vehicle for education (which is ironic considering this is not a topic where there is a defined right or wrong way to approach things).
 
Last edited:

Fabieter

Member
This is fine and dandy but the crybaby mob doesn’t look at it this way. Or, at least, there is no such thing as “forced” diversity or inclusion with them, it’s anll encompassing. Any minority or female character is immediately woke. Unless she’s dressed like a whore, then it’s like totes based my man.

This is why most people dislike "woke" games. You're simply dismissing others' opinions because this time, it's a developer or game you're excited about.

If pushing a political message takes priority over creating a good game, then they deserve the backlash they get.
 

Humdinger

Gold Member
This is fine and dandy but the crybaby mob doesn’t look at it this way. Or, at least, there is no such thing as “forced” diversity or inclusion with them, it’s anll encompassing. Any minority or female character is immediately woke. Unless she’s dressed like a whore, then it’s like totes based my man.

Can you point to a specific example of someone doing that on this forum, or in this thread? If so, I'd be interested. Otherwise it's just the usual predictable stuff - calling people racists and sexists for objecting to woke ideology. To me, it usually says more about the accuser than the accused.
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Saga frontier and Parasite Eve. And as a kid I didn't think anything of it, either way.

Parasite Eve has no LGBTQ elements in it. 🤔

I have not played Saga Frontier so can't comment on it.

What's wrong with the marketing for Fear Effect? It was 100% appropriate for the time period.

Just because the marketing wouldn't be appropriate for today's "modern audiences", it doesn't then mean the games themselves were poorly written.

Fear Effect was a thoroughly mediocre game though, and its primary marketing point was "hey watch these two hot girls doing sexy things".

fe_hana_rain.jpg


I guess in that regard it's not much different than Stellar Blade.

And well done completely ignoring the point I made about entertainment. There is nothing wrong with approaching sensitive themes from a more jovial point of view.

The whole point of videogames is to entertain, but fools like Matt Hansen instead think videogames are now a vehicle for education (which is ironic considering this is not a topic where there is a defined right or wrong way to approach things).

I'm not sure I follow this point. Matt Hansen's social media antics should not be transposed on the game without any evidence of the game being overly preachy (like Veilguard, for comparison).

As far as we know, this game's 'pandering' is just a pronoun option.

It might also have all characters be pansexual and be romanceable regardless of gender, but both these things were also done by Baldurs Gate 3 just over a year ago.



Metal Gear Solid:

ZTRGYKh.jpeg


Kojima is a true visionary.

artworks-000440838567-6lgou2-t500x500.jpg
 
Top Bottom