SEGA SATURN JAPANESE VIDEOGAME RANKINGS (1-100)
In the year 2000, Sega Saturn Magazine JP conducted a readers poll to rank every videogame in the Saturn library. Readers submitted their votes using a 1-10 scale, and all games were then ranked in order. A book was then published by Soft Bank titled Saturn no Game wa Sekai Ichii with the full listings of 945 games.
Let's take a look at the first hundred rankings and see what Japanese fans loved the most (games released in the US in bold):
1. EVE Burst Error
2. Grandia
3. Langrisser 5: The End of Legend
4. Kono Yo no Hate de Koi wo Utau Shoujo Yu-No
5. Machi
6. Pia Carrot e Youkoso!! 2
7. Sakura Taisen 2: Kimi, Shinitamou Koto Nakare
8. Linda Cube Kanzenban
9. Culdcept
10. Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers
11. Shining Force III: Scenario 2
12. Himitsu Sentai Metamor V
13. Cross Tantei Monogatari: Motsureta Nanatsu no Labyrinth
14. Thunder Force V
15. Chaos Seed
16. Princess Crown
17. AZEL: Panzer Dragoon RPG
18. J.League Pro Soccer Club o Tsukurou! 2
19. Kidou Senshi Gundam: Giren no Yabou
20. Grandia Digital Museum
21. Super Robot Wars F Kanketsuhen
22. X-Men VS Street Fighter
23. Vampire Savior
24. Sakura Wars
25. Lunar Silver Star Story MPEG
26. Dead or Alive
27. Shining Force III: Scenario 3
28. Advanced World War: Sennen Teikoku no Koubou
29. Silhouette Mirage
30. Wizardry Llylgamyn Saga
31. Soukyugurentai
32. Kakyuusei
33. Soukyugurentai Otokuyo
34. Pia Carrot e Youkoso!!
35. Marvel Super Heroes VS Street Fighter
36. Policenauts
37. Radiant Silvergun
38. Idol Janshi Suchie-Pie II
39. Dino Island
40. Virtual On (FOR SEGANET)
41. Gungriffon II
42. Doukoku Soshite…
43. Marie no Atelier Ver. 1.3: Salburg no Renkinjutsushi
44. Shining Force III: Scenario 1
45. Virtua Fighter 2
46. Game Tengoku
47. Super Robot Wars F
48. Panzer Dragoon Zwei
49. NiGHTS
50. Another Memories
51. Kidou Senkan Nadesico: The Blank of 3 Years
52. Fire Pro Wrestling S: 6 Men Scramble
53. Digital Pinball: Necronomicon
54. Gungriffon: The Eurasian Conflict
55. Soldnerschild
56. Layer Section
57. Sega Ages: Phantasy Star Collection
58. Quiz Nanairo Dreams Nijiirochou no Kiseki
59. Sega Rally Championship
60. Falcom Classics II
61. Madou Monogatari
62. Magic Knight Rayearth
63. Devicereign
64. Desire
65. Meltylancer Re-inforce
66. Sega Rally Championship Plus (X BAND)
67. Baroque
68. Magical Drop III
69. Sega Ages: Fantasy Zone
70. Langrisser IV
71. Bulk Slash
72. Stellar Assault SS
73. Hanagumi Taisen Columns
74. Real Sound: Kaze no Regret
75. Tomb Raiders
76. Ginga Ojousama Densetsu Yuna 3: Lightning Angel
77. World Advanced Daisenryaku: Koutetsu no Senpuu
78. Princess Maker 2
79. Lunar Silver Star Story
80. Virtua Fighter
81. Tokimeki Memorial Drama Series Vol. 3: Tabidachi no Uta
82. Langrisser Dramatic Edition
83. Dodonpachi
84. Yuukyuu Gensoukyoku 2nd Album
85. Tokimeki Memorial Drama Series Vol. 2: Irodori no Lovesong
86. Mass Destruction: Otousan Nimo Dekiru Soft
87. Can Can Bunny Premiere 2
88. Courier Crisis
89. Battle Garegga
90. Real Mahjong Adventure "Umi-He": Summer Waltz
91. Vampire Hunter
92. Yuukyuu Gensoukyoku
93. The King of Fighters ‘97
94. Darius Gaiden
95. Christmas NiGHTS
96. Virtua Cop
97. Marica: Shinjitsu no Sekai
98. Sonic Jam
99. Angelique Special 2 (Premium Box)
100. Waku Waku Puyo Puyo Dungeon
Some quick thoughts:
- Japan's tastes are obviously different from Western gamers, greatly preferring RPGs and Adventure games over Arcade titles. "Visual Novels" are a very popular genre. In addition, they don't appear to be nearly as obsessed with graphics and 3D polygons, as the dominance of 2D games demonstrates. Many US players look to videogames as eye candy or something to "show off the console" to friends, which often means the cutting edge of technology.
- These game rankings don't equate to "best selling" titles. Many of the most beloved Saturn classics sold modestly, such as EVE Burst Error (190,000 copies sold), Yu-No (220,000) and Langrisser V (90,000). Most shocking: Thunder Force V and Soukyugurentai only sold 20,000 copies each. Ouch.
- Virtua Fighter 2 was Saturn's top seller at 1.7 million copies sold. Sega Rally also reportedly sold over a million, but I don't have numbers available. The original Virtua Fighter sold 710,000 copies and ranks high in many gamers polls in Japan. Again, they don't seem to obsess as much over graphics.
- There are barely any sports titles in the complete list, and only one in the Top 100 (J.League Pro Soccer Club o Tsukurou! 2) which is, in fact, a manager sim. Again, this may be a cultural difference, or this may be due to the voting pool. Pretty much anywhere in the world, computer nerds don't like to play sports.
- Fascinating upsets: Dead or Alive (#26) ranks higher than Virtua Fighter 2 (#45), Soldnerschild (#55) ranks higher than Dragon Force (#204), Street Fighter Zero 2 (#102) ranks higher than Street Fighter Zero 3 (#267).
- Courier Crisis at #88? Really? That has to be the biggest surprise in the entire list. It was almost universally derided in the West, and even today, is only begrudgingly respected for its resemblance to Crazy Taxi. Oh, well, the heart wants what it wants. I'll have to give that one another spin.
- The five worst-ranked Saturn games in the entire poll: Standby Say You! (#941), Planet Joker (#942), Starfighter 3000 (#943), Fist (#944) and Death Crimson (#945). Ouch.