So, I bought it hoping for an out from my gaming PC because I'd prefer console convenience and access and a few other reasons. My PC is a 4090-based dedicated living room gaming PC.
My son and I spent a while with the Pro last night. We played a couple worlds in Ratchet and some Spider-Man and more. Looked at some PS4 games with the sharpening on, like Batman: Arkham Knight which I recently beat on PC. The Pro looks nice and runs great. Best console yet, for sure. But as we were playing, it still was in my mind that we are not close enough to the PC's fidelity as I hoped we might be. My son fired up Minecraft, and he's like "I don't think I like it" on the Pro based on PC being able to give more FoV. He's like "I'm too close, like being in front of my character instead of being my character".
So, then we did some A/B back and forth and confirmed that position. I think we both ended in the mindset to return the Pro and keep going with the PC.
No harm, no foul, no hard feelings. The Pro is certainly the best console yet. I think I just need to accept that I prefer to be a PC gamer when I weigh the trade-offs of each decision because I value visual fidelity and performance so much. I know folks will say, just keep both. I really don't want to do that though.
I'll experiment some more and take my time. I have like two months to return it. Maybe we'll Platinum Astrobot 2 for fun, but then we'll see.