• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Raise the flame shield: Your "controversial" gaming opinion.

Carna

Banned
I don't like Mario (lol) this blog from a nobody explains why :

 
Last edited:

Bakkus

Member
I don't like Mario (lol) this article explains why :

Lol, people are not gonna read through an article just to understand you opinion. At least copypaste it.
 

M1chl

Currently Gif and Meme Champion
DOOM ETERNAL's arcade direction ruins the game
This and also Doom 3 is really great game, enjoyed it way more. I got it with pre-order for Doom: Eternal. I would go as far to say, that I enjoyed more Doom 64, which was also pre-order bonus.
 

GiJoint

Member
Nintendo first party games are ok, nothing special - not interested in them

This is mostly down to the fact that when I was a kid growing up, Nintendo didn’t bother with New Zealand as a market so we were all Sega here, Master System and Mega Drive(Genesis) over NES and SNES.
 
Well we can start with the big N then..
  • Pokemon hasn't "evolved" significantly since the first iterations, the last one being the worst one yet.
  • Zelda BOTW has some great gameplay elements and nothing else. It's an 8 at best. Not GOTY by any means.
  • Mario Odyssey needs difficulty options, it's a snoozefest to play all the 5 year old easy stuff to get to some challenges. Mario was a challenge from the start now it's a shadow of it's former self.
  • Mario Tennis Aces is a great game completely destroyed by the same shit N pulls everytime, terrible online.
  • Smash ultimate is great but took no chances. Also during the quarantine I notice that the online is also terrible.
  • Octopath Traveler is worst than 20 year old gameboy jrpgs. There was no effort in the joint story or the gameplay. Just a weird aesthetic that wore off a few hours in.
 

squallheart

Member
Nintendo first party games are ok, nothing special - not interested in them

This is mostly down to the fact that when I was a kid growing up, Nintendo didn’t bother with New Zealand as a market so we were all Sega here, Master System and Mega Drive(Genesis) over NES and SNES.

Lol damn I was going to respond something like this. Grew up with Nintendo but always thought their first party games were horrible. The only one I enjoyed was ocarina of time oh and Mario kart but I see that as an auto pass mainly for being the first in that genre.
 

sneas78

Banned
Mortal Kombat 2 is the greatest game of all time. I’m my opinion it even made street fighter more popular. What I mean by that is I started playing street fighter because of MK.
 
Last edited:

Miles708

Member
Mortal Kombat 2 is the greatest game of all time. I’m my opinion it even made street fighter more popular. What I mean by that is I started playing street fighter because of MK.
Hah, this is an interesting opinion!
I never liked Street Fighter that much (preferred MK in the 16-bit era) but now that I think back, there was a clear rivalry between the two in every gaming circle, so you could be very well right in this.
The opposite is also true, of course.
 
Last edited:

sneas78

Banned
Hah, this is an interesting opinion!
I never liked Street Fighter that much (preferred MK in the 16-bit era) but now that I think back, there was a clear rivalry between the two in every gaming circle, so you could be very well right in this.
The opposite is also true, of course.
For sure, looking at it now most people I guess liked street fighter. It’s all good.. killer instinct came into the arcades around the same time as MK3 .. if I remember correctly. And KI is a bad ass game.
 
Last edited:

Freeman720

Neo Member
I've been playing classic Zelda games for the past couple weeks.

I don't know if this is actually a controversial opinion or not, but if BoTW marks the end of the classic-style 3D Zelda games, I'm gonna be fucking furious. I love BoTW, don't get me wrong, but it just does not scratch the same itch for me as those games.
 
Hmm

Well now i see this is actually about games i will reconsider my post :p

Controversial gaming opinion.. i think any Mario title is a vapid children's game that nobody outside of preschool has any business playing. I remember playing it on a gameboy in the 90s and even then I switched it out for tetris repeatedly.

Also, i think Final Fantasy games are COLOSSALLY overrated. The stories are saccharin and boring, the gameplay is too, the fighting feels ancient and immersion breaking, their constant attempts to tweak it are unanimous failures, the characters are exaggerated and cartoony, the tone is PG as fuck, the art direction is middling at best, the graphics are chock full of filler, it's just a huge money sink of a series.
 
Last edited:

Casanova

Member
Halo 1-3 were gold and anything after that was trash. Super Smash Bros is super fucking boring, Fallout 3 is better than Fallout New Vegas, skill-based matchmaking is a good thing even though I don't get to destroy bots and new players repeatedly, Fortnite is actually a fun game, japanese RPG's suck with the exception of Dark Souls, simulators are for weirdos, Grand Theft Auto isn't really fun to play for more than like 20 minutes, war games are for people who like to drink Bud Light for a good time (except for Halo 1-3).

I could keep going, but I'm getting kinda pissed off just reading my list.
 
Last edited:

Heimdall_Xtreme

Hermen Hulst Fanclub's #1 Member
If America is cooler, than why did UNIQLO come from Japan? America has no cool clothing brands. The only thing America has 'cool' is Apple. Everything else is un-cool.

Lol... even for best Cellphones Huawei is Awesome, best Tech and with a excellent price to be honest… Apple is a piece of shit, expensive and with a low tech.
 
Last edited:
- the 'video games are art' discussion was invalidated when people praised Sony for its censorship agenda and (tried to) rationalize changes for different markets

- journalism in video games doesn't exist. I don't remember the last time a 'journalist' asked a (big) developer/publisher uncomfortable questions and kept pushing for an answer when the other would try to dodge the question.

- somewhat related to the above: Nintendo deserves so much shit for the lack of system-wide party-chat and messaging. The pedophile-excuse doesn't count, because the Switch has the most extensive parental controls ALREADY. Don't wnt children to talk and text to strangers and accept friend requests? ALREADY POSSIBLE. Lack of voice chat and messaging persists because nobody calls out Nintendo once they hear 'Swapnote pedophile'. Fucking sigh ...

- WHY can't we see panties in so many modern games? Honestly, what would happen if Jill Valentine wore her original skirt and we saw her panties during her crawling on the ground? Would the world implode? Because that's the impression I get from those welcoming anti-panty direction. Same for the model viewer in Valkyria Chronicles 1: Someone made sure that no female character's panties could be seen. Must have been quite some work, considering each model demanded a different angle. Ridiculous.

- Monster Hunter World sucks and ruined the franchise. Thanks Capcom and Sony.
 

justAjohn

Member
Captain Tsubasa 2 Super striker is one of the best football games, 4 and 5 are better graphicaly and sidestories in 5 are great but the sound, music and scenario in 2 are much better. They collectively poop on FIFA, PES and the like because CT made footbal fun.

Baldurs Gate 2 is better than Planescape Torment, because the overall package quality is higher than reading.

FF 12 / TZA has made other FF cumbersome to play (except Tactics)

The Last Remnant actually emulates you being in a charge of a group, rather than an all manipulating God (okay Imoen now strip naked, ignore your thief training and learn magic), which makes it the best as far as party management goes.

I didn´t know that Mario was a big deal until I went on the internet. He´s nothing.

On Soulsborne; I played Dark Souls, Dark Souls 2, Demons Souls, Bloodborne, Dark Souls 3, Sekiro in this order. Dark Souls is an empty experience with not much impact until the end (how does the character we play as know the item descriptions). Dark Souls 2 has swifter combat and great spell variety, but bland setting. Demons Souls has great atmosphere, but that´s it. Bloodborne is great except arcane variety sucks. Dark Souls 3 hurt my eyes - so many shadows and light sources. Some fights are tedious, some fights rely on i-frames, some fights are awesome. Sekiro - I reached Oniwa and said no, I will probably try again but the impression I got is overreliance on parry mastering, floaty jumping and weird movement overall. They are all good in 1 on 1 combat. I didnť like how the parry worked in all of them (except Bloodborne) - I found Nioh 1 much better in the parry department.

Dragons Dogma is worse in 1 on 1 combat, but better in spells, better in 1 vs all combat, better in 1 vs monsters combat, better in ingame impact on the world.

Syphon Filter 1 is better than Metal Gear Solid 1. The fluidity of movement, the targetting system the unobfuscated scenario and variety of badass stuff you can do in the former makes it for me.

Alundra 2 is more entertaining than 1.

Digimon games are MUCH better than Pokemon poop, and they always were.

FF 10 is bad - characters eventually become differentiated only by overdrives, story idea is good but the execution is eyerolling, the visual flair masks emptyness (Lulu doesnt fit visually at all), FF 12 is better.

Diablo 1 is better in approach and atmosphere than 2. Diablo 2 has longer and varied scenario, but becomes a roulette lootfest on higher difficulties and very grindy.

Disciples 2 probably has less to offer when compared to Heroes 3, but it has more character and consistent style. Heroes might actually have so much to dazzle you with the amount to hide the shallowness.

The lighstaber has more weight (and maybe length) to it in Jedi Knight 2 than in Jedi Academy. The pure single lightsaber duels are better in JK2, JA has the variety with the 2swords and staff and both are better than Fallen Order, but I appreciate the effort.
 

Darkmakaimura

Can You Imagine What SureAI Is Going To Do With Garfield?
I love all the consoles for different reasons. Console wars are dumb.

Opposing Force is the best Half-Life.

Steam is overrated and has a terrible UI and a mess. Too many horrible games too not worth a smelly ass corn. Worst is it's not drm free.

Darkwatch was a cool game that should got sequel.

Bloodstained Ritual of the Night is good but suffers from some terrible character portraits and lackluster environments. I'm an Iga fan too but it could be better. Curse of the Moon was actually the better Bloodstained game.

Silent Hill: The Room was best Silent Hill.

And yes, I still stand by my view that Diablo 3 is the best Diablo game.
 

Miles708

Member
I've recently realized that I played all the way to the final boss of Bloodborne, and even the final boss of the DLC of Bloodborne, just to finally admit to myself that I honestly hate this game.
Some enviroments are cool, so are the encounters with human-like enemies, but from the ugly woods onwards it's just more lows than hights. Also many bossess are just cheap bullet sponges.

The Playstation d-pad (Vita excluded) is the work of the devil.
I think the Dual Shock 4 D-pad is actually useful. Not perfect, but a stark improvement.
The Sega Saturn pad is light years away, though.
 
Last edited:

ROMhack

Member
Controversial, you say?

Even during its golden generation, Final Fantasy never had a good story, with the exception of FF6.

7 is merely passable and only liked because people played it as impressionable teenagers (soz, might not be true but does feel like it).

8 and 9 are totally forgettable; one being all over the place, the other derivative.

10's is just shockingly shit.
 
Last edited:

M1chl

Currently Gif and Meme Champion
There's nothing controversial about this opinion.
Well, now I can ask, do you find D pad on DS4 "mushy"? Because I like way more XB1 dpad, because it's clicky. But people are saying that it sucks for some reason.
 
As a long time PC gamer, I have say that PC gaming is not all it's hyped up to be. PC's can be temperamental as fuck! Of all the rigs i've owned over the years, I'd have to say well over half of them have suffered from some kind of hardware related issue. Don't even get me started on software related issues!

As PC gaming has seen a huge boom in popularity in recent years, I have a pretty big hunch that many hardware manufacturers out there are cutting more corners when it comes to testing their wares before shipping them, just so they can keep up with the growing demand. Nowadays whenever I purchase a new PSU, MOBO or GPU, I can't help but feel it will become faulty and die within a year of owning the thing.

Like only a few months back I purchased a brand new, RTX 2070 Super and after 3 weeks of use it shit the bed, as it began to show artifacting on the screen, then it would freeze displaying just a single colour. Despite it having adequate cooling, sufficent power and wasn't overclocked or modified in any way.

In my opinion, Console gaming is still the most reliable, stable and cost effective way of enjoying modern releases, even if it means playing with reduced graphics and FPS. It still beats spending hours upon hours trying to troubleshoot a PC.
 

plushyp

Member
Like only a few months back I purchased a brand new, RTX 2070 Super and after 3 weeks of use it shit the bed, as it began to show artifacting on the screen, then it would freeze displaying just a single colour. Despite it having adequate cooling, sufficent power and wasn't overclocked or modified in any way.
The RTX series is in no way indicative of typical graphic card failure though. Nvidia really lost a lot of credibility with it as the failure rates were through the roof. My own 2070 gave up after just 5 months but my 7 years old GTX 770 is still going strong lol.
 

Darkmakaimura

Can You Imagine What SureAI Is Going To Do With Garfield?
Knights of the Old Republic 1 and 2 are on par with and maybe even better than the original trilogy.
 
Fallout 76 is actually a good game. And it's better than fallout 4.

Sure, it uses the same old buggy engine. And on top of that it's an always online shared world. It's a recipe for disaster.
But i haven't experienced nothing game breaking on my end so far. And after over 600 hours of fallout 4 and skyrim and oblivion before that i'm used to the jankness of these games.
I'm new to the game. I have 59 hours of playtime. Never experienced it before the wastelanders update.
There are tons of quests. None groundbreaking until now. But the writing isn't terrible and they give enough context to what you're doing. Voice acting is good enough.
I'm playing it the same way i did FO4. As a single player game. I only interact with other players when doing public events.
 
Spiderman PS4 was an okay game that got a major boost for being a Spiderman game and a PS4 exclusive. It had many elements that people have been complaining bout for years...Ubisoft type tower system, Arkham style combat and the typical "I don't want to go full rpg so here's a half assed skill tree to keep people happy." If it was a third party game it would have been getting more 8's and not 10's.
 

jshackles

Gentlemen, we can rebuild it. We have the capability to make the world's first enhanced store. Steam will be that store. Better than it was before.
My favorite Star Fox game is Star Fox Adventures for the Game Cube
 

SaucyJack

Member
Pokemon is biggest pile of garbage.

it has none of the elements that make an RPG fun to play, like a story, combined with gameplay that is just a chore and is absent any real challenge.

What is the fucking point.
 
Sony's current gen western games games are extreamly overrated and the fan base encourages it. Last gen I could count on one hand the amount of people who would go ballistic if you said Infamous 2 or uncharted 3 sucked for x,y and z. Now if you have any complaint against a sony game your now a hater if some of these games were third party they would be scoring in the 7-8 range.

Game stories like GOW2018 ,TLOU and spider man ps4 are overrated if you've watched at least a decade worth of movies and cartoons. Those games bring almost nothing to the table.

People dislike xbox because the games they make are still heavily inspired from the early 2000s Halo "area shooter" gears "third person action game with arena like MP" Forza "drving game" most of the gaming community couldnt care less about real life cars and most of them have 0 patient to get good at something like an arena shooter.

SSDs arent getting rid of walkie talkie section next gen.
 

Laptop1991

Member
I played Doom Eternal through once and i don't want to replay it, i don't think it is as good as Doom 2016 and it felt like i was just going from death match arena to death match arena, by the same platforming over and over and i wasn't playing the story, i was being told it, also i felt my choice of what weapon to use was taken away and i wasn't a fan of the ammo refill, and it's only missing a store,

just my opinion.
 

Phase

Member
I like playing games on Stadia.
giphy.gif
 

Neil Young

Member
Not a new or hot take but...Breath of the Wild was terrible. It did NOTHING great. Nothing. But people convinced themselves that weapons breaking like they were made out of pretzels, copy and pasted shrines, completely empty areas was somehow revolutionary. "I loved the exploration." For what? A little monster under a rock? How about them bosses? Oh cool, that's an awesome sword...I better not use it because it will break in ten swings. People actually defend this shit. Game of the century.
 

Carna

Banned
Not a new or hot take but...Breath of the Wild was terrible. It did NOTHING great. Nothing. But people convinced themselves that weapons breaking like they were made out of pretzels, copy and pasted shrines, completely empty areas was somehow revolutionary. "I loved the exploration." For what? A little monster under a rock? How about them bosses? Oh cool, that's an awesome sword...I better not use it because it will break in ten swings. People actually defend this shit. Game of the century.
Lol thank you
 
Top Bottom