• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

SIlent Hill 2 Remake | Review Thread

What scores do you think Silent Hill 2 Remake will get?

  • 50-55%

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 56-64%

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 65-69%

    Votes: 9 4.6%
  • 70-74%

    Votes: 15 7.6%
  • 75-79%

    Votes: 36 18.3%
  • 80-84%

    Votes: 74 37.6%
  • 85-89%

    Votes: 50 25.4%
  • 90-94%

    Votes: 8 4.1%
  • 95-100%

    Votes: 5 2.5%

  • Total voters
    197
  • Poll closed .

simpatico

Member
Can anyone already playing comment on the seemingly Silisto Hillocol combat? I mean it looks straight up like a Callisto reskin in some of these melee videos. Plz tell me it doesn’t feel anything like it. That removed all tension since I knew I could whoop any number of enemies with my Mayweather-esque feinting ability.
 
Last edited:

rodrigolfp

Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
Can anyone already playing comment on the seemingly Silisto Hillocol combat? I mean it looks straight up like a Callisto reskin in some of these melee videos. Plz tell me it doesn’t feel anything like it. That removed all tension since I knew I could whoop any number of enemies with my Mayweather-esque feinting ability.
The dude is very "animation limited" and also becomes tired after a few hits. Also can't target more than 1 enemie.
 
Last edited:

Lokaum D+

Member
Still no word on PC performance?

Uh Oh Omg GIF by Rosanna Pansino
download the demo and try it for yourself, buy it if performs good on your PC
 
Last edited:

deriks

4-Time GIF/Meme God
It's the same scene.
Are you nuts?!

Pyramid Head is with two mannequins forcing "something" on them, then they dies. Also, James gets desperate, goes to the closet and shoots the hell of Pyramid Head, then he leaves. Strong, confusing at first, and very effective. This original scene is as close for a rape than a Diddy party has baby oil on people.

The new game a manequim is throw, James kinda sees it, but of course the scene has a different shot and last only two seconds - you can even hear the mannequin in pain thou. James then goes sneaky to the closet and have three shots at Pyramid Head, which he just stands a little and then leaves. Confusing with no instance of resolution, and overall boring
 

Ulysses 31

Member
Are you nuts?!

Pyramid Head is with two mannequins forcing "something" on them, then they dies. Also, James gets desperate, goes to the closet and shoots the hell of Pyramid Head, then he leaves. Strong, confusing at first, and very effective. This original scene is as close for a rape than a Diddy party has baby oil on people.

The new game a manequim is throw, James kinda sees it, but of course the scene has a different shot and last only two seconds - you can even hear the mannequin in pain thou. James then goes sneaky to the closet and have three shots at Pyramid Head, which he just stands a little and then leaves. Confusing with no instance of resolution, and overall boring
Wait till you see what they did with the Maria deaths scenes... 👀
 

Ulysses 31

Member
Cringiest video I’ve ever seen.
That's a culture warrior for you. I post his videos for laughs usually but every now and then he makes a point IMO.



How about this one?

He's more about the the length that can't really support the combat system and things the game does right you might under appreciate because of this.
 
Last edited:

HeWhoWalks

Gold Member
Are you nuts?!

Pyramid Head is with two mannequins forcing "something" on them, then they dies. Also, James gets desperate, goes to the closet and shoots the hell of Pyramid Head, then he leaves. Strong, confusing at first, and very effective. This original scene is as close for a rape than a Diddy party has baby oil on people.

The new game a manequim is throw, James kinda sees it, but of course the scene has a different shot and last only two seconds - you can even hear the mannequin in pain thou. James then goes sneaky to the closet and have three shots at Pyramid Head, which he just stands a little and then leaves. Confusing with no instance of resolution, and overall boring
Ito debunked the rape theme years ago.

The whole point was to look like something sexual is happening, but it is not. Pyramid Head is trying to erase the mannequins from James’ subconscious, but he refuses to let go, shooting at him in the process and prolonging his denials of things he’s done (I won’t spoil that for the newcomers).

So, it’s never been a “rape scene”, rather an expression of violence and the symbol of guilt trying to erase his desires. This is a years old discussion that I remember waaaaaaay back when.
 
Last edited:

SweetTooth

Gold Member
Are you 13? Does seeing a woman who looks like a woman instantly make you horny? So ridiculous that you think woman = pornmaterial
Honestly, your viewpoint is pretty gross.

I'm surprised you got triggered by a joke post! And I couldn't wrap my head around how you made those conclusions and your way of connecting the dots.

My point was Angela looks ok, as long as Blooper sticked with the original vision of Team SH. Fat chin, burned face, beautiful, ugly .. I don't care as long as they stick to Team Silent original vision..my issue is with the community trying their best to make a model out of her.
 

Trilobit

Member
I'm surprised you got triggered by a joke post! And I couldn't wrap my head around how you made those conclusions and your way of connecting the dots.

My point was Angela looks ok, as long as Blooper sticked with the original vision of Team SH. Fat chin, burned face, beautiful, ugly .. I don't care as long as they stick to Team Silent original vision..my issue is with the community trying their best to make a model out of her.

Your joke response is an extremely common serious response from a certain group of people who can't stand feminine looking women so they try to paint others as some kind of perverts, while they themselves come off as having no nuance between porn and depictions of normal looking women. And I often find that very disingenuous which is why I reacted like I did.
 
Last edited:

SweetTooth

Gold Member
Your joke response is an extremely common serious response from a certain group of people who can't stand feminine looking women so they try to paint others as some kind of perverts, while they themselves come off as having no nuance between porn and depictions of normal looking women. And I often find that very disingenuous which is why I reacted like I did.
Angry Season 4 GIF by The Office
 
To be honest i got used to Angela performance/appearance. Can't say the same for Maria, i just don't give a damn about her in this remake.
 
Last edited:

Hugare

Member
Your joke response is an extremely common serious response from a certain group of people who can't stand feminine looking women so they try to paint others as some kind of perverts, while they themselves come off as having no nuance between porn and depictions of normal looking women. And I often find that very disingenuous which is why I reacted like I did.
Every women in the game is cisgender, if you are worried about it.

Angela looks is based on her actress, who is also a cisgender woman.

Both Angela and Maria are based on women that exist in this real world. And both are "normal", as far as I know ("ugly", "not feminine" cisgender women also exist ou there, btw)

Dunno how important these points are in order to enjoy a survivor horror game, but here we are.

Funny how people never complain about ugly male characters. But sure, its not at all about sexual purposes. What do I know.
 
Last edited:

HeWhoWalks

Gold Member
Every women in the game is cisgender, if you are worried about it.

Angela looks is based on her actress, who is also a cisgender woman.

Both are women that exist in this real world. And both are "normal", as far as I know ("ugly", "not feminine" cisgender women also exist ou there, btw)

Dunno how important these points are in order to enjoy a survivor horror game, but here we are.
You’d THINK they would matter less than 0.5%, but alas, we live in an age know where how attractive someone is, is a sticking point to enjoying a game. Been around since the Atari 2600 days and I’ve never seen anything like it.
 

Trilobit

Member
Every women in the game is cisgender, if you are worried about it.

Angela looks is based on her actress, who is also a cisgender woman.

Both Angela and Maria are based on women that exist in this real world. And both are "normal", as far as I know ("ugly", "not feminine" cisgender women also exist ou there, btw)

Dunno how important these points are in order to enjoy a survivor horror game, but here we are.

Funny how people never complain about ugly male characters. But sure, its not at all about sexual purposes. What do I know.

If you don't think we live in an era where there is a push toward making women more masculine in games then I think you have your head so deep in the sand that you're probably half-way to China.
 

tommib

Gold Member
Your joke response is an extremely common serious response from a certain group of people who can't stand feminine looking women so they try to paint others as some kind of perverts, while they themselves come off as having no nuance between porn and depictions of normal looking women. And I often find that very disingenuous which is why I reacted like I did.
She looks like the fucking VA actress! How is that not feminine, dude.

KfYJs9W.jpeg
 

I thought it was hilarious that he mentioned Homecoming.

All I can say is that those voice clips confirmed my fears with the vocal direction. Luke Roberts was great in Outcast: A New Beginning, I don't fault the voice actors, just the direction. I'm glad I opted for Japanese voices.
 

Trilobit

Member
She looks like the fucking VA actress! How is that not feminine, dude.

KfYJs9W.jpeg

The issue was that some people here declared that the more beautiful version of the Angela character was somehow worse because she was too feminine and good looking and that only horny people would want that mod. But I might have misunderstood.
 
You want a hack and slash out of this? If two enemies engages at the same time you are fucked, the combat its great for what this kind of game it is
Come on now. The combat is fun/satisfying but James is a frigging machine. Fighting multiple enemies at once is simple. The dodge is responsive as hell. When I take damage it's my own fault because I get too aggressive.
 

FewRope

Member
Come on now. The combat is fun/satisfying but James is a frigging machine. Fighting multiple enemies at once is simple. The dodge is responsive as hell. When I take damage it's my own fault because I get too aggressive.
Idk on Normal, but in Hard the knife nurses are a fucking nightmare to fight in group
 

MiguelItUp

Member
I swear some folks need to get a breath of fresh air and stay off the internet or something, lmao.

The issue was that some people here declared that the more beautiful version of the Angela character was somehow worse because she was too feminine and good looking and that only horny people would want that mod. But I might have misunderstood.
I believe it's more so because people attempted to make a stink regarding how she looks in the first place when she is literally modeled after the VA. People can do whatever they want to their games with mods, it's their right, always has been. But I personally think the real "issue" is that there are people that think she is some grotesque looking figure that doesn't even resemble a woman when she is in fact modeled by an actual person and woman. It's pretty messed up.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom