-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
InFAMOUS [Mafia] [OT] No Good Karma...
- Thread starter melonrabbit
- Start date
Zippedpinhead
Member
Cabot are you telling me that we need to all get in the game room, tie each other up and have a blood test?
I'm down! But I don't think there is an easy way to do it.
After reading your and *splinter's post, you are right today is Almost impossible to be mylo. We have to assume lylo.
So let's get it right
I'm down! But I don't think there is an easy way to do it.
After reading your and *splinter's post, you are right today is Almost impossible to be mylo. We have to assume lylo.
So let's get it right
So I can't really argue with the Isaac point but the weak mention of Swamped was because they had barely posted up to that point. I didn't want to equate my suspicion of them with the others who weren't replacements so I put the maybe.
I really want to burn you to the ground, zipped.
Safe play would be to keep Sky and cabot around until mylo. Narrowing the pool, passing the problem along. I'm not necessarily happy that iirc only cabot has hinted at this thought. A pool of four then for me.
Initial stance would be Splinter = Zipped > Kalor > LP I imagine.
Initial stance would be Splinter = Zipped > Kalor > LP I imagine.
If I'm scum I feel sorry for town, cause they had no defensive abilities against the neutrals.
Zippedpinhead
Member
You posted The Gif, how could I not comment on it. That and reading the overnight posts just confirmed to me how serious today is that we get it right.
We have to assume today is lylo. Lynch or lose, Cabot and Splinter are right that a no lynch would likely sink this for us. Is that most scum to least scum or most town to least town?
i dont understand this post, we're in lylo?
I mean open your fucking eyes. You think, as scum, I claimed odd-night commuter on D2, and now with all claims in, it happens to work out?
Like think harder Kyan, this is a joke. Why do you put Splinter at the top of your list.
This may be seen as overly defensive, but you know what it's lylo, it should be. You mislynch, you lose. I want to win.
Look at that Town PR lineup, the only counters to the game from the flips given are Ri, Sky and I.
Ri is a protection from a mislynch, subsequently died in the night phase.
Sky protects from scum, though his play and the timing of his claim is suspect.
I protect from scum and both neutrals. I claimed on D2, where not much else was known and here we are now with all claims in. Outside of us 3, there's not much there for counters to extra KP or CCS.
But please, continue to read me as scum.
you mean that opportunity that could've happened at least twice before now?
do me a lemon.
I certainly am not recommending a no lynch. Order of lynch preference.
We have more than a single scum to lynch and thus there will be at least one more night kill. That narrows the pool and if we have enough night kills, scum might be forced to solve one of the claimed prs for us. A theoretical longshot, I know, but still the play imo, unless one of the pr claimants goes full scum.
I do tend to keep my eyes open when reading.
zzz pointless theoretical alternatives that have already been discussed zzz
Thought for a moment there earlier that cabot might just be town but then he got all obtuse about me and all and everything else and now all he does just annoys me.
so zzz, please kill me during the night or make a play for a townie so i don't have to deal with this shit any more
so zzz, please kill me during the night or make a play for a townie so i don't have to deal with this shit any more
i've been wanting to be dead for the past three phases, but I stepped up when I had to, because a mislynch means game over.
Shall I make it easier for you?
1) "Blarg has tunneled cabot but always drops out when the chance presents itself.", Splinter, a tunneler on cabot who does not take the chance to push cabot.
And I know, "buubububububub you say i is scum". Yeah. One or other. The play is damn too long for you two both to be scum.
Then there is the "read reset" from the start today, what essentially gives him cover from anything he has ever said. Posturing for a "well my record has been bad so far, I am not wrong for saying that, am I?"
And then I refresh the thread and lol, why do i even bother.
yeah why do you, been waiting all day for reads and you deliver nothing.
Guess we'll wait for the rest of the scum team to hammer you.
Yeah, this is at the fuck you point now.
cool, thanks.
So as town you'll disappear till final hour?
cause town is on the verge of losing here. Seems a mild fucking waste.
Zippedpinhead
Member
This is not helpful, why not comment on the roles theory? I am about to, would be helpful especially if you are going to peace out for 24+ more hours.
Also not helpful, I know he is being obtuse and difficult. I can tell you are frustrated (I'm frustrated with him not really answering either).
As far as your roles theory, your role fits with what we have seen so far with reveals. Escapist and the beast directly counter each other for weakness death protection for day on Ri and night on Swamped. A commuter of some sort sounds reasonable with what we have seen so far on flips: with the lack of an investigation role (outside of our dead suicide cop) night protection is another very important tool for our survival.
of the other two roles, I think 1-shot doublevote helps our roles fill out better than virgin. I just can't believe that town would get Death for town = punishments for scum roles. Just doesn't make sense.
So if I had to vote right now, I think it would go Skyodin, l_P, and then distantly followed by Kalor/Kyanrute. I have a strong town read on Cabot and only slightly less strong town read on *splinter.
Zippedpinhead
Member
Supposed to say "2 roles where a death for town = punishment for scum" in there.
I wouldn't be against a Sky lynch but I don't think we should do that today. We have four living players that have claimed ordinary and scum are definitely in that batch so I'd rather focus there. If we have to lynch a claimed power roles, that should be saved for the final day assuming we lynch right today.
Zippedpinhead
Member
Because it just flat doesn't make sense.
Assuming 3-4 scum (with 1 dead, can't be 5 since game would be over) and the two neutral, that leaves us with 16-17 townies. I can't believe that more than half of them would be power town roles.
You are absolutely right though. There is No way that scum is not hiding in the vanilla town. But scum also thinks like us. Why not claim a role that makes sense for scum not to night target. Frankly its the perfect role for scum to fake claim. Can't be NK'd afterwards so the virgin lasting until the end is great cover for them.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
We still have over a day, why vote.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Looking back, Blarg got 4 votes and cabot got 2. If you had voted cabot instead, it would've been 3-3.
It's convenient because a townie died, and it wasn't the one you were pushing for previously.
Would you still vote for cabot today?
Right, but I wanted to lynch Blarg, so that's where I voted.
Well, like, just on a gut level, he's either town or he's gone way overboard on the feigned frustration angle. So no I won't be voting Cabot today.
Why Zipped exactly? I'm not against a Zippedpinhead lynch, but why are you for it? I know you mentioned the day 4 vote on Swamped looking like a scum on scum vote, is there anything else?