Support NeoGAF

[Blargonaut]

When I was in the third grade I acted like I read The Count of Monte Cristo for a book report, but I just cheated and copied the one my sister wrote the year before.

quoted for new 50ppp

 

[Blargonaut]

According to their Roles I've unearthed, we can cross myself, franconp and NeckToChicken off this list as 91%-likely Town--

"Player List:

6) NeckToChicken [m] (new)
13) franconp [m]
16) Blargonaut

8) kitsunelaine [f] (new)
12) rac [m]
14) Fat4all [m]
15) melonrabbit [f]
17) Kalor [m]
18) CornBurrito [m]"

--so it's in this pool of 6 we gotta dive into. Six shots more than enough to kill anything that etc.

I agree with NecktoNeck being town. But I thought you said franconp was a big fat liar?

Looking at the votes yesterday, I think we can say kitsune is most likely town. Kitsune was at 5 votes. That's too close for comfort for scum to risk. Wee was a vote on kitsune.

You could say "oh its a bus" but wee was doused and we now know that wasnt a ruse. Scum would bus weemad before they would bus an undoused player.

.

 

[Blargonaut]

 

[Blargonaut]

hmm, I think I agree with kits appearing Town.

That leaves 5

 

[Blargonaut]

Anyone else want to provide their keenest insight into the vote counts

 

[Blargonaut]

UNVOTE

...Well. I definitely wasn't expecting THAT from the arsonist. I'm happy so many scum got done.

And yeah, I stand by my roleclaim as vanilla town. I was incredibly suspicious of the people who started voting against me, thinking that maybe Acohrs was scum and they were rallying to save him and lynch a townie in his place, but lordy was I wrong with that assumption.

im vanilla

I'm a Motion Detector.

I can target anyone at night and see if anyone used and ability by or on them. I cannot tell the difference between those two things (aka, dunno if who I targeted used an ability, or if something was used on them).

Likewise, I can't tell what ability was used, or who it was used by, or any of that good stuff. I'm just either given a yes or no if there was 'movement' or not.

N1 - heymonkey - there was movement
N2 - N/A - (I was on the road and forgot to use my ability N2)
N3 - rac - no movement
N4 - melonrabbit - No Info (I was specifically told there was no reading, which is odd)

Well, this is an exciting day.

Yes, I am the last scum. Congratulations! Town wins.

Settle down, CB. I am the Town RB [Roleblocker].

I blocked you last night, Fat, because I was convinced that you were the arsonist. Clearly, I was wrong.

***

Fine.

Since I'm outta shots.

I blocked Fat last night and Blarg the prior night.

I'm vanilla town.

At this point I think rac or melonrabbit are scum. I'd had to look at how the other scum interacted with them before voting for one of them. I could see a world where Blarg is scum but I find it unlikely. A role cop makes sense for town.

You can't discount me. If I'm scum I bussed weemad hard, and that would be ideal because I'd have known he was doused by the arsonist anyway.

I can discount me because I know my own role.

I am vanilla Town.

Personally I think a role cop balances out the confusion a ton of watchers + sleepwalkers would cause. So I can believe town role cop quite easily. It also made Blarg a huge target for the arsonist so I don't think Blarg would claim role cop after someone claimed doused.

Unless Blarg claimed role cop before someone claimed doused.

8) kitsunelaine [f] (new) -> [TOWN?] Vanilla?
12) rac [m] -> [TOWN?] Vanilla?
14) Fat4all [m] -> [TOWN?] Motion Detector?
15) melonrabbit [f] -> [TOWN?] Roleblocker?
17) Kalor [m] -> [TOWN?] Vanilla?
18) CornBurrito [m] -> [TOWN?] Vanilla?

--and the delicious bit is, 5 out of 6 of you MUST be telling the truths about your Roles (CornBurrito being the exception, since via Neck's Gossip invite, Corn knew I was 2-shot before my reveal Today), since all of you were Role-claiming Today under the false impression/horror that I could have Role-Investigated any one of you the prior Nights!!

aha

ahaha

 

[Blargonaut]

It's Mafia

Dead Players:

19) Cewyn [m] Lynched Day 1, Scum Switcher
5) nin1000 [m] Killed Night 1, Town Sleepwalker
20) Zubz [m] Lynched Day 2, Town Night Watchman
2) Hey_Monkey [f] Killed Night 1, Town Watcher
11) Karkador [m] Lynched Day 3, Vanilla Town
1) Lone_Prodigy [m] Killed Night 3, Town Bodyguard
3) isaacnukem [m] Killed Night 4, Town Sleepwalker
4) Dusk Soldier [m] Killed Night 4, Scum Vanilliser
7) weemadarthur [-] Killed Night 4, Scum Ninja
10) LaunchpadMcQ [m] Sorian [m] Killed Night 4, Vanilla Town
9) acohrs [m] Won Night 4, Neutral Arsonist

Out of 20 players:

2 confirmed as real Vanilla Town postmortem (Karkador, LaunchpadMcQ/Sorian)
1 confirmed as real Vanilla Town via [my] Investigation (franconp)
---
3 confirmed Vanillas

Today:

4 Vanilla Town claimants (kitsunelaine, rac, Kalor, CornBurrito)

...

soooo



7? Vanillas in a 20 player game
13? Power Roles





7 dead Town
me, franconp, Neck, 3 more confirmed Town; live
---
10 real Town / 20 players



3 dead Mafia
?? left
---
That's 13/20 players accounted for, but plus acorns the Arsonist that makes 14

so 14/20




10 real Town, plus 4 *alleged* Vanillas Today?

alleging 14 out of 20 players are Town

6 slots left

3 Mafia take 3

3 slots left

Arsonist takes 1

2 slots left

2 Power Role claimants Today (Motion Detector, Roleblocker; Fat & melon respectively)

0 slots left




so therefore one or two of Today's Vanilla claimants, is the last scum of this game

 

[Blargonaut]

ergo

8) kitsunelaine [f] (new) -> [TOWN?] Vanilla?
12) rac [m] -> [TOWN?] Vanilla?
17) Kalor [m] -> [TOWN?] Vanilla?
18) CornBurrito [m] -> [TOWN?] Vanilla?

One of these 4 is Just Mafia

 

[Blargonaut]

Between these 4 Vanilla claimants:

• kitsunelaine stuck to her guns with her Vanilla claim, and I don't think she's been playing or voting informed throughout the game. Corn thinks she's definitely Town.
• rac has been the meandering wild type of poster this game, along with his votes; sinister or innocently aloof? Dunno.
• Kalor has mostly been an under-the-radar entity this game; I've had my suspicions throughout the game about him, but nothing conclusive. Have to go through his vote counts for patterns' sakes.
• CornBurrito, through being invited to [Town] NeckToChicken's Gossip chat, is the only one who knew I was 2-shot Detective before the mass claim Today; and so he knew that it would be safe to lie Today.

HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM

 

[Blargonaut]

uhhhhh wait my math

 

[Blargonaut]

10 real Town, plus 4 *alleged* Vanillas Today?

alleging 14 out of 20 players are Town

6 slots left

3 Mafia take 3

3 slots left

Arsonist takes 1

2 slots left

2 Power Role claimants Today (Motion Detector, Roleblocker; Fat & melon respectively)

0 slots left

2 slots left

2 Power Role claimants Today (Motion Detector, Roleblocker; Fat & melon respectively)

0 slots left

2 slots left

2 Power Role claimants Today (Motion Detector, Roleblocker; Fat & melon respectively)

0 slots left

2 slots left

2 Power Role claimants Today (Motion Detector, Roleblocker; Fat & melon respectively)

0 slots left

 

[kitsunelaine]

I like to think you all can think I'm innocent because, if nothing else, I claimed vanilla townie before it was cool.

 

[franconp]

That math makes no sense Blarg.

Also both Blarg and Melon said that they ran out of shots so that would make Fat and Neck the only power roles in the game.

Fat power role at the beginning of the game was kind of useless from all the roles that were in play but now it could be a very important role.

If Neck don't use his role and fat target someone and find that he had activity that only could be scum. If he doesn't find activity that means that the player is most likely town (the scum ninja is dead so scum would appear on the investigation unless there are 2 left).

 

[rac]

I like to think you all can think I'm innocent because, if nothing else, I claimed vanilla townie before it was cool.

not really something to brag about

 

[CrimsonFist]

CornBurrito (0)
Blargonaut (2011)

Melonrabbit (1)
CornBurrito (2023)

Blargonaut (1)
Rac (2094)

Kitsunelaine (1)
Melonrabbit (2096)

Day Ends:

Majority is 5

 

[Blargonaut]

You know, since no one has confessed since the beginning of the game to have been Vanillaized... What if scum predicted I would Investigate franconp after his D2 Zubz tunnelling debacle, and Vanillaized one of their own (franconp) in order to best fool me?

 

[Blargonaut]

VOTE: franconp

 

[Blargonaut]

but I mean c'mon the last scum's obvs. melon

Town Roleblocker? pls

 

[franconp]

You know, since no one has confessed since the beginning of the game to have been Vanillaized... What if scum predicted I would Investigate franconp after his D2 Zubz tunnelling debacle, and Vanillaized one of their own (franconp) in order to best fool me?

So, you think that scum used their only vanillaizer on me hoping that you would target me that night?

Even when you said during the day phase that you wouldn't target me?

I find it unlikely.

 

[Blargonaut]

7? Vanillas in a 20 player game
13? Power Roles

3/13 confirmed dead scum

10 PRs

me 9

Neck 8




nin, Zubz, hey_monkey, LP, isaac.

7, 6, 5, 4, 3.


fat and melon.

2? and... 1?



0





No room for existing Arsonist acorns PR (or at least 1 of Today's PR or Vanilla claimant)

SOMEONE'S LYING







IF ONLY WE HAD A ROLE COP

 

[Blargonaut]

So, you think that scum used their only vanillaizer on me hoping that you would target me that night?

Even when you said during the day phase that you wouldn't target me?

I find it unlikely.

 

[franconp]

So you think that I bused hard on Cewyn day one?

And that I tried to stop año the arsonists lynch even when one of my partners was doused?

 

[CornBurrito]

Blarg idk why people listen to you.

 

[franconp]

Because he is one of the few people actually posting?

Just look at Kalor. He made 44 post so far. Just barely over the 10 post rule. And that's the most extreme example. There are others.

 

[rac]

corn and i had 76 posts each

until this post

 

[rac]

oh look another player I read perfectly, Dusk Soldier

so why not ever vote for them?

 

[melonrabbit]

I like to think you all can think I'm innocent because, if nothing else, I claimed vanilla townie before it was cool.

I'm not exactly sure what this is supposed to tell us. Claim aside, you sheep (copy) all your votes and your support of your reads (opinions) on players has been nonexistent.

Like, I just want to hear more from you. What are *your* thoughts on the game? What's happened and been talked about today so far?

There's being new and worried about how to jump in and actually play mafia and then there is not even trying to play -- and if I go down the latter road I have to ask myself 'why?'

 

[CornBurrito]

Melon, you're not going to get the lynch on kitsu. Give up bro. You're the final scum arent you?

 

[NeckToChicken]

Also both Blarg and Melon said that they ran out of shots so that would make Fat and Neck the only power roles in the game.

Fat power role at the beginning of the game was kind of useless from all the roles that were in play but now it could be a very important role.

If Neck don't use his role and fat target someone and find that he had activity that only could be scum. If he doesn't find activity that means that the player is most likely town (the scum ninja is dead so scum would appear on the investigation unless there are 2 left).

Blarg, this is why keeping that a secret would have been a good thing. You being the biggest threat gets you put on night-kill street, sure, but it also gives Fat one more opportunity to motion detect. *Assuming everyone is telling the truth* any motion at this point is scum caught red handed.

It also had the bonus opportunity of outing you or Corn as scum if you didn't die, due to either you being scum or Corn knowing that you're toothless and he wouldn't need to follow through on you.

As is, Fat is now the top kill candidate because he is the only one with a power that matters anymore.

Also franconp I have to use my invite every night or it's used at random for me, but I could easily just invite Fat to avoid triggering a motion detect.

 

[NeckToChicken]

I would also like to take this opportunity to METAGAME and mention that all scum roles so far have been "x-shot blah blah blah", and the only town role that had an x-shot component (Zubz) was not mentioned in the role name.

I wonder why it would be that a role cop ability wouldn't reveal that specific weakness...

 

[franconp]

Blarg, this is why keeping that a secret would have been a good thing. You being the biggest threat gets you put on night-kill street, sure, but it also gives Fat one more opportunity to motion detect. *Assuming everyone is telling the truth* any motion at this point is scum caught red handed.

It also had the bonus opportunity of outing you or Corn as scum if you didn't die, due to either you being scum or Corn knowing that you're toothless and he wouldn't need to follow through on you.

As is, Fat is now the top kill candidate because he is the only one with a power that matters anymore.

Also franconp I have to use my invite every night or it's used at random for me, but I could easily just invite Fat to avoid triggering a motion detect.

But if you don't use it you still know who you will be inviting the next day phase when it's at random?

Because if at the start of the next day phase you know who you targeted after Fat post his result you can say who you invited and that player can confirm. So we would know if you messed up with Fat investigation. Also if you targeted someone and Fat investigated him and he said no results he is lying and should be lynched.

This could work with you making the invite, just don't post who you target beforehand.

 

[Fat4all]

Wait, I'm confused, should I say before the end of the day who I'm going to target tonight?

 

[franconp]

Wait, I'm confused, should I say before the end of the day who I'm going to target tonight?

Please don't.

Just target the one you find more suspicious. If he moves and wasn't targeted by Neck he is most likely scum.

 

[Fat4all]

Can do.

 

[Blargonaut]

The scum(s) wouldn't dare kill Fat while I'm still kicking. I'm a liability

 

[Blargonaut]

Blarg, this is why keeping that a secret would have been a good thing. You being the biggest threat gets you put on night-kill street, sure, but it also gives Fat one more opportunity to motion detect. *Assuming everyone is telling the truth* any motion at this point is scum caught red handed.

It also had the bonus opportunity of outing you or Corn as scum if you didn't die, due to either you being scum or Corn knowing that you're toothless and he wouldn't need to follow through on you.

As is, Fat is now the top kill candidate because he is the only one with a power that matters anymore.

Also franconp I have to use my invite every night or it's used at random for me, but I could easily just invite Fat to avoid triggering a motion detect.

T A C T I C A L

 

[Fat4all]

I wouldn't be shocked to kick the bucket tonight, but I know town can pull through in my absence.

 

[Blargonaut]

I wouldn't be shocked to kick the bucket tonight, but I know town can pull through in my absence.

NO, I'M STILL KICKING

MY KICKING

MINE

 

[Fat4all]

 

[Blargonaut]

Tonight's redudant. If all you slackers just stepped up your games Today, we wouldn't need to worry about the future

We have everything we need to catch the last scum NOW, not later

 

[franconp]

Tonight's redudant. If all you slackers just stepped up your games Today, we wouldn't need to worry about the future

We have everything we need to catch the last scum NOW, not later

We don't actually know if there is only one scum remaining.

But the post was true. Who do yo think we should lynch today?

I'm leaning between Melon, Kitsune and Rac (in that order).

 

[Blargonaut]

I'd say the safest elimination would be melonrabbit; "Town 2-shot Roleblocker" in the midst of all these Town Power Roles, just doesn't agree with me

The next best suspect would be CornBurrito; due to being invited to Neck's Gossip table before Today's mass Role-claim, only Corn was privy to tbe knowledge that I Rolecop was really empty-2-shot. Thus out of all of Today's claimants, it's the greatest probability that he's the liar.

Then it's rac, who's Just been wholly scummy with his skulking and jabbing between wasteposts and I don't trust him

Kalor and kits, I'm inclined to believe they're real Vanilla.

 

[Blargonaut]

That being said, you know I prefer the middle ground so

VOTE: CornBurrito

Meet me there

 

[Blargonaut]

"redudant"? smh

 

[Blargonaut]

and I don't need Powers to save my Town, I have brainpower

 

[Blargonaut]

Blarg idk why people listen to you.

scum if you escape me Today, I want you to kill franconp. If fran is still alive Tomorrow I will consider him to be the last scum.

 

[CornBurrito]

Blarg, I have a question.

In the gossip chat you said you LIED about checking franconp.

Now you seem to be claiming you actually did check franconp. Which is it?

 

[Blargonaut]

Blarg, I have a question.

In the gossip chat you said you LIED about checking franconp.

Now you seem to be claiming you actually did check franconp. Which is it?

sorry I lied

 

[Blargonaut]

about lying

 

[Blargonaut]

*chop*

I'm curious Blarg, was your vulture comment a call to invite Launch or did I misread that?

no, nothing to do with Launch, I was insinuating that I can't read the Gossip chat anymore; I thought I remember you saying there invitees had membership-for-life so I wanted to inform you that wasn't the case slyly

oops