• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Switch 1 OLED or Switch 2 (LCD?) for a newcomer?

What's a better choice for the next several years for a person, who hasn't owned Nintendo's console?

  • Switch 1 OLED

    Votes: 17 11.0%
  • Switch 2 (seemingly, LCD)

    Votes: 138 89.6%

  • Total voters
    154

daxgame

Member
Depends what "next several years" mean.
For a couple of years it might be worth getting the cheaper OLED as Switch 2 builds its library if budget is a factor for you.

But otherwise it doesn't make much sense.
 

Fake

Member
Depends.

I'll get Switch 2 because I'll not be on portable. 100% time will be plugged on my TV.

So, do you have a good TV? Or you want to play anywhere?
 

kevboard

Member
Do I need the new games NOW, if I haven't touched any Nintendo games for the past 30 years?

I mean... no, but many Switch games will probably really benefit from the new hardware.

some of the leaks say they already showcased Zelda running at 4K 60fps at gamescom last year to show off the hardware. (an given that literally all the leaks so far turned out to be true... I doubt this one will be the exception)

and given how Nintendo games are known to be long time sellers, Nintendo should be highly motivated to update they existing games to not only entice people to upgrade the hardware, but also to keep the sales of the old games going for as long as possible
 
Last edited:

Fake

Member
I want to try portable gaming.

So, Switch OLED.

My guess is NS2 will be focus on the docked rather than mobile. They want a Nintendo Switch to be good on TV, but the regular NS is doing fine on portable.

And is probably a LCD display, so is kinda of a downgrade in comparison with the OLED.
 

KyoZz

Tag, you're it.
A dying console, or the brand new one with better tech and retrocompatibility so you won't miss any Switch 1 game

Think Stephen Colbert GIF by The Late Show With Stephen Colbert
 

Parazels

Member
I mean... no, but many Switch games will probably really benefit from the new hardware.

some of the leaks say they already showcased Zelda running at 4K 60fps at gamescom last year to show off the hardware.

and given how Nintendo games are known to he long time sellers, Nintendo should be highly motivated to update they existing games to not only entice people to upgrade the hardware, but also to keep the sales of the old games going for as long as possible
Good point. That's why I created the poll to figure out the best decision.
 

Kacho

Gold Member
Just wait for the Switch 2 and you can play everything you want to. The price difference will be minimal.
 

adamsapple

Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Why would you buy a Switch 1 now, with the second one so close and reportedly having full BC which would benefit performance constrained games.
 
I sold my Switch OLED hoping the existing games get a performance boost. You might as well wait to do the same.

LCD panels are also a lot better than they were in 2017.
 

blacktout

Member
Honestly, I would wait until April to make this decision, because we're currently lacking some critical information. We don't know:

1. How much the Switch 2 will cost.

2. If it will enhance existing Switch games in any way.

3. If the Switch OLED is going to get a price cut.

4. How robust the Switch 2's launch library will be.

If the Switch 2 is $399 and the OLED Switch stays at $349, then this is an absolute no-brainer. Buying an eight year old console over a brand new one just to save $50 would be nuts. But if the price difference is larger and you don't care about playing the newest games right away, the OG Switch has a massive library that could easily keep you busy for years.
 

Parazels

Member
Honestly, I would wait until April to make this decision, because we're currently lacking some critical information. We don't know:

1. How much the Switch 2 will cost.

2. If it will enhance existing Switch games in any way.

3. If the Switch OLED is going to get a price cut.

4. How robust the Switch 2's launch library will be.

If the Switch 2 is $399 and the OLED Switch stays at $349, then this is an absolute no-brainer. Buying an eight year old console over a brand new one just to save $50 would be nuts. But if the price difference is larger and you don't care about playing the newest games right away, the OG Switch has a massive library that could easily keep you busy for years.
Yes, I want to play Metroid Prime and Metroid Dread, Resident Evil Zero, Mario + Rabbits, Valkyria Chronicles 1. Everything in a portable mode.
 
Last edited:

blacktout

Member
There won't be Switch 2 "exclusives" for maybe years anyway.

This is another reason to wait until April to make a decision. We have absolutely no way of knowing if this is true or not.

Furukawa made a statement about the importance of having Switch 2 exclusive software during the Nintendo investor Q&A a couple days ago, so they probably will have some games during the first few months that won't be available on the OG Switch, but we don't know yet which games will be exclusive and which will be cross-gen. Hell, there are currently *no* officially announced Switch 2 games, cross-gen or otherwise. Nintendo hasn't even officially commented on the Mario Kart game they showed in the reveal trailer.

You definitely shouldn't take over-confident speculation as fact.
 

blacktout

Member
Yes, I want to play Metroid Prime and Metroid Dread, Resident Evil Zero, Mario + Rabbits, Valkyria Chronicles 1. Everything in a portable mode.

Dread apparently looks especially good on the OLED screen, so I can see why you're conflicted.
 

diffusionx

Gold Member
You've waited this long, might as well wait until April to see what the Switch 2 actually is and what it is doing.
 

ANoa

Member
If you can wait until potentially Fall then go for a Switch 2. If you want to get something now and start working on the backlog, grab a Switch 1.
 

Zacfoldor

Member
I want to try portable gaming.
The OLED then. The LCD sucks for a handheld. Not only is it lower quality screen, but the ugly bezel is from 1999. OLED is vastly superior if you are going to use it in anything but docked mode. The screen on the OLED is just so good and the old screen is just so shit that you can't compare them.
 

Ozriel

M$FT
The OLED then. The LCD sucks for a handheld. Not only is it lower quality screen, but the ugly bezel is from 1999. OLED is vastly superior if you are going to use it in anything but docked mode. The screen on the OLED is just so good and the old screen is just so shit that you can't compare them.

Terrible advice. And read the OP. The ‘LCD’ in discussion is for Switch 2, not Switch 1.

See the PS Portal for how LCD displays can still be high quality.
 

Parazels

Member
Ok, perhaps it's more reasonable to buy Switch 2, because even if I buy Switch 1, later I will have to buy Switch 2 anyway.

So why take more steps, than necessary?
 

kevboard

Member
There won't be Switch 2 "exclusives" for maybe years anyway.

Mario Kart 9 will not release on Switch 1.
I would bet on that even.

the next 3D Mario game will also not release on Switch 1 and will probably release within the first year of the system.
that's another bet I'd take.

Splatoon 4 will also not release on Switch 1, but that might not come within the first year.
 
Last edited:

EruditeHobo

Member
Mario Kart 9 will not release on Switch 1.
I would bet on that even.

the next 3D Mario game will also not release on Switch 1 and will probably release within the first year of the system.
that's another bet I'd take.

Splatoon 4 will also not release on Switch 1, but that might not come within the first year.

I don't see any reason to believe any of that, with well over 100 million Switches out there.

3D Mario being exclusive I think makes the most sense out of those bullet points, but will have to see where that falls in the release calendar. Mario Kart looking pretty much like DLC/add-on IMO would be disappointing to be exclusive... if that's what's meant by "this won't play on Switch 1" then the only thing that does is really devalue what it means to be "Switch 2 exclusive", for me. It also would only change things for people who are desperate to be day 0 for the new MK game, which obviously doesn't apply to OP otherwise he'd have already been there for Switch, right?

BUT admittedly and obviously all this is just common sense-ing and guesswork... like everyone else, I'm waiting to see see the actual, verifiable shape of things. And that starts in April.
 
Last edited:

Fbh

Member
The Oled screen is nice, but at this point it doesn't make sense to get a Switch 1 IMO.
Switch 2 will be backwards compatible on top of having new games and probably more third party support too.
It's also very likely it will run Switch 1 games better too, even if Nintendo doesn't release enhanced versions (though I don't see why they wouldn't), I imagine the extra power from the hardware will still allow Switch 1 games to reach their resolution and performance targets more consistently.
 
Last edited:

Minsc

Gold Member
good luck with the burn in lol

Fake news. Burn in takes longer than battery degradation. And you can just swap in a new screen if you need to in 10 years, like with the Steam Deck, but more than likely you'll just be gaming on the Switch 3 instead.
 
I'm really disappointed in the reportedly lack of OLED for Switch 2( though not surprised, it's obvious what their play will be here). LCDs have gotten better but we need to see what quality of panel they use. Will it be more in line with the original Steam Deck, or the Rog Ally?

Hell, if Nintendo put out a Switch 1 lite OLED for $199 I'd grab one exclusively for 2d Indies. I remember the first time I played Hollow Knight on the OLED coming from the OG model, talk about transformative.
 

kevboard

Member
I don't see any reason to believe any of that, with well over 100 million Switches out there.

3D Mario being exclusive I think makes the most sense out of those bullet points, but will have to see where that falls in the release calendar. Mario Kart looking pretty much like DLC/add-on IMO would be disappointing to be exclusive... if that's what's meant by "this won't play on Switch 1" then the only thing that does is really devalue what it means to be "Switch 2 exclusive", for me. It also would only change things for people who are desperate to be day 0 for the new MK game, which obviously doesn't apply to OP otherwise he'd have already been there for Switch, right?

BUT admittedly and obviously all this is just common sense-ing and guesswork... like everyone else, I'm waiting to see see the actual, verifiable shape of things. And that starts in April.

the Switch 1 will not have a cross gen period like the PS5 and Series consoles. third party Devs will not be able to port most games to Switch 1 due to hardware limitations, and Nintendo has no incentive to make cross gen games that aren't already promised (Metroid Prime 4 for example is announced for Switch 1 already, so they will fulfill that promise)

not a single big Nintendo game that isn't already announced for Switch 1 will release on Switch 1. there's no reason to believe otherwise. Nintendo doesn't need to sell 20 million copies of their games to make a profit, but Nintendo needs to establish a big userbase for Switch 2 as quickly as possible.
therefore releasing any game on Switch 1 that isn't already announced for it would be a stupid move on their part.

Pokémon Z-A and Metroid Prime 4 will absolutely be their only big titles that will be cross gen.
they will probably release some small titles for Switch 1 for maybe a year or so, just to make it not look pike like they instantly abandoned it. but those games will be stuff like remasters.
 
Last edited:

Spukc

always chasing the next thrill
Fake news. Burn in takes longer than battery degradation. And you can just swap in a new screen if you need to in 10 years, like with the Steam Deck, but more than likely you'll just be gaming on the Switch 3 instead.

Oled was never fixed
The screens can even crack and explode
 

kevboard

Member
It absolutely will.

literally technologically impossible for anything that isn't an indy game.

you can't port Doom The Dark Ages, Halo Infinite, Call of Duty, Forza Horizon 5, or Flight Sim to Switch 1... and this is only Microsoft's titles
And Nintendo has no incentive to release cross gen either.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom