keefged4
Member
I cant speak for the PS5 version, but on PC I played through the release code to completion with no issues. The labyrinth bug was introduced in a later patch. You should be fine.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
[Digital Foundry] Silent Hill 2 Remake on PS5 Pro: A Mixed Bag of an Update... And PSSR Has Issues
Topher
Identifies as young
Devs should definitely add an option to run in non-Pro modes, but that's not up to Sony. This is on Blooper to fix.
Yea. Patch 1.006 looks extremely similar to the base ps5 version. Like almost identical.
I think I might be right here guys.
MaKTaiL
Member
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
Or, don't implement it in a patch until it's ready. The good results show that this is much more of a dev problem than a PSSR one.
Feel Like I'm On 42
Member
There seems to be a downgrade in Quality mode to my eyes ...the lighting used to have a very rich quality to it that isn't there now
Feel Like I'm On 42
Member
Sony should be stepping in to help with games like this especially timed exclusives ...they have every reason to want to help out
Feel Like I'm On 42
Member
I think they did mess with the Gi/Lumen because light bounce seems worse, colors seem worse in general especially noticeable in Quality
Yea, they adjusted the DRS range maybe and the pro clearly looks sharper in this section with a higher lower bound.There was a BIG hit in performance though.
Nah, I think they reverse back to the old ps5 version with higher DRS range.
Take a look at the new video comparison above this post. The new lighting is pretty similar to the base ps5 which had lower quality in AO compare to the pro 1.005 version.
owandeseis
Member
Seems they did put shadows and AO to the absolute minimum on this patch, lower than in base PS5, and also took a FPS performance hit, to raise the internal resolution to try to fix a bit of that crazy shimmering, and it works since it looks at least playable now.
And this was in the patch 1.005 :
Topher
Identifies as young
Sure, but saying they need to help the devs is a different argument than suggesting the problem is the tech itself. Unless, of course, I misunderstood the previous post.
Last edited:
Feel Like I'm On 42
Member
It's the opposite...the first thing i noticed was the lack of depth to the image and washed out look
Digital Foundry is often wrong as they're not spending the same amount of time we are playing these games
Feel Like I'm On 42
Member
I agree with that ...i don't think the tech is bad though clearly it's not in a mature state. I feel very strongly though that Sony should be stepping in to help 3rd parties starting first with timed exclusives like SH2.
Sony's handling of the Pro has been terrible. From not updating games like Ghost of Tsushima and Returnal to being so "hands off" working with devs and not paying devs if needed to get big games like Cyberpunk supported.
I'm also constantly getting DNS drop outs using Wifi on it.
Giallo Corsa
Member
Bloober team, you absolute incompetent hacks, way to tarnish the reputation of your 9/10 received game, you have to be some special kind of stupidly incompetent hacks as to screw things up like this.
I mean, shit, all their previous games ran like absolute shit on consoles (minus The Medium) so this was to be expected, thing is, this isn't their run of the mill shite that they produce but a beloved game that - magically - they managed to pull it off.
Once mediocre, always mediocre, said it before and i'll say it again : This company has actually some pretty good artists but when it comes to the technical side of things (coding) they're an absolute mess.
I mean, shit, all their previous games ran like absolute shit on consoles (minus The Medium) so this was to be expected, thing is, this isn't their run of the mill shite that they produce but a beloved game that - magically - they managed to pull it off.
Once mediocre, always mediocre, said it before and i'll say it again : This company has actually some pretty good artists but when it comes to the technical side of things (coding) they're an absolute mess.
Topher
Identifies as young
Think Sony could definitely have prioritized SH2 more than they did considering how incredibly different things look for Stellar Blade. Matter of resource allocation, I'm guessing. But yeah, don't really have much problem with what you are saying overall. Every game is basically a promotion for Pro and that can be positive or negative. It is certainly in Sony's best interest that games released with "Pro Enhanced" labels meet a certain standard. At the same time, devs are able to look at the game just as well as anyone else and see the issues. They need to hold off on patches for Pro until the patch is ready, whether with Sony's help or not.
Luipadre
Gold Member
Yes they patched it
SlimySnake
Flashless at the Golden Globes
Just switch out PSSR guys. it's ok to take the L.
Maybe some money exchanged hands which is why they are being so stubborn about it. I already see the comments shitting on UE5 when the base PS5 version didnt have these issues lol.
The issue isnt with UE5. Lets all use our brain and stick to TSR. You will get back more GPU and you can push resolution even more than 900p.
Devs need to realize that this is not a PS4 pro style upgrade, and they need to extract the most out of this 40-45% extra GPU performance. If you increase settings, you lose a good portion of that. If you use PSSR, you will lose a good portion of that. Then there are the memory costs of AI reconstruction. Do what Lords of the Fallen devs did, increase the resolution by 40%, keep everything the same across both modes.
Maybe some money exchanged hands which is why they are being so stubborn about it. I already see the comments shitting on UE5 when the base PS5 version didnt have these issues lol.
The issue isnt with UE5. Lets all use our brain and stick to TSR. You will get back more GPU and you can push resolution even more than 900p.
Devs need to realize that this is not a PS4 pro style upgrade, and they need to extract the most out of this 40-45% extra GPU performance. If you increase settings, you lose a good portion of that. If you use PSSR, you will lose a good portion of that. Then there are the memory costs of AI reconstruction. Do what Lords of the Fallen devs did, increase the resolution by 40%, keep everything the same across both modes.
Mister Wolf
Member
They should just enable TSR instead.
Zathalus
Member
While the implementation is pretty bad I don’t think the blame should entirely be placed on the developer. Multiple games with various different engines are having issues with PSSR. Even GT7 PSSR/RT mode has severe IQ issues, and that’s from one of the most talented developers at Sony.
It appears that PSSR is having problems with low resolution and/or issues with some forms of RT and that’s pretty much on Sony to improve. I hate to bring up DLSS again, but getting good results from that upscaler (as well as XeSS) is extremely easy to do, even for really bad developers.
It appears that PSSR is having problems with low resolution and/or issues with some forms of RT and that’s pretty much on Sony to improve. I hate to bring up DLSS again, but getting good results from that upscaler (as well as XeSS) is extremely easy to do, even for really bad developers.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Co-signed. High quality TSR is really good, really clean. Good in motion as well, unlike most implementations of FSR.
Last edited:
TerribleAtThisGame
Member
With this much horseshit going on, might as well go full PC-For-Dummies and put actual detailed options in the Graphics menu and let us choose ourselves what we want on and off. Some GAFer will find a better combo than them within 32 seconds.
James Sawyer Ford
Gold Member
Severe? Seriously dude, it does not
James Sawyer Ford
Gold Member
A dev has stated on era that many games are using very old pssr versions due to some weird sdk limitation
bundylove
Member
Then dont force it if it doesnt work
Is not forced. Both Horizon games do not use PSSR. They kept their upscaling tech and used the extra power for higher internal res and other effects.
Last edited:
bundylove
Member
we talk about silent hill here
You said don't force it if it doesn’t work. By that it looks you mean Sony is forcing PSSR on the devs. Hence my quote to your post.
bundylove
Member
Thats fair
There’s likely no ‘Sony is pressuring devs or that money has changed hands’. Anyone who has followed non DLSS upscalers over the last five years knows how hit and miss/outright negligent devs can be if they’re not dealing with Nvidia directly supporting DLSS integration.
Last edited:
Zathalus
Member
It absolutely does. Drive through some sort of tunnel and look at the dashboard (I was using a Mercedes SLR), it is extremely obvious that PSSR and RT is not mixing well. This is not a blink and you will miss it kind of thing, it’s right in your face. Outside of that specific scenario the PSSR/RT image is once again let down by stability issues, which is odd as the performance/PSSR mode is razor sharp.
Last edited:
So I was right. They switched back to TSR, but i need to know if they raise the base DRS range from the ps5 version.
Looking at the video, it seems like it because it is noticeable sharper to me. This will baffle me If this is a fixed resolution with TSR instead of raise the DRS range with the ps5 setting.
Can anyone with DF patron confirm regarding to resolutions on the new patch?
Zathalus
Member
Counted 1008 in a few areas for performance. Same DRS window as the base. Image quality vs the base PS5 is virtually identical. Performance is not much different either, a 2-3fps gap. Where the base drops to 49-51 fps the Pro drops to 50-53fps. Lumen GI on the Pro appears a bit lighter as well and the image is slightly altered. Not sure what’s going on there, it’s not a higher Lumen setting or anything. Oliver thinks it looks a bit worse.
Quality mode is unchanged, still same resolution and exact same PSSR resolve.
Last edited:
Gaiff
SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
So the DRS lower bound did raise. I am guessing 1008p to 864p. The outdoor and the beginning we see 1008p most often where the base ps5 drop to 864p.
Wait a minute. DF video on Silent Hill with Tom stating the pro was running from 1080p to 1620p and tend to stay at the higher DRS range with a few drop to 864p with the disc version, and the ps5 range is from 864p to 1152p. This is all over the places.
From what you have paraphrase here, Would it be better just delete the pro Version on the store let people play the base ps5 version? It sounded like a downgrade just for using the same TSR upscaler.
Bloober need to come out and comment on this lol. What are they even doing?
Edit: I missed the PSSR in the quality mode. So they are using 2 different upscalers in the game with 2 different modes?
Last edited:
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Sounds like a Bloober booger bug somewhere.
Played SH2 on my PS5 Pro (06 patch) - I was surprised to find that the quality mode is using hardware RT reflections (performance mode is using software RT reflections).
The quality of the hardware RT reflections is not very good, but it is still more than a visible improvement in some situations (will share comparison videos later).
What I also found is that the quality mode is using PSSR, but the performance mode is using TSR.
In both quality and performance modes the RTGI is software based, which is expected (as it is very expensive in hardware form - still need to check what improvements we have in UE5.5).
Dev from resetera. I guess Oliver couldn't spot it.
The quality of the hardware RT reflections is not very good, but it is still more than a visible improvement in some situations (will share comparison videos later).
What I also found is that the quality mode is using PSSR, but the performance mode is using TSR.
In both quality and performance modes the RTGI is software based, which is expected (as it is very expensive in hardware form - still need to check what improvements we have in UE5.5).
Dev from resetera. I guess Oliver couldn't spot it.
Zathalus
Member
Yep, 2 different upscalers. Honestly they should just remove PSSR until it gets an updated version and just focus on pushing that TSR res as high as possible. It’s a mess all around.
Mister Wolf
Member
I would love to see how Rebirth looks with UE4 TAAU instead of PSSR.